Egg and Cheese Sandwich at Jack's Diner

jacks diner egg sandwich

Hard roll, two eggs, cheese.

By Daniel B.

Update: Details on the full Tour de Egg Sandwich are now available at fUSSYlittleBLOG.

All egg sandwiches are not created equal.

And I'm not even talking about different forms of egg sandwiches that can be enjoyed all around the country. Like in Philly where they scramble the egg and put it on an Amoroso hoagie roll. Or in New Jersey it comes with Taylor ham and saltpepperketchup. In New Mexico you will find scrambled eggs in the form of a burrito stuffed with green chile. Here, we put flattened fried-eggs and American cheese on a grilled hard roll, which I've recently discovered is decidedly not hard.

In the Capital Region almost every diner, deli, convenience store, bakery, and cherished institution produces a version of this sandwich. So, to better understand what makes our egg and cheese so special, I recently went on a Tour de Egg Sandwich along with 17 other likeminded eaters.

The competition among the five places was close. Very close. In the Tour de Egg Sandwich voting, Jack's Diner in Albany edged out McCarroll's in Delmar by a nose, with Famous Lunch in Troy nipping at their heels.

So what sets this diner apart?

One word: Balance.

Well, that and the two fried eggs that graced the sandwich were the most tenderly cooked of the day. Whereas our local egg and cheese sandwiches default to eggs over-hard, the ones at Jack's Diner were decidedly over-medium. The color of the yolks was a deep golden orange, and the whites were just set.

Far too often fried eggs are obliterated on a too hot griddle, browning and toughening the whites.

The flip side of this more delicate cooking style is that the hard roll was only lightly grilled. It was enough to provide some enriching fat to the cut surfaces of the bread, but the only crispness was found along the roll's outside edge. Even the fans of Jack's conceded that the hard roll was better elsewhere. For what it's worth, the toasting on the buttered Prinzo's rolls at McCarroll's was beautiful.

jacks diner egg sandwich closeup

However, it was Jack's fairly ordinary roll that allowed the center of the sandwich to shine. And a large part of that was what they did with ordinary run-of-the-mill white American cheese. (NB: those who ordered cheddar also thought highly of the cheese).

You may never have paid attention to cheese placement on a sandwich before, but it matters. Does the cheese go on the top, the bottom or in the middle?

Jack's wisely places a generous quantity of the stuff in between the two eggs sizzling from the grill, causing the cheese to transform from a bland piece of industrially produced dairy, into what's effectively a rich and savory sauce. Yet the sandwich holds together, and maintains its structural integrity. And when eaten as a whole, a plurality of us agreed that it was the best of the bunch.

It's also pretty substantial, both in its size and its cost. While some delicious versions of this sandwich can be had for less than two dollars locally, Jack's Diner will set you back about four bucks (before tax and tip). Meat will cost you an extra dollar. But you do get to eat at a booth or a counter, on a proper plate, and at a joint with table service.

Does Jack's Diner make the best egg and cheese sandwich in the Capital District? There are too many places that make this regional specialty to say with any degree of certainty. But their version is great, and it bested some very strong competition, which makes this diner a worthy contender for the crown.

For those who are curious about how the whole tour played out, a full report will be available on the FUSSYlittleBLOG later this week.

Daniel B. is the proprietor of the FUSSYlittleBLOG.

Earlier on AOA: Jack's got a mention on Crystal's list of the best diner breakfasts in the Capital Region.

Find It

Jack's Diner
547 Central Avenue
Albany, NY 12206


Jack's in pretty much the best diner in town, and their staff is always so friendly and attentive. I'm so glad they are getting the recognition they deserve!

I love this!

How about BACON, egg, and cheese for Round 2?

A well placed source tells me that "Best Egg Sandwich" will be a category in this year's Times Union readers' poll.

McDonald's is the early favorite.

It was a fine sandwich- I went for McCarroll's for the win but I can (and I did) appreciate the simple and solid virtues of a thing done right at Jack's. Add in the diner atmosphere, plus friendly service, and I'll be doing another breakfast there in the near future...but I'm off egg sandwiches for a while.

I hope you'll provide more details on each sandwich on your blog, 'cause I find that your "best" wouldn't always be mine. I would call that egg up there underdone, for instance. And if the whites are a little brown and crispy, I call that a good thing. :)

I love Jack's! I also think their corned beef hash (their homemade version, although they also offer a canned version) is just a greasy pile of perfection.

The proliferation of Dunkin' Donuts and that sliced tube of egg they (and others) serve has almost ruined the egg sandwich for me. Great to see it still exists in places in its real classic form. Makes me wish it was morning now so I could head over to Jack's.

Daniel - only you turn an egg and cheese on a hard roll into poetry - thank you

I don't know if Princess is still working the grill in the ESP concourse, but she makes the best egg sandwich hands down.

For the curious, the full story of the Tour de Egg Sandwich is up on the FUSSYlittleBLOG. It lays out the qualitative differences between each establishment.

In summary they break down as:
- The cheesy soft one
- The crusty toasted one
- The awful one
- The rich one
- The small cheap one

The plurality of the people on the tour preferred Jack's Diner. But if you have a different set of criteria, one of the others might be the egg and cheese sandwich for you.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Talking about the Veggie Mobile on its 10th anniversary

Capital Roots is celebrating the 10th anniversary of The Veggie Mobile -- it's rolling green market on a truck -- with a party called The... (more)

The beautiful State Education Building will be open for regular public tours

The State Education Building will be open for public tours on the second Saturday of each month starting in August, the state Education Department has... (more)

Melancholy, arriving on track 2

Check out this photo of the old Union Station waiting room in downtown Albany, via the Albany Group Archive. It's dated to 1968, which... (more)

Colonial ice cream day at Crailo

This could be interesting (and delicious): The Crailo State Historic Site is hosting a "Colonial Ice Cream Discovery Day" August 12. Blurbage: [D]iscover how colonists... (more)

Where to get a hybrid or electric car serviced?

Mark emails: I've been on the hunt for a mechanic that specializes/is-well-versed in electric/hybrid cars, but have failed to bag anything. I have taken my... (more)

Recent Comments

I still don't know why it has to look like a spaceship. There are countless downtown theaters that fit in aesthetically with their surroundings. I was just in Arlington, Massachusetts and they have a six screen theater in a building fronted with a bakery, a toy store, a salon... Thinking that theaters can only look like suburban malls shows either a lack of imagination or a lack of awareness.

Melancholy, arriving on track 2

...has 2 comments, most recently from Elisabeth

Experiences with Uber and Lyft so far?

...has 19 comments, most recently from Amy

Where to get a hybrid or electric car serviced?

...has 3 comments, most recently from chezjake

The week ahead

...has 1 comment, most recently from Amy Koren-Roth

One critique of the proposed 1 Monument Square design, raised up one level

...has 9 comments, most recently from J