Nuns of New Skete key lime cheesecake

new skete cheesecake sections overhead

By Jeff Janssens

At first glance, it may seem like a novelty: cheesecake made by nuns. But to stop there, to nod and smile but not try the cheesecake, would be a mistake.

When it comes to the cheesecake made by the Nuns of New Skete, a group of five nuns living in a monastery in Cambridge, about an hour northeast of Albany, it would be foolish to not take their endeavors seriously. While the neighboring Monks of New Skete support themselves through dog breeding and training programs, the nuns have supported themselves for more than 30 years through baking.

I don't doubt the delectability of all their goods -- but it's the nuns' key lime cheesecake that stands out as a perfect summer treat.

The nuns have received a fair amount of attention in recent years for their cheesecakes--I dare you to watch the video accompanying this New York Times profile and then tell me you don't want to try their product -- but the key lime cheesecake is good enough to garner attention no matter the backstory. It can be ordered through the nuns' website or found on store shelves in the Capital Region, such as at the Delmar Marketplace and Hannaford locations in Clifton Park and Latham.

new skete cheesecake box

This cheesecake is a treat, especially for lovers of key lime flavor. Having lived for a short time in the South, I learned the differences between good key lime pie and the inauthentic stuff found in most supermarket freezers. Besides not using artificial green coloring, real key lime pie should showcase the key lime (freshly squeezed -- not juice from a bottle), which brings a more intense level of sourness than the grocery store standard Persian limes. The nuns capture that in their cheesecake by having their key limes shipped up from Florida, and you can taste that naturally tart flavor in their desserts.

new skete cheesecake single slice

But we're talking cheesecake, not pie. And in a bit of a surprise, the filling is really well-balanced -- surprising because it's made not only of the key lime juice, but also of cream cheese, which is somewhat sour in its own right. The key is the amount of sugar used in the recipe; it creates a perfect balance between the sweet and the sour. There's also a modest sprinkling of key lime zest atop the cheesecake, which deepens the lime flavor.

The filling is relatively dense, yet maintains a pleasant creaminess. The cream cheese-key lime mixture sits atop a crust that's thin and rather plain. In some ways, I miss the traditional thick graham cracker crust of key lime pie, but I do think the mild taste of the cheesecake's flour-based crust functions well to highlight the delicious filling.

new skete cheesecake sections

This is certainly not an inexpensive cheesecake. I found it at the Latham Hannaford for $31.99. But the cheesecake is four pounds, and if you're on good behavior it should last you a while -- or provide dessert for many guests at a dinner party. It's neatly pre-sliced into 16 servings, each divided by a slip of paper to help insure the presentation is clean. And if you do want to take your time working through cake, the box indicates a shelf life of two weeks when refrigerated, six months when frozen.

I love this dessert for its combination of richness and tartness; although cheesecake may be perceived as a heavy dessert, this version feels appropriate for the summer because of its bright citrus flavor. With the long days beginning to wane, it's best to find some way to hold onto the season as long as possible.

Jeff Janssens writes about food beer at The Masticating Monkey.


New Skete has always been THE holy grail of cheesecake. That is, until a few weeks ago when I discovered a German cheesecake recipe that uses quark vs cream cheese. It's lighter and less sweet than a typical cheesecake, making it perfect for summer. :)

Great choice for a topic! I've been itching to try this for a while. I didn't know you could find it locally. I can't remember the last time I've eaten key lime cheesecake that wasn't homemade. I'll definitely have to pick this up as a treat sometime.

I have to try this cheesecake. HAVE TO. Anyone know if the Hannaford in Niskayuna or Glenville carry it?

@ Jamie: That sounds really interesting. If that recipe is online, please share!

@ Val: Definitely try it--though it won't hurt to have someone(s) to share it with.

@ Andrea: Not sure you can get it at those Hannafords, but I'm sure a call/email to the main office of the supermarket to stock it could encourage them to expand the distribution.

nuns of new skete is a great little day trip. they have this cool refrigerator where you help yourself...stocked full of cheesecakes! honor only!

I see these all the time at Hannaford in Guilderland/Altamont. I've always wanted to buy one, but history has proven that having an entire cheesecake in the house is not the best thing for me.

My mother looks forward to me taking a day in the fall and driving her up to Cambridge to get one at the nunnery itself. It is a nice day trip.

I do know that the Hannaford in Guilderland carries them.

Thanks for the great article. Looks like the Nuns of New Skete will be shipping a few of those Key Limes back to the Florida Keys... In a cheesecake, of course.

Here's the link to a nice German recipe:

You can find Quark at the Co-op in Albany.


@ deb & Lilly: Definitely makes for a good little day trip up to Cambridge--I'd say it'd be a great extra stop during the Washington County Cheese Tour this fall, too.

@ derryX: It definitely is a lot of cheesecake to have around. We made sure to pick this one up before a few relatives made a quick visit here--it's always nice to share, especially with out-of-town visitors.

@ David L. Sloan: I think you've got the right idea--and a really great festival down there in Key West!

@ Jamie: Thanks--looks good!

For those planning a day trip. Might I suggest you go on a Sunday and head out early in the morning to drop by and get King's Donuts. . .

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

AOA is bringing presidential historian Alexis Coe to town and you should come because, wow, there's a lot to talk about (and it'll be fun)

Maybe you're like us and you read the news every day involving the current presidential administration and it's all just... well... let's just call it... (more)

An end for plastic shopping bags in New York?

Paper or... reusable? On Monday the Cuomo admin floated a bill that would ban many kinds of plastic shopping bags starting at the beginning of... (more)

The Albany All Stars Roller Derby opens its home season this weekend

The Albany All Stars Roller Derby 2018 season opens this Saturday, April 28. The All Stars will be back at the Albany Capital Center to... (more)

An insurance broker for car insurance?

J asks: Can you recommend a good local insurance broker for auto insurance? To go along with J's question, we're curious about people's thoughts or... (more)

Janet Jackson at SPAC

The Janet Jackson is set to play a show at SPAC July 26. Tickets go on sale this Friday, April 27 -- they're $29.95 and... (more)

Recent Comments

... This will make Albany into a place that many of us don't want to live in and came here to get away from: Big buildings, heavy traffic, congestion, noise, and parking shortages are really not what we or what people seeking to raise families and considering moving to our area want. Building big and tall will change Albany from a family friendly city to a metropolitan city and only increase the gap between the have's and have not's. ...

AOA is bringing presidential historian Alexis Coe to town and you should come because, wow, there's a lot to talk about (and it'll be fun)

...has 1 comment, most recently from Rkn

An insurance broker for car insurance?

...has 4 comments, most recently from Jeannette Sheehy

Janet Jackson at SPAC

...has 1 comment, most recently from Tim

Morning Blend for Apr 23

...has 1 comment, most recently from Bob

Approval for another big apartment project, Warehouse District reuse, Pine Hills demos, and more exciting tales of the Albany planning board

...has 3 comments, most recently from -R.