Jump to the intro.

New York State electricity generation by fuel

This kind of like a square pie chart of each fuel's share for New York State in 2012. Gray = fossil fuels. Green = not fossil fuels.

nys_electric_generation_by_fuel_tree_map.png

And here's generation by fuel type over the last 10 years:

nys_electric_generation_by_fuel.png

Renewables -- such as wind and solar -- are way at the bottom of that graph. So here's a graph of just renewables -- it doesn't include hydropower (because hydro is already such a large share):

nys_electric_generation_renewables.png

New York State carbon dioxide from electricity generation

nys_electric_generation_CO2.png

And here's the state's CO2 "intensity" for electricity generation -- how much CO2 is produced for each megawatt hour of electricity -- over time. (Note: This chart uses a much more crude measure of intensity -- the intensity for all forms of electricity generation -- than the figures mentioned by the EPA for its new target for New York. The EPA's figures are about CO2 intensity for electricity generated from (generally) fossil fuels.)

nys_electric_generation_CO2_intensity.png

Top 10 highest-capacity power plants

nys_electric_generation_top_10_power_plants.png

The Blenheim-Gilboa plant, on the Schoharie Creek, is "pumped storage"? What? It's basically a way to use water to store the ability to generate electricity. When demand for electricity is low, the plant pumps water to an upper reservoir. When electricity demand soars, and the system needs additional capacity, the plant can then release that water into a lower reservoir to generate power.

Numbers via the US Energy Information Agency New York Electricity Profile 2012.

How New York State generates electricity

air conditioner

That air conditioner compressor isn't going to spin itself.

The biggest source of carbon dioxide emissions in the United States -- almost 40 percent -- is electricity generation. So the Obama administration's announcement this week that the EPA is proposing new emission targets for states in order to reduce CO2 emissions from power plants by 30 percent by 2030 is a big deal.

New York State is line for one of the largest percentage cuts in the nation: a 44 percent decrease in the amount of CO2 emitted by Empire State power plants per megawatt hour of electricity produced. As it happens, New York is is line for such a big cut because it's already moving in that direction, thanks in part to its participation in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative here in the Northeast and the fact that it doesn't rely much on coal for generating power. If New York hits its target, it would be among the states with the smallest carbon emissions per unit of electricity produced. (The EPA rule gives states some flexibility on how to meet their goals.)

Anyway, the news got us interested in how New York State generates electricity -- what are the sources, what are the trends in those sources, the biggest power plants.

So we pulled together some numbers, and here are five charts about the topic (along with a map... because maps).

The charts are above in large format -- click or scroll all the way up.

A few things

+ Natural gas represents about 44 percent of the state's electricity generation. The role of natural gas has soared in recent years as its price has dropped, in large part because of fracking.

+ Meanwhile, the role of coal -- which creates much more pollution than natural gas when used for electricity generation -- has steadily declined. (This has happened elsewhere in the country as well.)

+ Another fuel that's risen sharply in recent years (by percent, if not by total share) is wind power. In 2012 it represented 2.2 percent of electrical generation (coal was 3.4 percent). And it was responsible for generating almost 3,000 percent more megawatt hours than in 2000 (because its role in the year 2000 was very, very, very small).

+ Solar's role is currently extraordinarily tiny. In fact, it doesn't even register in the federal statistics until 2011. But its megawatt hour production increased more than 700 percent between 2011 and 2012 (again, because the starting number was so very, very small).

And maybe that points to a big opportunity. The price of solar systems keeps dropping quickly, and there's been a recent boomlet in residential solar installation -- so much so that power utilities are now looking at the trend with a wary eye because it represents potential competition and could eventually upset funding for the traditional power grid. Each house or business that adds a solar system represents an extraordinarily tiny fraction of the overall picture, but if it becomes more common -- and for whatever reason, we seem to be noticing the systems popping up much more often now -- solar generation could start to really add up.

New York State currently has a tax credit worth as much as $5,000 for residential solar installation.

Comments

The potential issue with solar and wind isn't just as a competition issue (remember that in NY, what you think of as utilities, such as National Grid, do NOT own generation). Their variable nature creates additional issues for the grid, both in terms of voltage/stability (fluctuations in output aren't the friend of stable operations) and a need for more flexible traditional generation units to deal with that variability in output (that means gas). Don't read that as negativity, but as actual issues that need to be overcome, and that everyone has to pay for in order to accomplish greater renewable integration.

The price of cleaner burning natural gas would drop further if Cuomo would stop sitting on his hands and allow it to be produced within NYS. Everyone wants to have their cake and eat it too.

While natural gas power generation runs most efficiently at steady state (big heavy giant spinning metal rotor) nuclear can more or less have the production (speed of the reaction) dialed up or down. It makes it very complimentary to solar and wind, both of which are variable and weather based. (Sunny? Solar. Stormy? Wind. Too stormy? Hydro.) Solar also has the added benefit of having peak generation during the most peak power consumption times (the middle of the day).The larger your installed solar base, the less over all amount of fossil fuel burning sources needed.

Interesting data on power generation. How does this match up with the sources of power used in NY? I seem to recall a large portion of our power comes from hydro, both within NY and Hydro Quebec.

There are dozens, if not hundreds, of small hydro plants dotted across the state generating a few Mw of power each, if my high school science project research of ~40 years ago is still correct. :)

Fascinating. Nice job on the graphics, too.

I find it quite ironic that out of the 10 largest power plants you show here, 6 of them use natural gas and petroleum and yet Gov Cuomo just shut down the possibility of fracking in NY State. Maybe NY should have to pay 10 times the amount for their natural gas that comes from PA and Ohio, or shut down these 6 power plants and put up wind mills and solar panels for the people in New York City.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Mini hot dogs from Pete's Pups

It takes a lot of chutzpah to start a hotdog joint in the Capital Region. We know our hotdogs, especially mini dogs. While other parts... (more)

A big enough Lyft?

Over at NY Mag there's a long profile of Lyft, the taxi-app service that's most publicly been pushing for New York State legislation that would... (more)

For sale: caboose

The realization of your lifelong dream of owning a train caboose approaches: New York State is selling an old caboose via its state surplus eBay... (more)

Solarize Albany

There's a boom in solar energy installations right now, including in the residential market. And all sorts of companies have popped up offering home installations... (more)

Take a different way

One of the takeaways of an analysis of on-time flight arrivals and departures for ALB by the Biz Review's Todd Kehoe: avoid flying through O'Hare.... (more)

Recent Comments

But where else would it go? We need a roadway connecting those areas somewhere or else downtown businesses are doomed. Whats' the alternative, demolishing downtown to put a highway there? I don't think so. 787 is here to stay. I think we need to look at lower hanging fruit solutions and make the best of what we have. ...

For sale: caboose

...has 2 comments, most recently from ethan

Latham Sonic now open

...has 5 comments, most recently from Thepersonalispolitical

Rail, River, Hudson II

...has 5 comments, most recently from Nancy L.

Who lived in the neighborhood knocked down for the Empire State Plaza?

...has 3 comments, most recently from Dave

New York closer to $15/hour for fast food workers?

...has 10 comments, most recently from Joe A