New York State's highest court rejects bid to ban large sodas

nys court of appeals exterior

The state Court of Appeals building in downtown Albany.

New York State's highest court -- the Court of Appeals -- issued a decision today that blocks New York City's much-talked about attempt to cap the size of containers for sodas and other sugary beverages at certain outlets. The 4-2 ruling rejected an appeal of lower court decisions by the city's Department of Health and Mental Hygiene.

There are a lot of issues that intersect at the point of a 16-ounce soda -- health, business, personal liberty -- but the court's ruling was focused on... separation of powers.

Specifically, the majority opinion argued that the city's Board of Health, a part of the health department, had overstepped its authority in issuing the ban on soda containers larger than 16 ounces because it was acting in a legislative rather than regulatory capacity. From the opinion by Judge Eugene F. Pigott, Jr:

By restricting portions, the Board necessarily chose between ends,including public health, the economic consequences associated with restricting profits by beverage companies and vendors, tax implications for small business owners, and personal autonomy with respect to the choices of New York City residents concerning what they consume. Most obviously, the Portion Cap Rule embodied a compromise that attempted to promote a healthy diet without significantly affecting the beverage industry. This necessarily implied a relative valuing of health considerations and economic ends, just as a complete prohibition of sugary beverages would have. Moreover, it involved more than simply balancing costs and benefits according to pre-existing guidelines; the value judgments entailed difficult and complex choices between broad policy goals - choices reserved to the legislative branch.

In this case, the legislative branch is the New York City Council. Let's skip ahead a few paragraphs:

... when an agency in our present time either prohibits the consumption of sugary beverages altogether or discourages it by regulating the size of the containers in which the drinks are served, its choices raise difficult, intricate and controversial issues of social policy. Few people would wish to risk the physical safety of their children who play near high-rise apartment windows for the sake of unobstructed views. However, the number of people who over-indulge in sugary drinks, at a risk to their health, is clearly significant. An agency that adopts a regulation, such as the Portion Cap Rule or an outright prohibition of sugary beverages, that interferes with commonplace daily activities preferred by large numbers of people must necessarily wrestle with complex value judgments concerning personal autonomy and economics. That is policy-making, not rule-making.

The dissenting opinion from Judge Susan Phillips Read is interesting in part because it includes a condensed history of how New York City has attempted to handle public health issues over the last two centuries. In her opinion, she argues that the majority's take on whether the Board of Health overstepped its bounds doesn't match with the city's long history of the topic. Rather, she argues, it's just an attempt to cover for the fact that the majority "does not believe it to be a good idea for the Board to mandate the portion size of sugary drinks." She also points out that there apparently wasn't a problem when the Board banned restaurants from using trans fats.

It's a good bet that more topics like the soda portion cap will come along in the next handful of years. As a culture, we seem to be at a place where we're OK with being all up in each other's business about how we eat. Maybe it's the upswing in obesity, maybe it's that there's more attention on health care and health care costs, maybe it's just the proliferation of foodies. We're guessing it's easier to push rules like the soda portion cap through an agency like a department of health than it is through a legislative body because there's often going to be public outcry. You know, who doesn't have an opinion on stuff like this? Everyone eats.

So it'll be interesting to see if this ruling affects the course of these topics in the state.

Elsewhere: NYT: City Loses Final Appeal on Limiting Sales of Large Sodas

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

The old observatory

Speaking of observatories... Albany had an observatory. In fact, the observatory still exists... just not in Albany. The Dudley Observatory was once located at different... (more)

Tracking trucks in Albany's South End

People in Albany's South End have long been calling for attention and resources to focus on air quality and other environmental health issues in the... (more)

"People talk about the beer like it's got f------ unicorns in it."

Over at Longreads, there's a profile of the famed Vermont beer Heady Topper and how it came to be. But the part we found most... (more)

Capital Region Homebuyer Fair 2017

The Capital Region Homebuyer Fair will be at the Albany Public Library's Washington Ave Branch this Saturday, April 29. What's it include? Blurbage: + Meet... (more)

How should we respond when someone is being clearly inappropriate in public?

This question comes from Greg, but we'll block quote it in standard Ask AOA format: I was in line at the supermarket this past weekend... (more)

Recent Comments

Hike! The capital district and surrounding areas from Hoosick Falls to Lake George have beautiful trails, mountains, waterfalls etc. This spring I want to get out and explore outside as much as possible..then come back and eat ice cream.

Drawing: Champagne on the Park 2017

...has 86 comments, most recently from Kay

"People talk about the beer like it's got f------ unicorns in it."

...has 1 comment, most recently from Randy

How should we respond when someone is being clearly inappropriate in public?

...has 5 comments, most recently from Roni

Capital Region Homebuyer Fair 2017

...has 1 comment, most recently from CLT Schenectady

A call to customize Nipper

...has 6 comments, most recently from Paula