French onion soup at The Ginger Man

ginger man french onion soup closeup

By Deanna Fox

A round of applause for Jeff Janssens, who very capably headed up the Eat This feature over the last year. And now we're happy to welcome Deanna Fox, who's next to occupy this seat at the table.

There are few times when eating soup requires the use of a knife. The French onion soup at The Ginger Man in Albany is one of those instances -- unless you plan to use your fingers to rip at the gooey cheese and broth-soaked toasts that encrust the soup.

I wouldn't blame you for throwing decorum aside and just going for it. This soup -- which is so much more than the typical French onion soup -- is worth it. But, just in case, keep the knife at the ready.

A good French onion soup (FOS) should be topped with a molten layer of cheese. A great FOS should be broiled until crackling shards of nearly-burnt dairy can be broken with the smack of a spoon's back. Once the cheese has been burrowed through, a hearty slab of baguette is all that remains before delving into a mid-layer of briny broth and a base layer of onions clinging to their final moments of life.

What I've described sums up the FOS at The Ginger Man on Western Avenue. Chef Ian O'Leary takes a ubiquitous bistro-style menu item and elevates it to its best potential.

ginger man french onion soup

There are a few key components to O'Leary's interpretation of the soup. First are the onions (it is onion soup, after all). O'Leary cuts each onion in half, and then slices thin semicircles around the core of the onion, instead of vertically dissecting the onion as most would. Picture the onion as Earth: Cut the onion from the North Pole to the South Pole. Lay half of the orb on its flat side, then begin to slice the onion starting at the South Pole diagonally towards the mock-Earth's core, working towards the Equator, then the North Pole. Make sense? Good -- that's what O'Leary is doing, except with fancier knifes and more deft skill than likely you or I have. The purpose here is that O'Leary's method changes the way the the onion breaks down as it's cooked. Instead of ending up as lifeless, fibrous strings, the final product is silken strands of onion that are cooked nearly to the color of molasses. The onions nestle in the bottom of the soup crock and melt in the mouth.

Next is a combination of long-cooked beef consommé and veal demi-glace to create the liquid portion of the soup. Whereas many versions of FOS rely on a basic beef stock (or even plain water), The Ginger Man's offering is especially pungent thanks to the concentrated meaty tones melded with the caramelized sweetness of the onions. (And is that a hit of a sherry or even Cognac in the broth?)

While many eateries relegate FOS to an overlooked, obligatory menu fixture, O'Leary's soup feels like a small luxury that aims to highlight what FOS should be, instead of something just to fill out a menu.

It's worth the two extra bones to get the Gruyere, as it is the classic cheese option for FOS and offers an assertive, nutty taste that helps break up the rich saltiness created by the broth and onions. The Gruyere option is not listed on the menu, and you won't be asked about it, so be sure to make special mention to your server if you plan on trying it.

A cup of French onion soup at the Ginger Man is $3.95, while a crock costs $5.95. At this price, you get the delicious soup described above, topped with Provolone cheese. O'Leary has also created a secret sub-order for the soup, tacking on a two dollar upcharge for the use of specially crafted, six-month-old "baby" Gruyere cheese in place of the Provolone. (The Gruyere is sourced from The Cheese Traveler, on Delaware Ave, and is also used on The Ginger Man's beef short rib sliders.) It's worth the two extra bones to get the Gruyere, as it is the classic cheese option for FOS and offers an assertive, nutty taste that helps break up the rich saltiness created by the broth and onions. The Gruyere option is not listed on the menu, and you won't be asked about it, so be sure to make special mention to your server if you plan on trying it.

