On trying to fill the space left by Metroland

old metroland rack cutout

It's been about six months since Metroland stopped publishing, leaving a hole in the local media scene. And this week came official public word of a new effort intended to fill that left-behind niche.

The Daily Gazette, Proctors, and Overit announced Tuesday that they've joined together to back a new weekly publication called The Alt. From a Proctors press release:

This collaboration between for-profit and not-for-profit groups reflects the best practices of the creative economy and will be a well-curated, thought-provoking and constantly updated portal to goings-on in the eight county Capital Region; enticing new visitors and speaking dynamically to young locals and travelers alike with a vibrant, irreverent and tech-savvy flavor.

An article in the Daily Gazette includes a bunch of other details. They're expecting to launch this fall.

As you might expect, we have a few thoughts about all this. So here they are, along with a notable disclosure.

The disclosure

We'll mention this right from the start: We've known this publication was in the works for months because for a time earlier this year there was some possibility that AOA might be involved in some way. We had long talks with the Daily Gazette about potentially working together, but ultimately those discussions didn't lead to anything. And in our view, the episode ended amicably.

So, do we see this publication as competition? Sure. Everything is competition now, from other publications to every other sort of media. That said, we think there's room for all sorts of media orgs in the Capital Region. And having more coverage of what's going on is better than less.

A few thoughts

Possible strength in combination
One of the interesting aspects of The Alt is that it's backed not just by The Daily Gazette, but also Proctors and Overit. And there could be some real benefits from that.

The hardest part of starting a new publication isn't the content -- it's selling the ads and generating revenue. The Gazette has a lot of experience doing that sort of thing, so it won't have to start from scratch. Likewise, the Gazette also has a lot of experience printing things.

A skill that a lot of traditional media companies have struggled with, though, is web development. And in that regard, Overit -- which has a whole collection of people who do that everyday -- should be a big help.

And, of course, Proctors is Proctors. It has a ton of experience staging events, and it has tremendous influence in the region.

Proctors exterior 2016-June

But the non-traditional backing could also be an issue
The potential downside to this group of backers is that their other businesses prompt questions about conflicts of interest. If The Alt is dedicated, in part, to covering the local arts scene, it's not unreasonable to be at least a little bit wary about the area's premiere arts organization owning a third of the publication (and providing office space and accounting services for the publication). The same goes for Overit, which has a robust marketing and PR shop -- what are people going to think when one of the firm's marketing clients is featured prominently in The Alt?

That is not to say there will be conflicts of interest. Media companies have for many years erected organizational walls (that are mostly solid) between their business and content sides. But the appearance of conflict is something they'll all have to address at some point.

Paper still lives
Launching a new alt weekly is swimming against the tide in the media industry. And planning to print 25,000 weekly copies of the publication is almost retro in direction, given the trends and the way publications have been trimming their print products. But, again, the Gazette has a lot of experience with this part of the business. And it owns its own printing press, so presumably The Alt will be getting a good deal.

What's the niche?
The Alt won't be the first publication trying to fill this space. The Spot 518 -- from the Spotlight News -- has been trying to claim some of that ground. So it'll be interesting to see what sort of niche The Alt will be aiming to fill. Here's a clip from the Gazette article Tuesday:

The weekly, to be named "The Alt," will cover stories in Albany, Saratoga, Schenectady and Troy that the newspapers in the region, like The Gazette and The Times Union, aren't touching, said Gazette President and Publisher John DeAugustine.
At the same time, DeAugustine said he doesn't believe The Alt will directly compete with the other newspapers in the area. Rather, it will feature stories that push the boundaries with quirky topics and strong opinions.
"This will truly be an arts and entertainment alternative news publication," he said. "We will go after controversial topics in the region. We're not going to shy away from topics that may be uncomfortable for others. If they had a porn expo at the TU Center, we would cover it, while the Gazette would probably pass on it."

Alt weeklies around the country were, in some sense, a response to how old-school metro dailies covered their cities. And the critique was that the dailies were too staid and too focused on traditional news.

It's worth thinking about whether that's still the case. To use DeAugustine's example of the porn expo, that's something not difficult to imagine being covered by the Times Union. (Also, two words: SEEN gallery.)

That's not to say there aren't important stories that currently go un-covered or under-covered -- not at all. But the tide in media, even local, has been toward many of the alt-weekly staples -- food, entertainment, sex -- and away from the staid (but often important) stuff like local government meetings.

Adding to the challenge will be staffing. According to the Gazette article, the plan is to hire one editor, one web editor, and one reporter. That's not a lot of people, especially when you have to put out a print product. (The work of filling the calendar section they're planning will soak up a lot of hours just on its own.) And doing in-depth work on the sorts of topics mentioned in that article -- "the changing face of employment and industry, the activity of downtowns and social rights and transparency" -- will be difficult with that number.

[T]he fact that Metroland left some sort of hole in the local media landscape doesn't necessarily mean whatever comes next should try to fill that spot exactly.

The new niches
Zooming out a bit, there's the bigger question about what sort of niches or audiences aren't being served in the Capital Region. Because the fact that Metroland left some sort of hole in the local media landscape doesn't necessarily mean whatever comes next should try to fill that spot exactly.

So, let's throw a few ideas out there for new niches or viewpoints to focus on or serve:

+ An explicit focus on the urban areas of the Capital Region.

+ A publication largely directed by, and prominently featuring, the voices of minorities.

+ An approach that frames stories and issues by looking at their potential solutions.

+ Media products to serve the area's growing multi-cultural immigrant population.

+ The area already has a stand-alone publication focused on business, but its coverage often approaches issues from the perspective of business owners and executives -- so how about coverage that looks at business issues from the perspective of labor or workers?

+ A focus on tech and science and health.

