Surveying the hot food at Stewart's


By Casey Normile

Stewart's is a local favorite, of course. Whenever you see their famous maroon and white signs, you know there's a place to get a cup of coffee, a buttered hard roll, snacks, or ice cream.

But a part of the Stewart's lineup I had never tried was their spinning shelves of hot food -- things like the eggwich, hamburger, and... pizza.

So I decided to try it.

This was what was available in the case during two recent trips to Stewart's. The full lineup of hot food is more extensive.

The Eggwich - $3.99


Pros: It'll fill you up if you have a long drive ahead of you. But the idea of this one made me a little nervous. Sometimes egg sandwiches can just taste like, well, floppy-patty cheese sandwiches. But the one I found was on an everything bagel, which easily adds flavor, and the egg actually tasted like egg, which was encouraging.

Cons: The bagel isn't toasted. And the only options are bacon egg and cheese, sausage egg and cheese, or ham egg and cheese. For those who don't want a meaty breakfast, you'll have to take it off or choose something else. It does fill you up, but you also get that heavy feeling in your stomach about 20 minutes later when your stomach realizes what just happened.

The Egg Wrap - $.99


Pros: This particular wrap was sausage, egg, and cheese. A little snack of protein for only 99 cents! Plus, if you eat and drive, having your meal in wrap form makes it easy. One hand on the wheel, one hand holding your tiny breakfast.

Cons: There's something unsettling about eating sausage that has been spinning in a case. Even the girl behind the counter seemed surprised I had chosen to buy this particular item.

Make Your Own Deli Dog - $1.60


Pros: It's a piping-hot hot dog that you can fix yourself, exactly the way you like it. They offer everything you should need for your dog; not just ketchup and mustard, but also relish, onions, hot sauce, and meat sauce. There aren't a lot of places that offer that many condiment options. And it's the same price no matter what you put on the dog.

Speaking of options: in addition to the regular hot dog, Stewart's also offers a "Cajun" dog and kielbasa.

Cons: The bun we sampled was a little stale. But the major problem was the packaging. You spend all this time crafting your dog the way you want it just to shove it into the little bag, smearing your intricate ketchup work.

The Hamburger - $1.99


Pros: It's $1.99 and it's a basic burger -- the kind you'd eat at a large family reunion. It has the essentials: fresh bun, fully-cooked patty, and melty cheese. And, just to mix things up, they offer cheese, bacon, or a double burger.

You might say, "Well, I can get a burger on the road anywhere." But I would argue that you can get it here with chili and some ice cream while your friend or family member pumps gas outside. That's convenience.

Cons: It's exactly what you'd expect from a $1.99 burger. As is always the risk with fast food burgers, it's not like the pictures. The bun was flat, the burger was small, and the edges were a little strange -- jagged, like a cartoon explosion shape.

The Meatball Sub - $3.49


Pros: This is a meatball sub... that you can get on the road... for only $3.49. That alone seems like a pretty good deal. As I watched the shelves spin in the case, I was surprised to find this sub among the usual suspects. The bun was fresh and the sandwich was warm (not hot). Overall, a good roadside find.

Cons: The sub wasn't covered in melted cheese and smothered in sauce like a more hearty meatball sub would be, but rather with a light layer of sauce. So after you finish the sandwich you didn't get that exciting "it was so delicious I feel guilty" feeling, but more of an "I just ate three meatballs in a bun" feeling.

The Chicken Sandwich - $3.99


Pros: Now, the hot sandwich we bought was a honey mustard chicken sandwich. But it doesn't stop there. You can also get barbecue rib subs and sausage and peppers. Again, roadside options are important. It comes on a nice, fresh Kaiser roll and it wasn't just a round, flat chicken patty. There was a nice, plump chicken tender in there.

Cons: The honey mustard part of this sandwich was just that, a squirt of honey mustard inside. The dressing is good and the chicken is good, but after you take it out of the container you get this distinct "So I guess this is what I'm eating" feeling.

The Pizza - $1.69 a slice or $8.99 for the whole pie


Pros: It's their newest offering and they seem excited about it. You can buy it by the slice or get the whole pizza. They'll throw a slice in the oven for you so it warms while they ring you out. It's doughy, but with just the right amount of cheese and sauce and the crust was surprisingly crunchy. I was expecting it to taste like frozen pizza they simply heated up, but it didn't.

They only offer cheese and pepperoni, but that seems reasonable. If you want a Buffalo chicken pizza, you can wait until you get home to order it.

Cons: It comes on a paper plate. If you're eating it in the shop, that's one thing, but walking out the shop into the cold with a paper plate, putting it in your passenger seat like a fragile gift, and then driving home to eat it seems kind of sad -- like getting a piece of cake at a birthday party and immediately taking it home to eat it alone.

Pick one...

If I had to pick one thing to grab on the road, it would be the meatball sub. The bun was fresh, it was cheap, and it doesn't leave a heavy feeling in your stomach.

The best part of this experience was piling an entire case of prepared food onto the counter and seeing the cashier's face. She seemed surprised, but quickly covered it up and rang me out.

So I suppose not a lot of people come to Stewart's to grab dinner for their entire family that often. But overall, their hot food selection is kind of like finding a baseball field concession stand on the road. There's probably something you crave. It's convenient. And the price is decent.


Mr. Dave -- a Stewart's aficionado if ever there was one -- recently tried the Stewart's pizza.


wow Casey that's really taking one for the team. All of those food-like items look disgusting!

Your poor stomach.

