Troy is the new Brooklyn

Troy is the New Brooklyn.jpg

Who knew?

When the folks at Some Girls Boutique closed their Colvin Avenue store and consolidated in their shop on 2nd Avenue in Troy, they left this message in the window for their customers, "Troy is the new Brooklyn."

We love the Collar City, but here's what we need to know -- if Troy is the new Brooklyn, does it come with good bagels? And can Harry Tutunjian help Sandor find a decent egg cream?

(Thanks, Laura!)

Comments

What exactly is this sign supposed to mean, "Troy is the new Brooklyn?" I don't get it.

I live in Troy. Bed-Stuy maybe. Williamsburgh it ain't.

I'll tell ya what it means... we'll be tripping over those damned mini-Hummer style baby strollers just to get a coffee and all be forced to wear tight pants and ironic t-shirts!

I'm not sure about the bagels, but Troy's hipster cred rose significantly when I moved away.

I know they have a pretty kick ass derby league!

You can check them out all summer at Frear Park!

Troy is the new Dove Street. It still has a way to go, but at least it's not the new Henry Johnson Blvd. anymore.

There is nothing in this entire region that will come anywhere close to Brooklyn.

Back in February local photographer/art reviewer/critic David Brickman noted in his blog Get Visual that he considered Troy to be the the Brooklyn of the Capital District specifically because of its "walkability and friendliness to artists." See http://dbgetvisual.blogspot.com/2009/02/celebrating-spaces.html

Is Albany the new Manhattan?

Puh-lease.

Troy is not even similar to Brooklyn. There is nothing to do, see, or eat in Troy.

It's barely worth a day trip from other parts of the capital region.

re: Jennifer - while i do think calling troy the new brooklyn is bewildering / potentially incorrect / totally irrelevant, it apparently has been a while since you have wandered on over here - as there is actually stuff to do, see, and even eat in troy these days. a quick gander at AOA's listings of what is happening on the weekend will usually point towards stuff to do, plus all those open signs on restaurants (even a few on sunday! who knew...) would mean you can stuff your gullet while you are out doing and seeing (perhaps even hearing and smelling - be careful / mindful with the touching, i would say).

or you can stick in your house / apartment / houseboat / cardboard box with internet (upscale!) and glower - your choice.

skfl (who is coming up quick on a decade in this little town)

Where's a walkable grocery store? Am I too unfamiliar with Troy?

Jennifer- do you live in Troy? When did you go to Troy? Let me guess, you went once and wrote it off. There is plenty to see and do and eat in Troy and the area around it. There are great shops, galleries, cafes and restaurants. It's worth a day trip and you should give it a better shot. Just don't have such a crappy attitude about it next time.

Troy is the new Brooklyn like Lark St. was/is the new Greenwich Village back in '95 or whenever? I must live in "Jersey" up on Allen St.

walkable markets in troy are still a stumbling block - uncle sam's is decent, but the produce selection is small / uneven, and the hours are not really convenient for working folk. the price chopper in watervliet is surprisingly close, but walking about the route 2 bridge with heavy bags is iffy. thankfully, i hear there is a co-op opening soon right in downtown - i have my alarm set for some time in 2019 (holding my breath until then, naturally).

In the 5 years that I have lived upstate I have wandered over to Troy many times, ever hopeful am I...and I stand by my (perhaps too harshly stated, I will admit) assertion that Troy is to Brooklyn as marshmallows are to tofu.

~Brooklyn girl, born and raised.

I heard about the Troy co-op as well albeit it was a few years ago. I thought for sure it was open by now? A walkable grocery store kept some friends of mine from moving that way.

it say here - http://troyfoodcoop.com/ - that it is slated to open in 2008, though is seem to remember them thinking it would be even earlier when the idea was first pitched. i seem to remember it becoming 2009 a few months ago - hence setting 2019 as a reasonable goal...

@skfl: that Troy is no Brooklyn, right, but no need to bother answering to Jennifer, she was trolling.

There are obviously tons of things to see, eat and experience in Troy; one of our best concert venue, a fantastic classical concert hall, EMPAC, Troy Night Out, a sprawling cemetery, scary flock of crows, a derby team, a nice photo center, a good market, etc. And I'm not even from Troy. You would have to live blind-folded in a barrel stuck at the bottom of a freakin' cave guarded by giant were-bats to ignore that.

I'm a troll because I don't think Troy is comparable to Brooklyn? Okay.

And the examples you give of what make Troy so fabulous include a cemetery and flocks of crows? For real?

@Jenn: no, but close. obviously. for real.

There are beagles in Troy. I cannot believe that nobody made the connection about Brueggers being founded in Troy.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

The wild turkey

Historical illustration of the day, because Thanksgiving week: "The Wild Turkey," from Zoology of New York, published in 1844. Or: The New-York Fauna: comprising detailed... (more)

Albany red light camera forums

The Albany Police Department is hosting two public forums on December 2 about the possible locations for red light cameras in the city -- at... (more)

The Trial Before Christmas returns

The Trial Before Christmas -- a mock trial to settle who really wrote "A Visit from Saint Nicholas," first published in the Troy Sentinel --... (more)

The burger at 15 Church

Ever have a cheeseburger change your life? I haven't either -- though I've had plenty of cheeseburgers that remind me why it's good to be... (more)

A Syracuse Billion

Following on a comment from Andrew Cuomo that upstate cities should propose ambitious projects, Syracuse mayor Stephanie Miner took up challenge (dare?) and her administration... (more)

Recent Comments

I am so very thankful for the wonderful people who wandered in and out of my life over the last few years. They have given me the love and support I need to survive and thrive. Last year at this time I was at my lowest. By the grace of all that is good in my life, I have climbed out and I'm happier than I've been in a very, very long time.

Drawing: What are you thankful for this year?

...has 45 comments, most recently from LisaW

A future in plastics and billiard balls

...has 11 comments, most recently from John Cernak

The burger at 15 Church

...has 5 comments, most recently from Lauren Darman

The Best Dozen: Park Side Eatery

...has 3 comments, most recently from julie

New UAlbany president's residence

...has 7 comments, most recently from Joe A