Reaction to the legislative assault on salt

salt shaker

All this should probably taken with a grain of... well... you know.

As you might have heard, state assemblyman Felix Ortiz (D-Brooklyn) has proposed a bill that would ban restaurants from using salt in the preparation of food.

That hasn't exactly gone over well. A quick spin around the table for reaction after the jump.

Also: a scan of Ortiz's other fun-filled legislation.

The reaction

The Center for Consumer Freedom, an industry-backed group that's "devoted to promoting personal responsibility and protecting consumer choices," appears to have been the first to yell about the Ortiz bill (it is their job, after all). CFCF calls the measure an "absurdist bill" and says Ortiz has "single-handedly insulted the intelligence of the entire state."

Following the tip from CFCF, Katherine Mangu-Ward from Reason -- the libertarian mag -- noted with sarcasm that the bill's $1000 fine for using salt was "totally proportionate and reasonable." She also called the bill "the ravings of a madman in legislative form."

Chore Sicha at The Awl: "[the bill] is off to the Committee on Health, where they are going to laugh and laugh and roll around on the floor and laugh some more before deep-sixing it in some filing cabinet somewhere." (Also, he found a great accompanying photo.)

Steve Barnes called the measure "a deeply misguided gesture that is also an abuse of the legislative process" and tagged it as "a nanny-state bill." Steve goes on to lay out the culinary and scientific basis for using salt in cooking (it's good stuff -- go read it).

The Center of Science in Public Interest's Michael Jacobson (pretty much the mortal enemy of the Consumer Freedom group) criticized the bill in National Restaurant News: "Limiting sodium requires more a scalpel than a meat axe."

The Village Voice's Rebecca Marx calls the bill "the kind of sadly deranged move that could have made only by someone whose electrolytes are hopelessly out of whack."

NYT commenter stanford mcstanihan: "Good idea. While we're at it, why not ban all the things that can potentially be used to excess and lead to death. I'm sure the list would be small. Prohibition's where it's at yo!"

Famed chef Eric Ripert to NYDN: "There are zero dishes I prepare that have no salt at all."

Daniel Maurer at NY Mag's Grub Street: "maybe chefs shouldn't even bother cooking and we should just have microwaves at every table."

The Atlantic's Max Fisher says Ortiz's bill is a good idea: "Bottom line, I doubt he really wants to ban salt. But he does want to get people thinking about salt as a health danger, which he's accomplished, and maybe to inspire a reduction in salt consumption."

OK, so who is this Ortiz guy?

Curious about who would actually float a bill like this, we took a look at the other legislation sponsored by Felix Ortiz. Among the bills:

That's only a slice of Ortiz's slate. Many of his bills look like they could be good ideas and are probably well-intentioned. But after reading through the list, we kind of get the sense that Felix Ortiz is the buzzkill at all the Assembly keggers.

photo: Flickr user Ingorrr

Comments

Two things you NEVER tax or ban: sugar and salt.

Looking at that list of legislation by Ortiz just makes me wonder, "doesn't he have anything better to do?"

Local restaurants should keep an eye out for Ortiz and serve him and his flunkies saltless meals.

Ugh. I seriously am starting to feel like I had more freedom in Russia. I may have to go back.

As a former long-time resident of the Salt City, I'm deeply offended. I hope Syracuse's representatives give him a good shaking.

This worked really well in India too.

"But after reading through the list, we kind of get the sense that Felix Ortiz is the buzzkill at all the Assembly keggers."

Please please PLEASE make this the comment of the week! So funny!!!

Ellen, I just posted that comment to my Facebook page along with the link to this story - it is definitely a great comment and probably so true!!

Ortiz should quit this grandstanding nonsense and work on the budget.

Every time one of these clowns proposes a nutty bill like this, the folks at DOH get to spend a month banging their heads on their desks evaluating the "potential impacts", even though most of them want to respond with "are you f-ing kidding me?"

the derision for the concept of the "nanny state" is part of the virulent underlying sexism of modern western culture. the idea that the maternal role is not a suitable one for government to take is absurd. that said, this salt thing is probably more paternal (punishment, post-event correction) than maternal (guidance, care for others). the solution is not to make it illegal to have salt in foods but to make it illegal to feed your children poor diets. it is just as much an act of child abuse to raise someone on mcdonald's as it is to hit them with a rolled up newspaper.

slavery is no longer acceptable in america unless you produce those slaves with your own body and they are under 18. children are the next political group that needs emancipation. if you haven't met a 16 year old smarter than most adults you know, you aren't talking to many 16 year olds.

Here's the conflict with the State and their excuse of putting a tax on salt use and a tax on sugar (i.e. soda) as a way of making us healthier and doing us a "favor," they're also proposing taxes on gym memberships and they're cutting back on school aid which will undoubtedly come out of athletics and phys. ed programs. They're making it more expensive to get licenses for outdoor activities and they're trying to close our state parks where people go to be outdoors and play outside. Will those things make our kids healthier?

NYS is trying to earn money, plain and simple, and they're desperate. Having a gov't that wants its hands in on every little decision that's made in the private sector is another problem, but it needs to be addressed sooner rather than later.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

10x10: Casinos, John Oliver, new spots

A while back we did a thing where wrote 10 reviews/comments in no more than 10 words each. People seemed to like it, and it... (more)

Holiday gifts: Deanna Fox

Gifts and giving are on most everyone's mind this month. So we thought we'd ask a few people to share some thoughts on presents, past... (more)

NY Thruway Guide

Might be worth a look: NY Thruway Guide, an iPhone app that's pretty much what it sounds like. It provides access to the lineup of... (more)

Stuff to do this weekend

There's lots going on the the Capital Region this weekend -- both holiday and non-holiday. So if you're looking to take a break from all... (more)

Morning Blend

The body of 5-year-old Kenneth White was found by a K-9 unit near the home where he had been staying in East Berne, according to... (more)

Recent Comments

... I tend to ask questions that make the person think about what they just said. I ask it sweetly and in a tone that notes confusion on my part. I have been called honey in the office and asked the person, " Can I ask what you mean when you call me honey? Because you don't call John honey." It calls out that he's treating you differently for being a woman. If he still doesn't get it, you can be more direct: "I appreciate that you respect my work and treat me equally, but I wouldn't want others to think otherwise based on how you address me."

Capital Region high school graduation rates 2014

...has 2 comments, most recently from Greg

NY Thruway Guide

...has 1 comment, most recently from Rob

Good neighborhood holiday light displays?

...has 4 comments, most recently from MikeH

Where to get latkes?

...has 14 comments, most recently from Susan Anthony Brownell

Stuff to do this weekend

...has 1 comment, most recently from Seneca