Moxie's is more than plain vanilla

moxies exterior

By Casey Normile

The first batch of Mexican vanilla ice cream that Moxie's ever made was technically illegal.

"But only a little illegal," Pamela Allie-Morrill explains. Ms. Pam, as she likes to be called, is the daughter of the eponymous Mohamed "Moxie" Allie -- she now runs the ice cream stand in Wynantskill. She says that original supply of Mexican vanilla hitched a ride into this country in her cousin's suitcase. It wasn't exactly an act of smuggling.

That Mexican vanilla has since been replaced with Mexican vanilla sourced via Illinois. But it's still an integral part of Moxie's Around the World of Vanilla -- a solar system of vanilla ice creams in a dish that surround Moxie's signature flavor, Blue Moon.

So, why vanilla? Pam says it's simple -- it was the most readily available flavor when she was looking to make her mark on Moxie's eleven years ago. And the vanilla sampler has been a popular staple at the stand ever since.

moxies vanilla tour

Here's how the tour shapes up:

+ It starts with the Haitian vanilla, which Pam got from a Haitian missionary ten years ago. It's a little bit sweeter than your average vanilla.
+ Your next stop is the Indonesian vanilla, which is commonly used for baking, so it will taste a little familiar.
+ Then follows the infamous Mexican vanilla. It has a slight spice to it, almost cinnamon-y.
+ The Tahitian vanilla is next. It has a hint of cherry to it, but that's not because there's any cherry in the ice cream, that's just how the bean finishes.
+ Then there's Venetian vanilla -- it's the only vanilla that is a flavor instead of a bean extract. In case you're a purist, it's the golden yellow scoop you want to avoid.
+ And to provide comparison, Moxie's also throws in a scoop of "regular" (Madagascar) vanilla.
+ To cleanse the palate, you get a bottle of Moxie's very own bottled water -- and a scoop of Blue Moon.

What is Blue Moon, you ask?

It's a flavor that Pam's brother found at food festival when he was 12 and Moxie's has carried it ever since. She says it's a popular flavor in the Midwest; but on the East Coast, it's basically unheard of.

"It tastes different to everyone and we've heard it all," said Pam, "It tastes like wedding cake, lemon, frosting, bubble gum. One woman even tried to say she tasted a hint of burnt almond; that was way off."

moxies flavor board

The only downside to taking the vanilla tour is that it might not leave room for you to sample Moxie's more exotic flavors like Cajun strawberry or sunflower. So plan accordingly.

moxies walk in freezerMoxie's has 79 flavors in their repertoire. Yes, they have chocolate, coffee, and strawberry. But they also have flavors such as blueberry lavender, cajun chocolate peanut butter, and chai tea. So the only sensible thing to do to try as many of these flavors as possible is to pair them. Pam herself never eats two scoops of just one type of ice cream. Her suggestions? Blueberry and mojito go well together, or nutmeg and Cajun Haitian vanilla (a pretzel cone is best for this pairing).

The repertoire of flavors has expanded over decades. Pam says they haven't really retired any of their flavors -- even the less popular licorice.

moxie's ice cream machine
Moxie's ice cream machine.

Another odd part of Moxie's history: Mohamed Allie never wanted to sell ice cream. He wanted to open a restaurant and work with his real love, burgers. But he sort of inherited the ice cream parlor along with his Wynantskill building and landed in the world of dessert. The adjacent restaurant ended up closing, but they've been selling ice cream there for 43 years. Along the way, Moxie and Pam even trained at the renowned Penn State ice cream course.

It seems to have paid off. Though Moxie still hasn't quite grown to love ice cream yet, their shop has built a reputation for good ice cream, interesting flavors, and natural ingredients.

"But I'm not famous," says Moxie, "I'm just little old me, running a little old ice cream shop."

Pamela Allie-Morrill and Mohamed Allie
Pam and Moxie

And when Pam isn't spending her summers helping her dad run the shop, she's living in El Salvador with her husband. There she meets people from all over the world. And one of her first questions usually is: "What's your favorite kind of ice cream?"

What brings her back to Wynantskill every summer is her dad, their shop, and their customers. "I like making ice cream and I love making it with my dad. I love looking out the back window every summer and seeing every picnic table full. It warms my heart to see kids running around the playground, from the truck to train screaming 'All aboard!' I just love that."

Find It

1344 Spring Ave
Wynantskill, NY 12198

(518) 283-4901


I did the around the world vanilla tour at Moxie's on Daniel B.'s hard ice cream tour and it was one of the highlights of the day. The gal working there kindly left the blue moon out at my request (btw, we saw that Blue Moon at more than just Moxie's on that tour) and forgot exactly which vanilla was which by the time she had scooped them all. It didn't matter, though, I had fun trying them and they were all really good for different reasons. That alone is worth the trip to Moxie's.

As a Poestenkill native, I grew up on Moxie's ice cream and can attest that it is delicious! Personally, I think Blue Moon tastes like fruit loops.

Moxie's is the best!

I've heard Moxie's sells vegan ice cream, does anyone know if this is a daily thing or only on certain days?

I think that without a doubt Moxie's has some of the best ice cream in the area. I do not feel that you get any value in their product. I know that they make an artisan type ice cream but $2.35 for a single very small scoop just doesn't cut it.

Moxies has vegan ice cream. So does the Peanut Principle.

My fave ice cream bar none. Eating this ruins my palate for store-bought ice cream. Sure other ice creams are cheaper, but they're not the real deal like Moxie's.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

The week ahead

Here are a few things to keep in mind, look forward to, or keep busy with this week, from the weather (hope for spring), to... (more)

40th Annual Photo Regional at Opalka Gallery

The 40th Annual Photo Regional -- titled Effects That Aren't Special -- opened this week at the Opalka Gallery on the Sage Albany campus. This... (more)

New owner for Madison Theater

Over at the Saint Rose Chronicle, Jackson Murphy reports that the next owner of the Madison Theater in Albany will be Cosmic Cinemas, a new... (more)

787 is sticking around for a long time, but if you want to change it the time to start is now

Let's just get right to the point most people want to hear about: The new draft of the I-787/Hudson Waterfront Corridor Study doesn't lay out... (more)

NYS Writers Institute: Trolley

Check it out: The NYS Writers Institute has started a new online journal called Trolley. It's a magazine of "of essay, opinion, literature, culture, and... (more)

Recent Comments

I applaud these future leaders of America. Keep speaking up and go vote! So proud of this generation.

Studying the future direction of Washington Ave

...has 11 comments, most recently from PK

Legs Diamond and The Kenmore Hotel

...has 18 comments, most recently from Chip lowery

New owner for Madison Theater

...has 3 comments, most recently from JulieA

Photos from the Albany High School walkout, and talking with the student organizers

...has 9 comments, most recently from Mike

Move Music Festival 2018

...has 1 comment, most recently from Jeff D