Plum Dandy Cookies and Milk

plum dandy cookies and milk three cookies

A PB Dark, a Gooey Louie, and Zoo Animal cookies.

By Lauren Hittinger

When I first walked by Plum Dandy Cookies and Milk, with a charming family inside enjoying sweet treats with adorable glassware and fancy straws, I felt like I was staring into a modern-day hipster Norman Rockwell painting. I wanted to stop in right then, but I was on my way to meet friends somewhere else.

I love sweets, so it was only a matter of time before I arranged another chance to stop in. And here's what I discovered when I finally made it inside.

plum dandy cookies and milk exterior

Cookies and Milk opened last year in a bright space in the new strip of buildings on Railroad Place in downtown Saratoga Springs. It's a sibling shop to the Plum Dandy frozen yogurt shop on Broadway.

When I walked in, I was initially confused over how to obtain my sweet treat, so the manager pointed out and explained the giant menus posted on the wall. There are over a dozen kinds of cookies you can order, along with specialty milks and coffees. The cookies span a decent variety, with biscotti, sugar cookies, and frosted animal cookies all represented among more traditional options.

plum dandy cookies and milk beverage board

I was most impressed with the variety of beverages, though. Among them: coffee milk (outside of Rhode Island!), marshmallow-flavored milk, egg cream, sipping chocolate.

plum dandy cookies and milk chocolate chip

During my initial visit, I settled on a classic Chocolate Chip cookie ($2.75) and vanilla soy milk (half pint for $1.60). I was quickly served my cookie, along with my milk in a miniature milk bottle. It was so cute -- but impractical for dipping. Luckily, Cookies and Milk had already thought of this and thoughtfully provided larger-mouthed glasses to accommodate dunking.

plum dandy cookies and milk dunking glasses

The chocolate chip cookie was firm on the outside but soft on the inside, with a smooth taste. It was a tiny bit sweet for my liking, but not sickly so. My soy milk was exactly as expected. I felt like one cookie was definitely enough for one person, so I brought my hunny back to try even more cookies on a different day!

On my second trip, we got a Gooey Louie ($2.75), PB Dark ($2.75), and Zoo Animal cookies ($3.50), along with coffee milk (pint for $3.10) and the Dandy Blend coffee (16 oz for $1.95).

plum dandy cookies and milk Gooey Louie cookie insides
The Gooey Louie

The Gooey Louie is a cookie made with Belgian cocoa, a caramel and chocolate and truffle center, topped with sea salt. This was by far our favorite cookie. It was incredibly gooey throughout the entire inside, with crispy edges. The salted top created a nice contrast to the sweetness of the cookie. It was sweet and smooth, but not sugary or overwhelming.

The PB Dark is like two cookies in one, since it's a combination of a peanut butter cookie and a chocolate cookie. I preferred the peanut butter side, and found it to be nice and creamy. The chocolate side was a tiny bit bitter and firm, especially after trying the Gooey Louie.

The Zoo Animals cookies were very cute. When you order them you get a set of three frosted sugar cookies. I received an elephant, lion, and some sort of primate, all thoughtfully decorated. These cookies were firm with hard frosting. The flavor was much less intense than the other cookies we tried, but they were a nice little snack. I feel like the larger cookies are more like an entire dessert, while the Zoo Animals are a small treat and less filling.

Our drinks were very good. I was thrilled to get delicious coffee milk that was the right amount of sweetness. It reminded me of my home-state roots. The Dandy Blend coffee was a nice pour for the price, and was served in a sturdy mug when eating in. The flavor was similar to a breakfast blend.

plum dandy cookies and milk interior1

There is plenty of seating inside Milk and Cookies, even mid-day on a Saturday. I imagine they're a work-friendly space, since they provide free wifi and a few outlets along the edge of the room.

In the center of the room there's a tall table lined with iPads, where kids were gathering around. When I went to investigate, I realized all of the iPads were loaded with games, many of them focused on baking and cooking.

plum dandy cookies and milk birthday party setup

On both Saturdays I have visited Cookies and Milk, there have been groups of children celebrating a birthday party in a smartly decorated area towards the back. I can't imagine their glee at being able to decorate (and eat) seemingly infinite amounts of sugary treats.

Overall, I'm happy with my Plum Dandy Cookies and Milk experience. It seems like a good place to meet up with friends if you're tired of coffee shops or bars. On both visits I also saw adults chatting while their little ones played on iPads. Don't be surprised it you also spot me working from a table, scarfing down cookies.

Lauren writes about shopping, crafting, and living well on a small budget at The Thrifty Ginger.

Find It

Plum Dandy Cookies and Milk
55 Railroad Place
Saratoga Springs, NY 12866




A de rigeur stop for us after a move with Addie. Though after the Lego Movie, cookies and iPad games seemed a bit overkill, but what the heck it was a Saturday and AddiesMom was out of town!

So I am totally going on this review, I bought the current groupon to check it out. Cookies & Milk are always cheaper & more fun to make at home but I splurged for my kids. I will let you know how it is.

This is one of our favorite places! Every time we go, we make a big production out of reading the menu only to step up and order the exact same things. My daughter loves the Gooey Louie, I get the Linzer tarts (1 apricot, 1 raspberry) and hubby gets chocolate chip.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

Gawking at the @HudsonPark residential conversion in Albany

This week we got a chance to gawk at the still-under-construction residential conversion of the former Long Energy building at Myrtle and Swan, right across... (more)

Albany winters have been getting warmer

A lot of people seemed to enjoy last week's post about when it's "actually" winter here -- that is, the part of the year here... (more)

What's up in the Neighborhood

Among the topics in this most recent spin around the Capital Region's online neighborhood: Phelps Mountain in the snow, ice on the lake, donating children's... (more)

"I'd rather have cities doing the right thing badly (at first), than continuing to do the wrong thing better."

This is an interesting way of looking at how cities attempt to change, what former Vancouver chief city planner Brent Toderian calls the learning curve... (more)

The New York State Writers Institute is getting two large gifts for its future

The New York State Writers Institute announced this week that it's received two large financial contributions from UAlbany alumni that will allow it to continue... (more)

Recent Comments

I just learned about the Woman's Club of Albany yesterday, during the Holiday House tour. It's a really large space that is chock full of character, and they rent it out for parties of the type Maureen is interested in.

Morning Blend for Dec 12

...has 1 comment, most recently from Zed F

The Albany Public Library is eliminating late fines for books and other items

...has 21 comments, most recently from Susan D'Entremont

Bike share grew in both use and reach this year -- here's what CDTA's thinking about for next year

...has 10 comments, most recently from EMB

Where to buy firewood?

...has 4 comments, most recently from Andrew Gregory

Walk/don't walk

...has 6 comments, most recently from Rebecca