Why I didn't vote last Tuesday

albany county ballot 2011-11-08

By Jennifer O'Connor

soapbox badgeTuesday was, of course, Election Day -- and for the third time in 12 years, I did not vote.

The first time I didn't vote was 1999. I turned 18 on October 3, was a freshman in college and was overwhelmed and misinformed about where to vote. The second time was in 2003. I had just moved to a new town and registered when changing my drivers license. The registration was never processed.

But this year, my absence from the polls was an active choice.

I'm registered at the address where I've lived since 2006, and my polling place is across the street. But, nearly every race for voters in Albany's 11th Ward (all but three, actually) was uncontested. I'm not talking about the "typical Albany" politics where there may be a Republican, or a third party, running that no one really takes seriously and has no shot of actually winning. No. Completely uncontested. The only candidate on the ballot.

I didn't vote last week, not because I didn't like my choices, but because I didn't really have a choice. As AOA stated on Wednesday, "voting for voting's sake is hollow." I didn't inherently have a problem with the candidates running. I avidly supported Chris Higgins in his 2007 bid for County Legislator for Albany County's 6th District. I don't know that much about Dan McCoy other than I know Chris avidly supported him. This in itself wouldn't make me vote blindly, but would factor into my decision. I would have been more likely to go and vote "none of the above," or write a candidate, if the candidates running unopposed were ones that I felt did not represent my values.

The Republicans have been pouring money and effort into races they think they can win, and I cannot argue with that stance. I was a little surprised (and disappointed) that the Green Party was not out and about, but they too have limited resources. I am wholly and completely frustrated with the rest of the "third party" lines in New York (Conservative, Working Families, Independence), who simply choose their favorite from the Big Two choices. These parties have means and a voter base to make a difference at the local level, and they choose not to do it.

I'm still grappling with my decision. I hate the level of voter apathy in this country, although I do understand it and I do sympathize with the frustration. Yesterday, I contributed to that apathy, and though voting for the sake of voting isn't much better, at least those who voted showed up, where I didn't. I took the rights my foremothers fought for and earned for me in 1920 and tossed it in the trash heap.

How do we solve this? It is easy to say that we should encourage more people to run for office, when in reality the solution is not that simple. I think it starts at a much smaller, much more local level. Do we read the local news every day? Have we made an effort to meet our representatives? Do we attend City Council meetings and contribute to the discussion? Do we contact our representatives - at all levels of government - when they're poised to make a decision on something that matters? I don't do as much of this as I should, though I try stay abreast of the issues and to speak up when it matters.

While I can't really blame one person (or one group of people) for the lack of choice in this year's local election, I can and do blame all of us, including myself. Our civic responsibility does not start and end with Election Day. If we want more choices and better candidates, we need to start speaking up and paying attention.

Comments

What do a handful of uncontested races have to do with the decision to not vote in the heavily contested judicial and school board seats?

Write-in?

My mother always submitted a write in vote for Mother Theresa when she didn't like the choices.

Judicial race and school board are pretty important, you can always vote on only some of the races and leave the uncontested ones blank.

Sad thing is, I heard people boasting about the fact that Albany is really a single party city. I've lived in a single party country before (former USSR). It's not democracy. It's not good for anyone. It's not America. It's sad. And anyone who'd boast is clueless about what true liberty, freedom, and democracy are all about.

Wish I had a solution, but my decision was not to live in Albany.

I strongly agree with the sentiment that civic responsibility must extend past election day. However, I can't support the statement "voting for voting's sake is hollow."

It is our duty to vote. We must be engaged in our government and voting is the least we can do. I was disappointed that I didn't have choices to make on Election Day. But casting my ballot is my way of saying "I am here and I am paying attention." If we don't express our opinion when formally asked, I am afraid the government may stop asking. That is why I go out of my way to cast my ballot in every national, state, local, school budget, and library budget vote. I am casting my vote for the right to continue to vote in the future.


I'm also curious why you thought that the contested supreme court and school board elections weren't important.

I wonder if it would make a difference if they added a line for "none of the above" - and if those numbers outweighed the candidates, they'd have to have another election. Costly? Maybe at first...but in time I bet we'd start seeing better candidates.

I did not cast a vote in any race with only one candidate. McCoy will have to earn my vote in the future. I made a point of voting in the school board race to vote against the pro-charter school candidate, who was an incumbent. And she lost so casting that vote was worth it.

"I'm also curious why you thought that the contested supreme court and school board elections weren't important. "

I third this sentiment.

I think there is a difference between voter apathy and intentional ignorance. Please don't take offense; it's not meant as a slight on you personally. However, there are those for whom the process has made them so jaded towards local elections that it's easier - emotionally and otherwise - to simply not vote and justify it with an argument such as the one you presented.

It creates two problems. One is that those contested races get ignored as well, which you either left off this post or simply didn't know about. The other is that it continues the cycle. The worst result of an uncontested race isn't that it occurs, it's that it instills the sort of attitude seen here that perpetuates further uncontested races.

There are other ways to make your voice heard. Find write-in candidates. Organize. Find out why these races are uncontested. Perhaps, even, run yourself, or if you're not into that, encourage someone else you know to run. And encourage them to do it outside of the machine in Albany.

Also, food for thought and something I'm genuinely curious about: why does this happen in a city as big as Albany yet in municipalities much smaller in size and scale - ie Saratoga Springs and Troy - equivalent races are not only contested but competitive?

There are many options when you don't like the choices - We've had historic wins in Albany, NY with write in campaigns in recent memory.

If you don't like any of the choices, walk in and leave it blank. I've done that with plenty of candidates I hadn't heard of or issues I didn't get a chance to research. But it's my job to show up.

I agree with LB, there was a lot of other issues that needed to be voted on.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.

Search

Recently on All Over Albany

The Capital Region's home ownership rate ticked upward last year for the first time in a while

Another few bits for the apartments / rents discussion... The home ownership rate in the Albany-Schenectady-Troy metro area ticked upward for the first time since... (more)

Stuff to do this weekend

Welcome to summer. Have a lemonade and some freshly-picked stuff to do. There's baseball, strawberries, jazz, wine ... all kinds of fun things to make... (more)

Dog poop is a universal issue

One of the bits from this Ian Bogost article about the topics that frequently pop up on Nextdoor: The dog-pop-in-other-people's-trash-cans issue is everywhere and all... (more)

No. No. No. No. No. No. No.

Tucked in at the end of a state Department of Environmental Conservation digest of agency police officer encounters -- titled "Strange Rattle in the Engine... (more)

Here's the design of that Henry Johnson commemorative medallion

Here's that how that coin-shaped medallion to honor Henry Johnson turned out. It will debut at a free event at The Palace June 27 at... (more)

Recent Comments

Troy has way more parking downtown than any other city I visit. There are 3 parking garages downtown and 2 are within 1000ft of Monument Square. There are public surface lots nearby. Outside the downtown core there is tons of street parking with few to no restrictions. It is unrealistic to expect cities to have parking directly in front of your destination like the suburbs. That's WHY they're different classifications.

No. No. No. No. No. No. No.

...has 2 comments, most recently from Ellen

Albany City Hall carillon concerts

...has 1 comment, most recently from Tim

Where to take foreign language classes

...has 6 comments, most recently from BrĂ­d

Five takeaways from the start of the fifth major effort to redevelop 1 Monument Square

...has 9 comments, most recently from RedBarron

Morning Blend for Jun 20

...has 1 comment, most recently from ace