What would you call a New York State without New York?

new york map broken in three parts question

Hudson?

Today's (more than) somewhat ridiculous question: If New York City and the rest of the state divorced, what would you call the rest of the state?

This question came up during a conversation recently (obviously a very serious discussion). It was quickly decided that New York City would retain the name New York State. But what about parts upstate?

And would "upstate" even decide to stay together? We could see Upstate West and Upstate East also deciding it wasn't worth it to stay together. (It's a pop/soda thing.)

Yes, all very important questions.

Long Island: We're just assuming that Long Island would stay with NYC -- but a few years back there was legislation introduced proposing a study of possible Long Island secession. (insert your own joke here)

Comments

Upstate America (h/t to Jimmy Vielkind for coining the phrase)

If New York City and the rest of the state divorced, which part would get legal custody of New Jersey?

Vermont is Green Mountains, New Hampshire from Hampshire, England, Massachusetts from the Native American words for "Great Hills" or "Many hills", and New Jersey from an English channel island, which leaves us with a general idea of where our name should derive from, our ancestry or geographical features. Considering there are 3 major areas of "New York East", the Adirondacks, The Capital District, and Catskills (Appalachian) Mountains it would be very difficult to find one common thread to tie the 3 together. In that case, I think Hudson may be most fitting. Otherwise we left trying to fit together the Dutch, English, French and Native American influences. So my choice is Hudson.

@katherine: Upstate American might work as a country -- but I'm not sure about the State of Upstate America.

@Bob: I think New Jersey gets shipped off to boarding school.

@Joe: Yeah, it's hard to pick some geographic feature to represent the whole state. I don't think using one of the mountain names would work for the rest of the state.

I like where Joe was going - New Hudsonland for the part above NYC. And, for the western section. Maybe - Syrochaloton? (Syracuse - Rochester-Buffalo-Binghamton)

Hudsonia and North Pennsylvania.

@Danielle: When Richard Florida was here a few years back he talked about how Buffalo, Rochester and Toronto were becoming an interconnected region -- which he then called TorBuffChester.

Canada.

Upstate would be "North New York" - like North and South Dakota/Carolina

West Vermont.

the obvious answer is New Amsterdam.

I'd go with "Niagara" and "Hudson."

Enlarged Beverwyck.It's a name that has everything.

Lucky?

Watertopia?

New Canada?

The Land That Pizza Forgot?

Newer York?

Fracklandia?

The Shire?

If needed, we could go back to the old name: New Netherland.

Albania!

@Paul - don't you mean "Smallbania"?

:D

Can't think of a good name otherwise, but I like the idea of NYC being kicked out. Can we just cut it off from the mainland and push it out to sea?

Romneyville

No way, uh-uh -- why do THEY get to keep the name and not the whole huge rest of New York? No way. WE get to be New York. THEY can be the state of Long Island (since that'd be the majority of its geography anyway).

No WAY. If New York City and Long Island were to become their own state, we get to keep the New York title by virtue of sheer numbers. They can be collectively called Starbuckia.

Shmew Shmork
The State Formerly Known as New York
East York/West York
Voorheesville
Erie and Hudson

Home.

Alabama.

Pennsylvania. Just Pennsylvania.

If we named it after Wegmans do you think they would finally come?

"If New York City and Long Island were to become their own state, we get to keep the New York title by virtue of sheer numbers."

Ummm...NYC + LI + Westchester/Rockland make up 63.5% of the population of New York State. So if you mean sheer numbers of residents, we lose.

New Amsterdam is good for the European angle. But what about something to go with the area's rich Indian history, Iroquois, Mohican, Mohawk? I'm sure someone really knowledgeable in the field could come up with something good.

Poor

New New Amsterwyk

CANADA

I say that the Upstaters should get to keep New York and that New York City, Long Island, and let's be honest, Westchester should just call themselves Long Island.
I like Hudson, but it sounds kind of odd as a state name. Maybe go back to our roots as a Dutch colony and call ourselves New Amsterdam or New Netherlands?

The-state-that-used-to-be-New-York-State-but-isn't-anymore-because-New-York-City-is-now-New-York-State-and-we've-lost-our-identity-and-we-haven't-come-up-with-a-name-yet.

There's also...

TBD

and

We could use a symbol like Prince did years ago.

New New Amsterdam

Hudson for upstate and Erie for the west.

Catirondacks or Catirondacia (using Joe's reasoning)

Roosevelt. One name to represent 3 significant historic figures.

Western NY would be a mix of finger lakes and the two great lakes. so some play on lakes would be a way to go. Probably naming it after a finger lake would be too much, or after a grape.

Eastern NY has two historic mountain ranges and two famous river valleys.

Maybe we can give Benedict Arnold his due and call it Benedictia.
How about Schuyler. I kind of like Schuyler

Any concatenation would be protested by at least one of the groups

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Happy Thanksgiving!

Happy Thanksgiving! We hope you get a chance to relax and spend some time with family and friends. Also: Maybe eat some pie. Because pie... (more)

Capital Region holiday markets 2017

The unofficial official holiday shopping season starts up Friday. If you're looking for something a little bit different -- craftier, handmade, more independent, fair trade... (more)

What's up in the Neighborhood

Among the topics in this most recent spin around the Capital Region's online neighborhood: old signs, public baths, mountain biking, hiking, new woods, the Adirondack... (more)

Tracking the paths of many steps

Maybe you've seen this heat map of activity posted by the exercise tracking service Strava. It basically shows the most popular routes taken by people... (more)

Morning Blend

Accused shooter in Albany death arrested, and dies later in the day Albany police announced Tuesday that they had arrested Taron Robinson, who was accused... (more)

Recent Comments

I'm glad to see people involved in community decisions. But at the same time, we can't just keep saying we want development "somewhere else" or "not in my backyard!". Having mini-suburbs in the city of Albany was feasible at one point in time, and now development is catching up. ...

Albany Book & Paper Fair 2017

...has 1 comment, most recently from Richard Adamiak Ph.D.

Morning Blend for Nov 22

...has 1 comment, most recently from Gabby

As it turns out, Tucker Carlson's understanding of Albany demographics is lacking

...has 18 comments, most recently from -B

Private dorm opposition, a big downtown residential conversion, and other exciting tales of the Albany Planning Board

...has 7 comments, most recently from daleyplanit

Here's every violation issued by the city of Albany over the last three winters for not shoveling a sidewalk

...has 6 comments, most recently from Harriet