The primary elections for state and local offices is this Thursday. And that means lawns, medians, parking lots, and other spots all over the Capital Region are currently adorned with political signs. So. Many. Political signs.
You can't help not seeing them. They're everywhere. So we thought it'd be fun to look at the signs a little differently, a little more fundamentally -- as design objects. And we got a trio of accomplished local designers to critique the design of signs from a handful of local races.
Because of the vast herds of signs this year, we've broken the design primary up into two days.
Today: design primary results from races for Albany County DA, State Senate 43rd, and State Senate 44th...
Quick note: These critiques are solely of the sign designs, not of the candidates.
First up, the designers critiquing the yard signs:
+ Mark Gregory is an illustrator and designer who's done design work for many businesses in the Capital Region -- including identity design, advertising for print and web, billboards, packaging, and caricatures.
Albany County DA
Doug: I really like how cleverly the "DA" in "David" (set in blue) lets the reader know immediately that this is a candidate for the District Attorney's position. Legible and not too fussy, blue and black on a white ground provide good readability from distance quickly--this is critical for political yard signs, just like it is for billboard design. The letterforms would benefit from a bit of kerning--which is optically adjusting the spacing between pairs of individual glyphs. For instance, the "A" and "V" in "DAVID" need to be a bit tighter together, especially given the color shift used in the name. The script face used for "Your" seems a bit out of place formally with the rest of the sign, but overall a pretty good effort.
Mark: Strong royal blue and black on white text for high contrast. San serif, bold, angular, all capital text suggesting that this candidate is serious, no nonsense. The DA of DAVID is blue for District Attorney - Brilliant. Also, no bleed around the border, everything is contained on the sign, nice and neat, black and white, right and wrong, just like the law (depending on how you see it of course).
Phil: The clear winner for the Albany County DA primary sign primary is David Soares. The very simple two color design using plenty of white space feels fresh compared to the dark blue and yellow palette of Kindlon. Also, the "DA" concept in David is much more clever and less forced than the awkward star in the "K" of Kindlon.
Doug: [The typeface] Futura is drawn based on the utopian ideology of pure geometry--many of its letterforms use straight lines and perfect triangles and circles. This makes forcing a 5-pointed star into the capital "K" an interesting, although clunky, visual choice. It's surprising that Lee Kindlon, battling the better known incumbent DA David Soares, would choose to omit his first name from his yard signs. Viewed from a distance, the word "DEMOCRAT" challenges "Kindlon" for hierarchy one--or the first thing a viewer will read when engaging a text. This results from the word being "knocked out" of the large yellow rectangle in an all caps blue text. I would argue that the proper hierarchy for this sign should read: Lee Kindlon, Democrat, Albany County DA. A bit of typographic love and better use of scale could accomplish this rather easily. Also, let's lose the yellow star in the "K," it affects readability in a negative way and adds little to the design as a whole.
Mark: Watch out, this guy uses a star, we have star power here. Nice orange blue combo to suggest his connection to the making of NYS license plates by people he's put away maybe? Maybe not?What the hell do I know, after all they are just colors right. What's this guys first name? Is it a guy? This signs not telling me any of that, but I have a feeling he's a DEMOCRAT!
Winner: David Soares
State Senate 43rd
Doug: I was hoping to find some questionable shading around the edges of this particular image against the grass on the ground to prove that this sign is simply a retouched fake, and doesn't exist in reality. I was unable to find those clues of a visual forgery, so I'll have to assume this design is actual, and not only did someone typeset it, but someone else approved and paid for it. This is troubling to me.
Mark: What is up with the overlapping first names on these Senate signs? Scribble McDonald underlined thin to thick is running for Senate. Go ahead, read that website fast... you can't do it, can you.
Doug: Unfortunately for candidate Marchione, the designer of her political yard sign decided that anamorphicaly scaling--or stretching the letterforms in her last name would be a good method to increase legibility. ZZZZZTT! Bad idea; typefaces are not designed to be stretched in one direction, ever. This is Typography 101. To add insult to typographic injury, throw in a non sequitur informal script face for her first name, and finish off this sign with a slogan set in Century Gothic, one of the clunkiest sans ever created. I'm going to have a hard time sleeping now.
Mark: What do you do with a 'y' that just won't stop overlapping your last name no matter where you put it? You make the first name all caps. But then someone on Kathy's team (or Kathy herself) tells you that 'Kathy' really needs to be in lower case, and in a fun curvy font. So you get this, an 'R' getting it's eye poked. Can we really count on this font... can we?
Phil: Sorry, but there are no winners in the State Senate 43rd category. They both try and connect with us on an emotional level by putting their first names in a poor handwritten typeface. I'm not buying it.
Winner: no one
State Senate 44th
Doug: In theory, I should dislike this particular application: two inappropriate, poorly-kerned typefaces [Times New Roman-bold and Arial-bold] knocked out of a blue field with a predictable white star and overly thick linear elements. There's something about it, however, that makes me want to try to attempt to work out a way in which I might be able to, after a while, begin to like this. It's simple, legible, to the point, and--given the aesthetic many of the other signs this year have taken--somewhat distinctive. It's not asking the reader to do too much, just remember "Breslin, State Senate." I've kerned those glyph pairs in my mind, and imagined the star and lines 25% smaller. OK, I like it now. Am I softening in my old age? The horror...
Mark: Another hypnotizing star sign, but this is simple, easy to read, and willing to introduce a whole new bright green into the color scheme. No website or first name needed apparently.
Phil: Breslin's sign for 44th State Senate has a huge lead over Shawn Morse. It's a very nice, centered layout with knock-out type that successfully combines serif and sans-serif typefaces. The word Breslin is the obvious anchor in this design unlike Morse [below] where you feel lost and confused what to focus on. Just don't look at the wacky red and blue stripes at the bottom, they suck.
Doug: This is not a good design, let me explain: 2 weights of the same typeface [Aachen-bold], some all-caps, some mixed case, predictable colors, etc... but what really makes this a formal disaster is the scale. Establishing a messaging hierarchy in signage applications such as these is paramount. As viewers drive by, the designer must engage them and make their eyes move to the messaging, reading the words in the intended order. There are numerous methods at the designer's disposal to accomplish this, such as type style, location and color, but what's noticeably missing here is proper scale. All the elements in this design are roughly the same size on the sign blank. By 'filling' the space, the viewer is unsure where to enter the piece, or where to exit. This lack of messaging hierarchy will cause the text to be read less, with significant less comprehension.
Mark: Some signs a just plain ugly. This one wins the most conflicting message through design award. Democrat is in red. The font reminds me of a wanted poster from the old west. The only change here is from red to blue with a headache inducing non predicting pattern. Two big underlining marks with the red on top. Thankfully this is the last sign, I need a nap. Wake me on election day please.
Winner: Neil Breslin
Here's the second part of the design primary with results for the Assembly 108th, Assembly 109th, and Assembly 110th.
Many thanks to Doug Bartow, Mark Gregory, and Phil Pascuzzo for their time and critiques.
Senate 43rd yard sign photos: Peter O'Toole. (Thanks!)
We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.