The Kinderhook Creature and other Monsters of New York

bigfoot photo illustration

Did you see that?

Bruce Hallenbeck remembers watching Frankenstein with his cousin when he was just five years old. "I wasn't frightened... I was fascinated."

These days Hallenbeck's fascination with monsters extends into the real world. When he's not working with microfilm and genealogy at the New York State Library, Hallenbeck writes books about horror movies and what he refers to as "real-life monsters" -- monsters of the bigfoot and Loch Ness variety.

A few years ago Hallenbeck wrote Monsters of New Jersey, and his is newest book -- Monsters of New York -- looks into the existence of creatures such as Champ, the Adirondack Bigfoot, the Kinderhook Creature and other creatures he believes are walking, crawling, and swimming around the Empire State. The book is the basis for an exhibit on display this month at the New York State Library.

Hallenbeck took some time out to talk with AOA about his search for these real world monsters, why he finds them so fascinating, and his own encounter with The Kinderhook Creature.

Bruce Hallenbeck

You write books about horror movies and about these [said to be] real world monsters. What's the connection between these two subjects for you?

I think my interests in horror movies and real-life "monsters" are inextricably linked. I've always been fascinated by strange creatures, be they werewolves, vampires or Frankenstein monsters. Discovering that there were undiscovered creatures that actually exist (if they actually do) is a little bit like finding out that Santa Claus is real.

So then, you do believe these creatures exist?

Well, obviously, I believe there's something to these sightings. I don't think mermaids, unicorns, or gorgons exist, but creatures such as the yeti (which Jane Goodall and Sir David Attenborough both feel is likely to exist), Champ, the Loch Ness Monster, etc. can be explained by science.

Too many reputable people claim to have seen them. Misidentifications are certainly possible; some bigfoot sightings are probably bears, some Champ sightings may be floating logs, and so on. But if even one of these sightings is genuine, then science must admit it doesn't have all the answers... yet.

No one these days is going to believe a digital photo; they're too easily faked. The only thing science will accept will be a specimen, alive or dead. In a way, I'd like there to be closure on what these creatures are; but then the mystery will be gone, and I love a good mystery!

Have you ever seen bigfoot or Champ or any of these creatures?

I don't know that I have seen them. I have experienced the fact that they are around.


monsters of new york book coverMy interest in the Kinderhook Creature has to do with experiences my family and I had in the early 80s with something that was visiting our home. My grandmother saw it, my cousins saw it. I didn't see but I heard vocalizations. Basically a bigfoot-type creature.

On September 24 of 1980 something showed up in my grandparents' backyard and started making some ungodly sound and scared everybody so much that my cousin came over with a shotgun and scared it off. He said it was walking on two legs. If you experience something you can't explain you can either say my eyes and ears are playing tricks on me or there is something really out there.

We tape recorded a vocalization that we sent to Cornell -- they have a library of animal sounds, which is a database where they can play this against recordings of other animal sounds. They couldn't identify what it was but they said it was something that was not native to Northeast New York.

PM Magazine -- a television show at the time -- came out to do a story on it. I think they actually dubbed it the Kinderhook Creature. Around that time there was a series of newspaper articles by Barney Fowler, who wrote for the Times Union and it went on for several months.

Another woman, Barbara -- she doesn't like to use her last name -- describes seeing something seven or eight feet tall with reddish brown hair near Kinderhook. It ran past her car lights and disappeared into a cornfield. It made a sound almost indescribable.

Then, a few years later I joined Joe Zarzynski to look for Champ. When I went to Lake Champlain, basically Joe and his girlfriend would go scuba diving, looking for Champ and I'd be up on the deck with the sonar. I'm a land lubber. And one time I saw a very odd reading. It looked like a big solid mass and when I showed him a printout he looked a little uneasy -- it was sixteen feet long and very dense. Sure, it could have been a school of fish, but it seemed too dense.

Is it frustrating to you that you've been looking so long and have never seen these creatures?

It is indeed frustrating that I haven't seen the Kinderhook Creature, although I feel that I've heard its cries on several occasions. The most memorable was in the summer of 1980, when a friend of mine from England was visiting. As I escorted her out the door of my grandparents' house one night, we both heard the most ungodly sound coming from the nearby woods. It started out as a shriek or howl, turned into a series of guttural sounds and ended in a series of low moans. My English friend turned to me and said, "Is that a typical American sound to hear at night?" I assured her that I had never heard anything like it before!

I have gone on excursions to Whitehall to seek the Adirondack Bigfoot, but didn't see anything there either! I do believe that the sonar reading I got on Lake Champlain that day in 1983 was quite unusual, however. Its shape suggested something like what we would expect Champ to look like.

hallenbeck speaking

What do you tell people who are skeptical about the existence of these creatures?

I think the important thing is to keep an open mind and if you think this is all a hoax that probably means you have not done your homework. There are lots of stories about these monsters. Great stories! I've found old newspaper reports -- and they go back to the 1800s -- for Bigfoot and the Lake Champlain monster. P.T. Barnum actually put out a hit on the Lake Champlain Monster. Great stories. That's what makes the research so much fun.

Three books, lots of research and investigating -- you've put a lot of time into the search for and study of these monsters.

Well, once you have experienced something like this -- as we did in 1980 -- it just kind of possesses you to some extent. You want to find this. You want to go out and search for it. I don't spend all my time doing this now because I don't have that much time. I just saw a picture of an oar fish that was dead -- it's a very rare animal, but it's in the oceans. And a classic example is the coelacanth and it was discovered in the Indian Ocean in 1938 by some fisherman -- and there are still some alive.

Those kinds of things do happen. They are rare, but they happen. And the oar fish can be up to 15 feet long -- now that's what I'd call a sea monster.

But there are things happening -- that's what fascinates me -- that we don't know. One of the things that fascinates me is that we think we know a lot about our planet, but we don't. We know just enough to get by.

This interview was lightly edited and condensed.

Hallenbeck photos courtesy of Bruce Hallenbeck


cryptozoology: where myth becomes...something

I read Bruce's book Monsters of NY and it was excellent. A lot of details, names, locations, etc. Good reporting.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Five Favorites: Albany Archives

Our all-time favorite local Twitter account might be Albany Archives. For years Matt Malette -- no longer anonymous! -- has shared all sorts of interesting... (more)

1984 x 3

Three local venues are part of a nationwide event next Tuesday, April 4 to screen a film adaptation of 1984: The Opalka Gallery on the... (more)

Advice for finding mental health support groups?

K emails: Could anyone offer advice at finding mental health support groups? Or where various AA groups meet? We're hoping that maybe there are some... (more)

Springing for lunch

The food trucks were back along West Capitol Park Thursday. Maybe spring isn't just a rumor.... (more)

The Half Moon Market returns to the Washington Park Lake House in April

The popular Half Moon Market is set for a return to the Washington Park Lake House April 28-30. It describes itself as "unique weekend-long marketplace... (more)

Recent Comments

I am very glad they are moving the bus stop back from the Armory to the Library. The number of near misses from folks turning onto Washington Ave is frightening. I am also happy to hear a mid-block crossing is being installed. There are waaaaay to many people walking down the middle of a 4 lane road not paying attention, hopefully this will give them a safer, faster, path to the other side.

1984 x 3

...has 1 comment, most recently from Tim

Advice for finding mental health support groups?

...has 1 comment, most recently from m

The next life of the EBA building on Lark Street

...has 22 comments, most recently from Gotham

John Mulaney at The Egg -- now at The Palace

...has 2 comments, most recently from capgirl

The Half Moon Market returns to the Washington Park Lake House in April

...has 1 comment, most recently from Tam