Maple walnut ice cream from Stewart's

stewarts maple walnut ice cream closeup

By Daniel B.

Slurpees are the defining product of 7-Elevens around the country. Every now and again I'll miss having easy access to this remarkable frosty beverage that so skillfully rides the line between two phases of matter.

When I first moved to the Capital Region I would have traded all of the Stewart's for even just one 7-Eleven if given the chance. But now, in no small part to Mr. Dave's romanticizing of the shop, I can finally see Stewart's as a cultural anchor of upstate New York. And despite my predilection for organic milk, eggs from free-roaming chickens, and ice cream made without additional gums, thickeners or emulsifying agents, I find myself regularly at my local Stewart's buying milk, eggs, and ice cream.

Amazingly, the reason isn't because Stewart's is convenient. It's because these staples are just really good.

Their maple walnut ice cream would have never even made it onto my radar had it not been for an event from last summer. Hands down, it's my favorite flavor in their case. And now is the perfect time to eat it.

stewarts maple walnut ice cream half gallon milk eggs

Last spring I led an intrepid group of eaters around five ice cream stands that make their own hard ice cream on site. To garner a fair comparison I had called ahead to see which flavors would be a common denominator across the board. Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry and coffee weren't surprising. Butter pecan kind of came out of left field. But I never expected maple walnut to make the list.

Chocolate chip wasn't available at five local ice cream shops but maple walnut was?

With over two dozen participants, not a single one of them chose to spend the afternoon eating five different scoops of maple walnut ice cream. So I was left wondering about this improbably popular flavor.

stewarts ice cream half gallon pull here

That is until that fateful day that maple walnut was the ice cream flavor of the week at Stewart's. For those who know, that means instead of a half gallon costing $4.29 it was just $3.19. That little bit of a price break was just the nudge I needed to try something new.

Whoa. This is good stuff.

Stewart's uses a natural maple syrup flavor. So it's unfair to compare it to the stuff that comes from the trees. Still, the ice cream captures the caramelized sweetness of actual maple syrup. And it's subdued enough to let the sweet cream of the dairy shine through. Frozen walnuts add not only a buttery crunch, but also a brilliant balancing bitterness that keeps the other flavors in check.

stewarts maple walnut ice cream

It's an adult flavor. Which isn't to say my kids don't like it. They do. They just aren't crazy about the walnuts. But hey, that just means more walnuts for me. As it is, there are plenty of large chunks of these tree nuts scattered through the ice cream, but I can never get enough.

Did you hear about how walnuts can also reduce your cholesterol? True story.

Winter may not seem like a great time to eat ice cream. But maple tapping has already begun as the daytime temperatures creep above freezing and plunge back down below at night. And when the next batch of real maple begins to flow, I suspect I'll find some way to enjoy it with walnuts. Because this combination of flavors is fantastic.

Daniel B. is the proprietor of the FUSSYlittleBLOG.


Sound yummy...sweet, salty, and crunchy! Actually, I found myself want to eat ice cream more as temperature drops. Winter + ice cream = yum!

Some years ago, before Fairdale Farms in Bennington became part of Garelick Farms, they used to have tiny little burger-and-ice cream shop right there at the dairy.

I used to love the burgers with real cheddar and maple-cured bacon, but what really drew me there was the maple walnut ice cream. I'd make the trip from Albany to Vermont just for that. And I still miss it.

But Stewarts' is a close second.

Any time of year is a good time to eat ice cream, just as long as you aren't trying to do so outside.

My concern with an ice cream like this would be that it'd be too sweet or the maple syrup flavor would be cloyingly fake. It sounds like that's not the case here--and it might be time for me to try some.

Given its flavorful blend of maple and dairy, as well as its particular deliciousness, let us hereby resolve to nominate Maple Walnut Ice Cream as an official New York State food.

I never thought there was anything unique or special about maple-walnut ice cream -- I've been eating it since I was a kid. Do other parts of the country really not have this flavor, or something? (That said, it is delicious, but when it's 12 degrees out, I don't really want to eat ice cream of any flavor.)

So the walnuts (may) reduce your cholesterol.. but they're found in the very rich, sure-to-raise-it ice cream?

Fancy food styling, Daniel B.!
Anytime I buy Stewarts ice cream for a special treat I get Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup - I'm too addicted to try anything else. I'll have to give this a go, though...

I love everything about Stewart's ice cream! Except packaging...
Those boxes are so inconvenient and that plastic sheet doesn't "protect flavor" at all.

I'm such a fan of Stewart's, having grown up with them (anybody else remember the "Bread 'n' Butter Shops"?), but two things about their ice cream are a constant disappointment. One is that if you control the entire distribution chain, there's really no excuse for artificial flavors and additives; no one is in a better position to deliver all-natural ice cream. And the second is the box. Since I was a kid I've found the lid so likely to rip that I almost always end up undoing the end flaps, gingerly lifting the lid off and then reassembling the box.

Crumbs along the Mohawk ...ummmm yeah..that's all.

The cultural anchor of Upstate, indeed - I think if I ever moved away the two things I'd miss the most are fish in a hot dog roll (I didn't notice that these weren't everywhere until Daniel pointed it out) and Stewarts.

And don't forget how cheap the ice cream is at Stewarts. We took our kids for hot fudge sundaes at Sundae School on the Cape and the bill for the four of us was around $25. And they weren't even "make your own sundaes".

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

What's up in the Neighborhood

Among the topics in this most recent spin around the Capital Region's online neighborhood: guns, crosswalks, a bad case of the selfies, a gravel grinder,... (more)

A very animated explainer about ticks

This might not be the claymation that we want, but it's the claymation that we need. The clip embedded above is a short claymation explainer... (more)

Morning Blend

Attorney General Underwood State lawmakers appointed Barbara Underwood as interim Attorney General on Tuesday. She is the first woman to hold the job. Underwood had... (more)

The Helderberg-Hudson Rail Trail is set to get a new paved section this summer, and a few more bits about its future

Albany County's Helderberg-Hudson Rail Trail is already one of the most popular bike/hike trails in the region, even though it's just a few years old.... (more)

After Dark: Brains & Games at miSci

There's another adult night at miSci June 2. The theme this time around is "Brains & Games," in connection with the museum's BRAIN: The... (more)

Recent Comments

I frequently find myself along this trail on Sunday mornings, hungry, & very little is open. There's a lot of talk about special mowers & building bathrooms & that's nice, yes, let's do that, certainly. But *right now* people using this trail are hungry & want to buy food & drink (& use the bathroom, as a paying customer): if the businesses that are already there were OPEN it would go a long way to providing amenities & destinations. ...

The Helderberg-Hudson Rail Trail is set to get a new paved section this summer, and a few more bits about its future

...has 3 comments, most recently from Sarah

Historic brewing district tours of Albany

...has 1 comment, most recently from Craig

That proposal for a big residential project on Western Ave in Albany has resurfaced

...has 18 comments, most recently from PK

NY Capital District Renaissance Festival 2018

...has 1 comment, most recently from Nick

A good real estate agent?

...has 49 comments, most recently from jsc