Nobody goes to Stewart's for the hamburgers.

Read this wondering why anyone would subject themselves to these things. Then I read { you get this distinct "So I guess this is what I'm eating" feeling } and just burst out laughing. Thank you.

It all looks like a petrie dish of ptomaine poisoning to me.

Ketchup on a hot dog?! FOR SHAME!
Also, eggwiches rock. I've only had them on the hard roll though. Something about that circular bacon is truly magical.

You're not required to rewrap the hot dog into the bag. Take a plate if you have a load of toppings on there, or just eat it there.

I never understood why places like this sell hamburgers. You could easily go to McD's or BK for one at the same price, only fresher and tastier.

I still wish there were Stewart's in Western NY. We now have 7-11 out here and they aren't as good as Stewart's.

Honestly, their chili is the safest bet for a semi-healthy grab and go Stewarts lunch. It's pretty basic with beans, veggies & beef (?) in a tomato base. You can spice it up with hot sauce or chopped onions and you don't feel gross after eating it since it isn't the leat bit greasy.

I agree with Kay. Chili and ice cream is the way to go at Stewart's!

I tried the Eggwich once. The bagel was stale and so huge that you got many bites of bagel without any cheese or meat. I don't recommend it.

I was going to write something about bravely taking one for the team... but I eat a hot Stewart's meal in Altamont every Wednesday before band practice. For some reason you skipped the BBQ rib sandwich. It's like the frozen hot chocolate at Serendipity. Genre defining.

For maximum Stewart's value, may I recommend filling the hot dog tray with meat sauce, ketchup, and onions (aka Stewart's chili) and sliding it back in the sleeve, then dressing a dogger and placing on top of the seemingly empty sleeve. For around 3 bucks you get two loaded dogs AND two concealed cardboard boats filled with barely edible chili muck. When American's talk about "Values", this is what they're referring to.

No peanut butter & jelly on a hard roll? No Perk-Up? No Cola? Not even a sip of Stewart's Mountain Brew Beer Ice? Or a sip of their newest concoction, Stewart's Impact? You leave so much to be desired...Amateur!

Stewart's ice-cream is really awful. I can't believe the locals can eat that crap.

I will confess to enjoying the occasional sausage, egg and cheese on a hard roll from the warm, spinny thing. But you're a far braver soul than I, venturing into the non- breakfast food items.

The breakfast sandwiches are not bad! I know I've seen egg and cheese sandwiches at Stewarts without meat in the past... so those do exist.

Also, Stewarts has one thing in particular that I love that no one else seems to understand. A roll with Peanut Butter and Butter. It's so commonly found at Stewarts that they even have a special sticker for the plastic wrapper! An untoasted roll with only PB is too dry! If the roll is going to be untoasted, (and you don't want jelly), it needs both 'PB&B'!

The ham, egg and cheese on a hard roll from the spinny thing are NOT bad for a ready to eat bfast sammy. Plus, they're huge!

I still avoid Stewarts; limited cold beverage selection, bad hot dogs and they were the last gas stations to offer pay at the pump. How dare they value my "forced" visits inside the store more than my time and convenience.

Stewarts hot food is surprisingly good and cheap. They will make sandwiches for you while you wait. Try the Roast Beef and Cheese with Horseradish sauce. Awesome...and 3.99 for a huge sandwich.

The burgers are surprisingly good too...for 1.99 for a Quarter Pound of Beef...not bad.

And their breakfast sandwiches are better than Dunkin Donuts...and are cheaper and bigger too.

Stewart's hot dogs are one of my minor life joys. Super tasty and cheap. Tons of condiments. Totally underrated.

The meat tastes like kangaroo meat. Absolutely nasty

OMG the eggwich on a hard roll rocks!!!!!

My only issues with Stewart's Hot Dogs:

1. Going from steaming to the roller grill. Just not as good.

2. Toppings- you can go in one time & find a full selection, and then go back & find a teaspoon of old chopped onion, one bottle of mustard, and meat sauce with a crust on the top. It's a crapshoot.

Hi there. Comments have been closed for this item. Still have something to say? Contact us.

The Scoop

For a decade All Over Albany was a place for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. It was kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who could help you find out what's up. AOA stopped publishing at the end of 2018.

Recently on All Over Albany

Thank you!

When we started AOA a decade ago we had no idea what was going to happen. And it turned out better than we could have... (more)

Let's stay in touch

This all feels like the last day of camp or something. And we're going to miss you all so much. But we'd like to stay... (more)

A few things I think about this place

Working on AOA over the past decade has been a life-changing experience for me and it's shaped the way I think about so many things.... (more)

Albany tightened its rules for shoveling snowy sidewalks last winter -- so how'd that work out?

If winter ever gets its act together and drops more snow on us, there will be sidewalks to shovel. And shortly after that, Albany will... (more)

Tea with Jack McEneny

Last week we were fortunate enough to spend a few minutes with Jack McEneny -- former state Assemblyman, unofficial Albany historian, and genuinely nice guy.... (more)

Recent Comments

My three year old son absolutely loving riding the train around Huck Finn's (Hoffman's) Playland this summer.

Thank you!

...has 27 comments, most recently from Ashley

Let's stay in touch

...has 4 comments, most recently from mg

A look inside 2 Judson Street

...has 3 comments, most recently from Diane (Agans) Boyle

Everything changes: Alicia Lea

...has 2 comments, most recently from Chaz Boyark

A few things I think about this place

...has 13 comments, most recently from Katherine