Eight dollars for a crock of soup might sound like a crock of something else to many, but this soup is a satisfactory midday meal, and that price is on- or below-par as compared to upscale dining options in the Capital Region. The space at the Ginger Man -- with its copper accents, wood paneling, and reference to Irish writers and poets -- is a good setting to enjoy the soup, especially on a damp early spring day, perhaps the last days of "soup season."

ginger man albany exterior 2014-March

The restaurant itself has been a longstanding fixture in the Pine Hills neighborhood. Its romantic bistro décor and quaint outdoor seating area feels better suited to Center Square, or even a side street in downtown Saratoga Springs, than squeezed between a block's worth of college bars and apartments. Regardless of occasionally overstepping a rogue beer can on the sidewalk, The Ginger Man attracts a clientele that ranges from business people holding a lunch meeting to a group of ladies catching up over wine and fondue.

At my last visit, I enjoyed the French onion soup with a side salad and a a glass of Anchor Steam. I later realized that The Ginger Man had Nine Pin Cider on tap, the bubbly effervescence of which would have been the perfect choice to cut through the rich soup. Bread is served to each table with a side of olive oil. (The soup, side salad, and beer came to $24.41 after tax and tip.)

For more delicate palates, the soup might seem a bit on the salty side; however, for a variation of the traditional dish, I doubt one could find a better version than the Gruyere-topped FOS offered at The Ginger Man.

Deanna Fox writes about many things, mostly about food. More can be found on her website.

Find It

The Ginger Man
234 Western Avenue
Albany, NY 12203


Deanna, have you ever had the french onion soup at Garden Bistro 24? It's phenomenal stuff, and if the Ginger Man's version is even better, I think I know where I'll be eating this weekend.

I want that. Right now.

Oh, and welcome to AOA! I was worried you didn't have enough on your plate.

There's a french tradition for the onion soup. Lot of french people eat it in the morning after party and drinking all night. Around 6 AM before go back home you eat an onion soup and you feel better. It can sound weird to eat this at this time but believe it is really good ;-)

So happy to see this piece is written by Deanna Fox. Im a fan. I usually like my french onion soup topped with a Fontina because its melting temp is optimum, but the Gruyere has my mouth watering.

@Amy - Hi! Thanks for commenting. No, I've never had the French onion soup at GB 24. I haven't been there is a while, in fact, so I think it's about time I made a return visit. Thanks for the recommendation!

@Deanna - Thanks! I'll be interesting in hearing how they compare.

Thanks for all the great comments!

@burnt my fingers - yeah, never enough to do. Le sigh.

@susan - you are too sweet! Thank you.

@learn french - this makes total sense, when you think about it. I am keeping this tip handy.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Today's moment of spring

We've been aching for one of those warm, sunny spring days that feels like everything is breathing deep and ready to burst forth. Until then... (more)

Mapping a way toward education

Maybe you know (if a bit vaguely) about the significance of Emma Willard as a pioneer in advocating for educational opportunities for women. She, of... (more)

Another look at New York State's population change, this time along the urban/rural split

Here's a bonus track from last week's post about the slow population growth of the Albany metro area -- and the melting populations of many... (more)

The mystery of Hazel Drew's death

The modern world is... The Daily Mail carrying a long article about the unsolved murder of a young woman in Sand Lake in 1908 because... (more)

Behemoth Short Film Festival 2017

The Behemoth Short Film Festival returns to the Saratoga Arts Center April 15. Blurbage: The Behemoth Short Film Festival showcases some of the very best... (more)

Recent Comments

I went to one last month. My friend took his oath of citizenship. It is a great ceremony. A local school choir sang. There was a moving speech from one of the new citizens who grew up a refugee and at the age of 21 was finally a citizen of a country for the first time in her life. The League of Women Voters give warm welcomes, flags and voter registration cards to all the new citizens. It gave me such warm fuzzies. Everyone should try to go to one of these if they get the chance.

A look at the plan for new bus and pedestrian amenities at Lark and Washington in Albany

...has 8 comments, most recently from Asher G.

WHAT? (airplane flies overhead)

...has 4 comments, most recently from Lu

The mystery of Hazel Drew's death

...has 1 comment, most recently from a

Another look at New York State's population change, this time along the urban/rural split

...has 1 comment, most recently from Bob

Lifestyle Farming Conference at SUNY Cobleskill

...has 1 comment, most recently from Barold