Voting "nay"

Noted: Kirsten Gillibrand is the only US Senator to have voted "no" on all three Trump admin nominees so far -- Mike Pompeo for CIA, John Kelly for Homeland Security, and John Mattis for Defense. For Mattis, she was the only "no" vote and publicly opposed the waiver necessary to allow Mattis, a former general, to serve as secretary of defense, citing an emphasis on civilian control of the military. [US Senate x3] [The Hill]

Comments

Gillibrand can have all my donations and volunteer time if she keeps this up. Now is the time to fight, before it gets worse.

I'm becoming more impressed with Gillibrand for standing up to Trump. Maybe she can drop that Blue Dog Democrat stuff.

I just called her office to thank her.

I guess she's getting a lot of calls because it took me a few tries to get through.

We are all quick to complain when politicians do the wrong thing. Let's recognize her when she does the right thing.

Good move, Ms. Gillibrand. Glad you're our Senator. As usual, we your political sensibilities synch up with ours.

This is all becoming a major shit-storm, thanks goodness for people like the Senator. For the first time in my life I was compelled to write my Congressman about the recent EPA clampdown. I have to pinch myself every day to remind myself that this is really happening.

I'm a little mistrusting of her because of the amount of money shes received from Wall Street and lobbyists over the years but I give her a lot of credit for fighting when a lot of the other Dems are rolling over.

"the amount of money shes received from Wall Street and lobbyists over the years"

I'll never understand this sort of purity-testing mentality. Sorry but if she wants to do anything as a senator, she actually has to be elected as a senator. One person cannot single-handedly overturn our campaign finance system, and there is not a single politician in a federal seat who can get by without this. (Keep in mind this applies to the alt-left's heroes like St. Bernie as well.)

Jeff W, Gillibrand (and Shumer) get a lot of money from Wall St because that's where the money is in New York State.

In other states the senators get their money from (insert major industry here).

Neither of them are saints but right at the moment, I admit Gillibrand is my favorite Senator. Even Warren, Franken and Sanders are voting for some of these clowns.

@JayK - I never understand the "well, that's the way the game is played" argument so we'll have to agree to disagree. Will it ever be "pure"? Of course not, but our system can be so much better than it is. So many people would rather take a backseat to special interests than actually try to change things for the better, then at the same times wonder why things never really get better.

@Stan - I agree to some extent that location plays a factor, but it still raises a bit of an eyebrow for me.

I should clarify my position as well - taking donor money doesn't make one a bad candidate, but they don't get the benefit of the doubt either.

I agree with Jeff W, expecting that our political leaders are free of entanglements is neither nieve or misguided. In my eyes it is simple to vote nay, when you know the votes and your given that gift\opportunity by the leadership. Let's not forget that our future first female President was appointed not elected. Once in, incumbency usually suffices to be reelected, as do those deep deep connections. Apologies, if my cynicism offends.

"Let's not forget that our future first female President was appointed not elected." Appointment does not involve winning the popular vote by a large margin twice in one year.

Personally, I'd rather "progressives" begin to focus on progress rather than this adolescent posturing over who can be the most perfect liberal. It doesn't seem my opinion is widely stared, at least on this comment thread.

@JayK are you saying that Senator Gillibrand did not get appointed to fill Senator Clinton's seat by Governor Patterson when Clinton went to the State dept. That is how she got there. I think that a majority of Gillibrands positions are right on but the senator doesn't need to be lauded for a purely political move orchestrated to strengthen the resume. Purity is what brought the conservatives to power over their establishment. Maybe it could work for the party that pretends to be the representatives of working people as well.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Five takeaways from the start of the fifth major effort to redevelop 1 Monument Square

Monday night the city of Troy had a public workshop to kick off the fifth major attempt to redevelop the 1 Monument Square site. Yep,... (more)

Buffalo, one of 52 places

The New York Times "52 Places Traveler" series makes a stop in Buffalo. Writes Jada Yuan: "... Buffalo went from a place I didn't think... (more)

South End Healthy Market

The South End Healthy Market opens its 2018 season Saturday, June 30 from 10 am to 3 pm at a new location, the the lawn... (more)

Freedom Park 2018 concert series lineup

The popular series of free concerts at Freedom Park in Scotia starts this Wednesday. As usual, the season includes big lineup with multiple concerts each... (more)

There's a workshop coming up in Albany about how to apply for a slice of state grant money for your project

For the last several years the state has distributed millions of dollars to projects around the state via the Regional Economic Development Council (REDC) process... (more)

Recent Comments

Elm St between Eagle and Phillip. Beautiful, colorful, Italianate row houses directly down the hill from the Executive Mansion.

Morning Blend for Jun 19

...has 3 comments, most recently from Greg

Solid Sound 2019

...has 2 comments, most recently from Greg

The ValleyCats open the 2018 season this weekend at The Joe

...has 1 comment, most recently from Kayla

Big lift

...has 2 comments, most recently from ravioliollie

Weekend Destination: Quebec City

...has 2 comments, most recently from Mary M