Round 1: Troy

pizza round 1 troy
The Troy bracket.

The opening round of the Tournament of Pizza heads to Troy. Lots of favorites in this bracket. The matchups: DeFazio's vs. Red Front and Knotty Pine vs. I Love NY.

Let's go to the results.

DeFazio's 0
Red Front 3
Post game: This was quite the upset, especially since the famed DeFazio's pizza didn't score a point. On reviewing the judge comments, though, it doesn't seem that DeFazio's lost so much as Red Front made an especially strong showing. DeFazio's was praised by the judges for its "good chewy cheese and crust combo" and it's good "oregano [and] umami flavors." But Red Front wowed the judges with its "bready and good" crust which one judge described as "crisp on outside, but fluffy as a pillow inside." Said another judge of Red Front's pizza: "simply delicious." One thing that might have done in DeFazio's was its ablility to hold up after being transported form the shop. Wrote one judge of DeFazio's: "would be better hot."

Knotty Pine 0
I Love NY 3
Post game: This was another 3-nil contest, but not nearly as close as DeFazio's vs. Red Front. The judges enjoyed I Love's "crazy sweet but nicely flavored sauce" and "all that" texture. Knotty Pine didn't fare so well. Judges complained about its "funky" cheese and "dry" texture. Wrote one judge of KP: "please don't make me eat this again."

So, after a very strong showing Round 1, Red Front moves on to meet I Love NY in Round 2.

Tomorrow in The Tournament of Pizza: Albany.

Previous Round 1 results: Saratoga | Schenectady.


pssst. check your bracket. it still lists a schenectady place.

OUTRAGE! There is no way Defazios got shut out. Red Front must be paying off the judges.

Woo, go I Love NY!
(PS: the results table still shows 'Pizza King' from the Schenectady round)

Thanks for heads-up on the scoreboard. It's fixed now.

I know I'm being picky here but if the pics above are acurate representations of the pizzas consumed, I don't think it's right to pit a round, neopolitan pie against a square, sicilian pizza. I'm not familiar with red front or defazio's so I have no vested interest in either one beating the other and you can make an argument for same cheese, same sauce used on either neopolitan or sicilian but... I think there's a world of difference in how that slice of pizza will tase, the crust alone makes such a difference (to picky me, at least....)(I'll stop complaining now).

it looks to me like you had ny style slices (triangles) compete against sicilian style slices (rectangles)... why wouldn't you pair the same kind/shape against each other (i.e. Defazio's vs. I love and Red Front vs. Knotty Pine)?

We all thought Defazio's would go against I loves. We even knew (from experience, it was a blind test) we were voting against Defaz at the time. Like they say "On any given Sunday.."

As awesome as it is to be good reporters and get "the full, official story", let us not play games here. This is a no-contest set-up you got going. I Loves. All the way. In fact, this is the first time I'm realizing that there are even other places. Really?

In case you AOA editors had any doubt about your blogs credibility/authority, I think the response to this contest is your answer. Folks are going ape shit over your opinion. They must really take you seriously.

And that's..... one to grow on.

1. The shape of a pizza does not make it sicilian. The thickness of the dough does. Shapes don't taste different.

2. Is this I Love NY on Hoosick, or (recently renamed) I Love Troy on 4th? If you've been to both, you know there's a big difference.

PJ, I'm with you, but just read the review... the DeFazio's pie wasn't even hot. Come on now. I still have people call it the best pizza they've ever had when I bring them, so that's good enough for me. In fact, I think it's about time I visit again...

Having grown up in Brooklyn (moved up here in my late 20's) I know full well what a 'real' sicilian slice tastes like & I know it's thicker than a slice that's called a 'square cut' up here but.... I still claim that a square cut tastes different than a round cut. It seems to me I love ny, especially, has a wonderful thin crust - that would not compare to a square cut slice from somewhere else.

I cannot believe that Defazio's lost in the first round. My whole world has been turned upside down and everything no longer makes sense. I need sake and lots of it.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

The week ahead

Here are a few things to keep in mind, look forward to, or keep busy with this week, from the weather (not bad), to baseball,... (more)

Approval for another large residential project in downtown Albany that could be the first of many notable projects, and other exciting tales of the Albany Planning Board

Exciting Tales of the Albany Planning Board is a program recorded before a live studio audience once a month in which the fates of multi-million... (more)

A row of buildings gone, except for one

A follow up of sorts about the old, beautiful Mechanics and Farmers Bank building at the corner of State and James in downtown Albany and... (more)

BUILT 2018 call for entries

This year's Historic Albany Foundation BUILT event -- "Albany's Architecture through Artists' Eyes" -- will be at the State Museum November 3. The annual fundraiser... (more)

"Gambling was the bedrock of every day of our lives growing up in Schenectady"

At the center of this Ringer profile of new Monday Night Football play-by-play man Joe Tessitore is an account of his childhood in/around Schenectady and... (more)