Does she sound like a senator?

Gillibrand's speech after being appointed to replace Hillary Clinton

A Siena poll out this week reported that only 29 percent of respondents said they would like to vote for Kirsten Gillibrand for US Senate in November -- 45 percent said they preferred someone else. That's a trend that's pretty much held steady since KG was appointed to replace Hillary Clinton a year ago.

So why don't voters seem to warming to Gillibrand? The NYO's Reid Pillifant recently offered a theory that was new to us: it's KG's speaking voice. From his Pillifant's piece:

"Kirsten Gillibrand has what I would call a non-regional American young female's accent," wrote Dr. Bert Vaux, a sociolinguistics scholar at the University of Cambridge, who was asked by The Observer to analyze Ms. Gillibrand's public speaking. "Though I lack the phonetic expertise to put my finger on what exactly is involved in this, her voice quality is of the sort that is typically associated with pre-workforce-age white American females. Judging by the case of this woman, this speech pattern has now extended into higher age ranges."

Pillifant goes on to note that Harold Ford is an excellent public speaker. Here's Ford speaking at a MLK Day event this week (with Gillibrand in the background).

We always thought the KG/Tracy Flick comparison was cheap and wrong. But we have to admit that when we watched her "accept" the appointment last January, we thought: "It kind of sounds like she's running for student body president."

A few other bits about Gillibrand/Ford after the jump.

+ That Siena poll also reported that Gillibrand registered her highest unfavorable rating (32 percent) of the past year. Even so, she leads Ford 41-17 in a hypothetical primary. She trails George Pataki 51-38 in a hypothetical general election matchup (Pataki hasn't said anything publicly about running).

+ Harold Ford announced this week that he's taking leave from his job at Bank of America Merrill Lynch so that he can, in the words of a spokesman, spend time "listening to New Yorkers and discussing his goals as an independent Democrat while he makes a final decision whether to run for Senate." [AP/NYT]


I could also argue that that's part of what makes her so liked by those that have actually met and had conversations with her. She's a very personable person, and very easy to talk to. Not in a George W Bush American Idiot kind of way. She's very intelligent, yet she sounds like an average person when she's talking to average people. I think her vocal quality has a lot to do with that.

Harold Ford, Jr. = Carpetbagger

How much was your Wall Street bonus this year?

Hillary Clinton = Carpetbagger

Why is it that Democrats who don't have good public speaking skills are referred to as "personable"?

It's nice to know some schmuck thinks we are that much of an unruly mob with a sheep mentaility, that it's Gillibrand's speech that is her undoing.

Why is Gillibrand unpopular?
1st, she was ALREADY unpopular with those left leaning wackadoodles who want laws for everything to fit their skewed moral compass, because she was laisez faire on many civil liberties. Which ANY politician should be

Then she became Sneator and changed...voted for Don't ask don't tell, the health care 'reform' bill (here's a tip, if it has a positive title in the is meant to screw you more) and even flipped her gun law stance. She has also became Schumer's lapdog...whatever he says she order to gain those NYC votes that she would have never gotten in the first place. However, if she remained constant to who she was and what she believes in, she'd have her dignity. She doesn't even have that anymore.

As for Ford being a great speaker? Why? That video didn't strike me as impressive, just a cliche of the 'preacher cadence' that many black politicians speak in, Martin Lawrence hams that speech pattern to death.

I also don't want Spitzer or any other of the Republicans I've heard on my Conservative side running either. We need a Libertarian or a Green party person to step up...and make history by showing that you don't have to be a Republicrat to win office.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Martin Luther King Jr. Day events 2018

Monday is Martin Luther King Jr. Day and there are celebrations and commemorations all around the area this weekend. Here's a handful of them...... (more)

Midday music break: bell's roar

Check it out: bell's roar has a new album out today, We Carry Us. There's a track from it -- "Celebrate" -- embedded above.... (more)

How old?

A sort of tangent to that map of Albany mayor homes since the Civil War... The city of Albany publishes an inventory of residential buildings... (more)

Stuff to do this weekend

Welcome to our weekly look at stuff to do this weekend, cleverly titled, Stuff to Do This Weekend. After the jump, a few things we... (more)

Morning Blend

Guilty plea in fatal Washington Park hit-and-run Jose Martinez -- accused of hitting Rajine Martinez while she was in a road in Washington Park last... (more)

Recent Comments

This is potentially good news for St. Josephs. I walk around it 2 or 3 times a week and the last few years the deterioration has seemed to accelerate. She will be looking right at it everyday from her front windows.

The week ahead

...has 3 comments, most recently from Greg

How old?

...has 4 comments, most recently from chrisck

Where every Albany mayor since the Civil War has lived

...has 8 comments, most recently from james

James Baldwin Celebration at UAlbany

...has 1 comment, most recently from Kathy Pakay

Stuff to do this weekend

...has 1 comment, most recently from Cf