+ A publication based on the perspective of the over-65 crowd, of which they are going to be a lot more people here in the future.

Some of these perspectives already get coverage. And there's also content popping up in non-traditional forms that give voice to some of these perspectives. But these all seem like potential growth areas in one way or another.

Are there robust media businesses to be built on them? In some cases maybe not. But backing them with resources and giving them a shot would help diversify the media landscape here.

Earlier and elsewhere

+ AOA: Every local publication is Metroland now

+ A few years back at Reuters, Jack Shafer wrote a good overview of how the alt-weekly industry has crumbled during the last decade



The Alt huh? This is great! I haven't had any papers for house training my puppies since Metroland disbanded! Notes to selves.....if going to be voice against the rich and all that crap make sure that you guys pay your taxes or else end up like the clowns that ran Metroland....otherwise good luck.....will be good for checking movie times at the least

Nice development. I'll be looking for this @ the usual outlets.

Huh. And here I was thinking AOA has already filled the space (and then some) left by Metroland.

A successor to Metroland is definitely needed. I realize it will be political, but I hope a voice can be found that is forceful but not shrill.

The Spot 518 seems to be aiming toward the entertainment & calendar angles, so The Alt audience will need to buy into whatever niches they fill. But I believe there's a big issue already - analogy to the "one editor, one reporter, one online editor" is a George Thorogood song, and we all know how that ends.

"The Alt"? If my 65 year old father and his golf buddies had to come up with name for millennial (!!!!) oriented weekly publication, I can imagine them coming up with a similar name.

Spot on, indeed.

Great to hear your perspective, thank you for sharing!

The Metroland failed because of two reasons in my opinion.

1) It tilted too far to the Left. Even in Albany (land of the Democrat) people want different views. There's so much Left-wing noise, and they were just more of the same.

2)It just wasn't very good.

What I would like to see in the area is a paper that has INTELECTUAL DIVERSITY. There's plenty of racial and cultural diversity in the local media, to deny that is foolish. Everyone is trying very hard to prove they care about racial and cultural diversity. Why should that be the focus? What we need is difference of OPINION, not difference of skin color or culture.

Wait... there are porn expos at the tu center???

I can't wait to see it. Good luck to them on making it interesting and relevant... and "alt."

It would be nice to see Paul Rapp's column in the new publication. I appreciate his discussions on law & the arts.

From the Gazette article:

The Gazette will print about 25,000 copies of The Alt each week [...] But the energy would not be put into the print product. The focus would be building a high-quality website and mobile website, by Overit, which would allow the Alt staff to experiment with calendars, social media and video.

So the print product is a way to sell ads and drive people to a website? It will face the same challenges as every other dying news-centric print publication - mainly the fact that you're old news before you hit the newsstands.

AOA, Nippertown, KeepAlbanyBoring and all the other local blogs replaced Metroland. The Gazette, OverIt, and Proctors could have just teamed up to launch another local website if that's what the end goal was. I don't see why this generic-named print version needs to exist.

I recall Metroland in the 1980's when it was pretty much a promotional rag for local rock bands....as long as they were friends with BLOTTO. After a while they seemed to think they represented the conscience of the district.

As always, a very thoughtful analysis of the pros and cons!

I love alt weeklies, I hope there's a place for them despite newspaper trends.

Will it offer movie contests, restaurant reviews , and a job for Steven Leon?

Insightful piece on The Alt. I found it useful when thinking about the project.


As always, I'm so thankful for AOA's reporting and perspective. There will be a lot to enjoy in The Alt but nothing about it makes me think it can ever meet my cultural, social, historical, and regional curiosity like AOA does. Bravo to AOA for staying independent; I know it's challenging. The Alt lost out on a big opportunity to be partners with a powerful media company with a devoted audience: All Over Albany.

Glad you guys chimed in on this. Great take on "The Alt." Too bad it didn't work out to partner with AOA.

We'll see what happens from here! Just hope The Gazette holds strong, and possibly grows as a result.

P.S. I would cover a porn expo at The Gazette. Just saying.

As is Alt-CTRL-DEL? ha ha ha I tend to agree with Rebecca's comment that AOA fills in where Metroland left off (without the ads!) Let's hope ALT is a little Village Voice-y , and doesn't end up as a "captive" publication for its sponsors.

In the last years of Metroland--especially the final year--I spent most of my time doing calendar listings. It is time consuming. But what's the alternative? The Times Union's web calendar, with listings uploaded by users, is pretty terrible. A "curated" list is better than a hodgepodge.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

Thank you!

When we started AOA a decade ago we had no idea what was going to happen. And it turned out better than we could have... (more)

Let's stay in touch

This all feels like the last day of camp or something. And we're going to miss you all so much. But we'd like to stay... (more)

A few things I think about this place

Working on AOA over the past decade has been a life-changing experience for me and it's shaped the way I think about so many things.... (more)

Albany tightened its rules for shoveling snowy sidewalks last winter -- so how'd that work out?

If winter ever gets its act together and drops more snow on us, there will be sidewalks to shovel. And shortly after that, Albany will... (more)

Tea with Jack McEneny

Last week we were fortunate enough to spend a few minutes with Jack McEneny -- former state Assemblyman, unofficial Albany historian, and genuinely nice guy.... (more)

Recent Comments

My three year old son absolutely loving riding the train around Huck Finn's (Hoffman's) Playland this summer.

Thank you!

...has 27 comments, most recently from Ashley

Let's stay in touch

...has 4 comments, most recently from mg

A look inside 2 Judson Street

...has 3 comments, most recently from Diane (Agans) Boyle

Everything changes: Alicia Lea

...has 2 comments, most recently from Chaz Boyark

A few things I think about this place

...has 13 comments, most recently from Katherine