Checking out the Troy crime map

troy crime map

A screengrab from this afternoon.

The Troy Police Department unveiled a new online crime map for the public today. From the press release:

With the exception of crimes related to domestic incidents and sexual assaults, all reported crime in our city will be mapped with a built in 72 hour posting delay. The delay is designed to give Investigators a "first look" at an incident and apply any limitations they see fit specifically relevant to their investigation. Once mapped, the information remains embedded in the mapping, subject to numerous choices the user can make; eg. date range, type of crime, etc. Previously noted exceptions to the mapping will always be subject to inclusion should a public safety need to post the incident be evident.

This is a good step, as we've said a bunch of times before, it'd be great to see other local municipalities head in this direction.

A few more quick thoughts:

Ease of use
In trying out the map for a bit this afternoon, the interface was relatively straightforward and the map functionality will immediately be recognizable to anyone who's used a Google Map-type map. That's a big thing because something like this isn't easy and understandable, people won't use it.

More info
The information provided for each incident is minimal -- just the type of crime, time, date, location type (residential, business), and block-level address. It would be good to see that expanded to include more details about what police say transpired and whether an arrest was made. Further, it'd be interesting if police could tag a string of events as related or possibly related. And even further, it'd great if the map could be the starting point in a storyline of information that links the incident to an arrest to a court outcome.

What shouldn't be shared
As the press release mentioned, the TPD has set up a delay so information shared on the map can be moderated. That touches on some of the important issues related to this sort of public information:
+ How sharing details publicly could help -- or hinder -- the investigation of a crime.
+ To what extent should the privacy of victims protected?

As this sort of public data sharing becomes more common, these issues will keep popping up -- and almost surely there will be missteps along the way. But it's good to see that TPD is thinking about them now.

Different views
The map also provides views of the incident data by list and in the form of charts and graphs. For example, here's a day/time representation of traffic incident reports for a roughly 10 day period in September:

troy crime map traffic incidents time day

Those views of the data could be interesting over time.

Upside and downside
Part of the upside to making this sort of information more easily accessible by the public is that 1) people can have a better understanding of what's happening where they live, and 2) maybe it can allow residents to help out by offering tips or suggestions.

But there's also potential downside. Data can often be interpreted a bunch of different ways, and it's easy to string together a bunch of points in a way that's maybe not fair or responsible. As much as there should be a responsibility for governments to share public data, we as citizens also have to make an effort to use it wisely.

In and out
As far as we could tell, there's no public feed or download capability for the crime data. Why keep it locked it up? The data's public and should be available in usable formats for the public, researchers, even other public agencies.

In that vein, it's worth noting that Troy is using a private company to share this data, which is understandable. But what happens if that company stops operating? Will there be a public backup?

The future
As we said up top, this is a good step. And we'd like to see other municipalities go in a similar direction. But you know what we'd really like to see: Local municipalities -- perhaps along with local news orgs -- getting together to agree on common, flexible formats for this sort of data (just say no to PDFs). That way Troy's crime data could easily be pulled together with Watervliet's crime data. Or Troy's codes enforcement data could be cross-referenced with Albany's. (Schenectady mayor Gary McCarthy has been talking about something similar.)

And once all this stuff is published in common, it could be aggregated in a regional online hub to make it easy to find, potentially opening the way for all sorts of projects and products.

Earlier on AOA:
+ Car crashes, snow, crime, and public data
+ Keeping up with crime data


I wonder how accurate this is. It would be to their advantage to not post everything. Better for business.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

Today's moment of summer

Ducky. Just ducky.... (more)

Eminent domain possibility in downtown Albany parcels

Mike DeMasi reports that the Albany IDA and Capitalize Albany are looking at the possibility of using eminent domain to acquire a bunch of parcels... (more)

CapSci workshop on talking about science with the public

The local org CapSci has a workshop August 25 at Siena that's focused on helping people become better communicators of science. Blurbage: As scientists, how... (more)

Old-school cooking and ice cream at Crailo

The Crailo State Historic Site in Rensselaer is hosting two food/cooking-themed events over the next two months: July 21: Summer Seasonals: Dutch hearth cooking and... (more)

What's up in the Neighborhood

Among the topics in this most recent spin around the Capital Region's online neighborhood: tipping, brunch on the farm, DMB weekend, local ice cream history,... (more)

Recent Comments

... Locally, I'd recommend, Truly Rhe in Troy, Ten Thousand Villages, and Sweater Venturer. TJ Maxx, Marshalls and Target also have a good selection.

Eminent domain possibility in downtown Albany parcels

...has 1 comment, most recently from Marco Romano

Today's moment of summer

...has 1 comment, most recently from Tim

Scanning that New York State Department of Health report that argues the case for legalizing recreational marijuana

...has 5 comments, most recently from Ra

A few more bits about the present and future of the Helderberg-Hudson Rail Trail

...has 13 comments, most recently from Will

Morning Blend for Jul 18

...has 2 comments, most recently from EMB