DeFazio's (finally) gets a Tournament of Pizza trophy

Rocco DeFazio with Trophy.jpg

Rocco DeFazio, with his 2013 TOP Trophy

We started to refer to them as the Susan Lucci of the AOA Tournament of Pizza -- always good enough to be nominated but never quite able to take the award. But this year, DeFazio's of Troy took first prize in the TOP. And this week we stopped by to award them their first Tournament of Pizza trophy.

Owner Rocco DeFazio, who inherited the business from his parents, says having what it takes to make it to the finals as often as they have comes from a family philosophy -- the constant desire to improve things.

Well, that and the secret of the DeFazio's crust.

Saint Rose Tournament of Pizza ad 2013 in post

"We're never satisfied," says DeFazio. "We always feel we can do better. It's something my parents would always tell us. 'Only give your customers what you would be proud to serve to your family and friends.' So we're always trying to do better. For some people making one kind of crust really well would be enough, but we offer seven different varieties of crust, including whole wheat, multi-grain and a Brown's ale crust. We're always trying to improve."

DeFazio Dough.jpg

It's the crust, DeFazio says, that is the secret to his pies. "Really good dough should taste like good Italian bread, I always thought. So we use my grandmother's Italian bread dough recipe -- not pizza dough, bread dough -- and a wood fired oven. The dough was configured to cook in a wood fired oven -- it's not meant for a gas oven."

The oven they use is the one DeFazio bought from Italy 30 years ago. "My parents, who had a wood-fired oven in Italy, said it's got to be wood fired. So I researched it. And 30 years ago there weren't that many places using wood-fired ovens in the US. Wood fired is better because you're cooking at a really high temperature, which sears your toppings, and you're cooking next to an open flame to give a little burned crust taste. It also cooks in half the time of a regular oven."

Don't tell him the water makes the difference in a crust. "It's the recipe, it's not just the water. Water is water... but it's the recipe ... the other things you put in."

Rocco and Sons .jpg

DeFazio says he apprenticed under his parents in the business for three decades. He started out as a teacher, but about 30 years ago he took a year off when his son was born to help out with the business. He's still there today, and his two sons, Matthew and Michael, are working alongside him.

"We're having fun," DeFazio laughs. "You tweak something, you see something new -- with the internet you can search the whole world for recipes and what people are eating in other places. We're trying new things, the Brown's ale crust, two kinds of pesto sauces, a Bolognese sauce my parents got the recipe for in Italy. We're always trying new things. And variety is what people want."

DeFazio Buffalo Chicken Pizza.jpg

Rocco and his sons went back and forth over what to enter in the TOP finals this year, settling at last on the Buffalo chicken pizza that had posted the tournament's highest-ever score in the 2012 contest.

"Well," he says, "We always have this big argument (laughs) -- not an argument, a discussion -- between my two sons and myself. In the past we've been a little more creative. And we've made some really good pizza's that didn't win the tournament. Some of our customers will come in and say, 'We want that pizza, the one with the Kalamata olives -- the one that didn't win the tournament.' (laughs) This year we said you gotta keep it really simple."

"The gorgonzola cheese with the Buffalo [sauce] is delicious. We have so many good ones. My son loves the pulled pork with caramelized onions... we all have our favorites."

And for Rocco DeFazio? "My favoritore has no mozzarella -- just Romano cheese. Delicious."

Tournament of Pizza Trophy.jpg
The trophy for this year's TOP was created by Troy Cloth & Paper in Troy.

Special thanks to The College of Saint Rose Graduate Program, sponsors of the 2013 Tournament of Pizza, and to the AOA judges and everyone who provided tasting space, shuttled pizza, and helped make the 2013 TOP possible.

Find It

266 4th St
Troy, NY 12180


Congratulations DeFazios! My parents and I frequent DeFazios on a regular basis and have never been disappointed. It's rare to find a pizza joint where people know you're name and even hug and kiss you when you walk in. I can't think of a better place to win this year.

I'm really happy for DeFazio's. I've only eaten there once but it lived up to my high expectations, I hope to go back again soon. And I enjoyed this follow-up article with them - thanks AOA.

Finally! Best pizza in the area. Period. End of story.

I haven't been this pleased with a tournament outcome since UCONN beat Duke in '99. Congrats to DeFazio's.

Congratulations, again.

For what it's worth, the pizza with the Kalamata olives that didn't win the tournament was totally delicious. Had it been presented on a traditional crust instead of a whole wheat crust, it could have taken the prize.

Not that the DeFazio's whole wheat crust isn't delicious. In the world of whole wheat crusts it may be one of the best. But it's still the classic crust that keeps bringing me back.

Congratulations to DeFazio's. One of the things I miss most about moving from the Capital District is the fabulous pizza at DeFazio's - and the home made pasta and the great sauces! There is nothing like their pizza where I live in Florida. I was lucky to live a few blocks from DeFazio's for a number of years.

Ahhh...about time. DeFazio's is a real gem!

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Listening to the ballgame

The Albany Muskrat shared this pic today -- it's said to be from the 1920s, of a crowd listening to a World Series game... (more)

Where New York's crime guns come from

Of the almost 53,000 guns recovered by law enforcement agencies in New York State between 2010 and 2015, 74 percent of those guns originated out... (more)

Pretty Much the Best Comedy Show: Andy Sandford

The Pretty Much the Best Comedy Show series will be at Capital Rep in Albany this Saturday, October 29, instead of its usual spot at... (more)

"That's why often we were called the 'isolation kids.'"

Over at the Albany Student Press, Stefan Lembo-Stolba looks at the strict summer orientation program for UAlbany's Educational Opportunity Program (EOP), and reports that some... (more)

TEDxAlbany 2016 speakers lineup, and tickets are now available

The lineup is out for this year's TEDxAlbany, which is December 1 at Overit in Albany. This topics for this year's talks range from social... (more)

Recent Comments

... the Helderberg neighborhood is fabulous for Trick or Treating, maybe too much so. We always see families coming from other parts of Albany by the van load - being dropped off at one end and working their way to the other. Lots of houses in friendly neighborhoods = a packed and good time. It is also rumored that a few adults dress up and roam the streets handing out adult beverages to other adults. Again, just a rumor...

How to store 750,000 gallons of water, out of sight

...has 4 comments, most recently from Brendan

Botanical gardens in the region?

...has 11 comments, most recently from Justin Balancier

Can you answer these five 8th grade math questions correctly?

...has 49 comments, most recently from beeb

Upstate Artists Guild campaign

...has 1 comment, most recently from Afraid

Eight short stories recalling the lives of African Americans buried in the Albany Rural Cemetery

...has 5 comments, most recently from Paula