Byrne Dairy ice cream sandwiches

byrne dairy ice cream sandwiches

By Deanna Fox

Though milder weather is apparently on the way, ice cream probably still isn't at the top of your mind.

But, really, any time is a good time for ice cream. And if you need justification, try this one that AOA Mary told me her dad used for wintertime ice cream while she was growing up: Eating food that's roughly the same temperature as the air around you will help offset any unpleasantries that weather or temperature might bring by creating an equilibrium between the temperature of your insides and the temperature of your outsides. (Also: Eating ice cream is, in general, an excellent distraction from what's going around you -- including the cold.)

While we have a bevy of good ice cream places in the Capital Region, Stewart's is perhaps the best known for year-round ice cream availability. But let's not overlook that other great New York State regional dairy, Byrne Dairy, which claims the hearts of Central New Yorkers. (It's the official chocolate milk of the New York State Fair.)

And it has one thing Stewart's doesn't: ice cream sandwiches.

There are no Byrne Dairy outposts in the Capital Region, but several stores do carry their products. It isn't hard to find a half-gallon of Byrne Dairy's chocolate milk locally. And lucky for us, the same is true for the ice cream sandwiches.

These sandwiches aren't the typical sticky, cake-y cookie layers encompassing a slab of bland vanilla ice cream that you might find in any supermarket frozen section. Available in a variety of flavors, Byrne Dairy's sandwiches are instead two large baked cookies (or brownies) that squish a generous swirl of the company's own ice cream. It is ice cream AND (actual) cookies. You don't have to choose between the two.


Byrne Dairy refers to the products as either a "Cookiewich" or "Browniewich," depending on the exterior layers. Cookiewich sandwiches ($1.89) feature chocolate chip cookies, while the brownwieches are self-explanatory. Flavors include the classic cookiewich or browniewich with vanilla ice cream, as well as cookiewiches with chocolate ice cream or vanilla-chocolate twist ice cream. The browniewich is also available with raspberry or mint ice cream.

The ice cream used on the sandwiches almost has the consistency of soft-serve, making the filling light enough to bite into with ease. It means you can eat it right from the freezer without having to let it warm enough to be edible.


But perhaps the biggest difference between Byrne Dairy ice cream sandwiches as other readymade options is that Byrne's offering feels, for lack of better terms, homespun.

And in the Capital Region, we are just as likely to dine based on emotional attachment or personal feeling as we are based on the quality of the thing we are eating. We don't always eat the thing that is qualitatively the "best."

Thankfully with Byrne Dairy ice cream sandwiches, we don't have to choose sentimentality over flavor, because they are very tasty, and when I eat one, I find pleasure both on the palate and in my soul.

For me, Byrne Dairy brings a taste of nostalgia to dessert time. I grew up on Byrne Dairy, the way my kids are growing up on Stewart's ice cream and milk, and ice cream sandwiches were always a special treat that were indulgent without being expensive. So until Stewart's starts making a comparable product, I'll keep a stash of Byrne Dairy's sandwiches in my freezer.

The Byrne Dairy ice cream sandwiches are available at Rite Aid locations around the Capital Region, as well as the Countryside Mart in East Berne, and the Olde Country Store in Schoharie.

Deanna Fox writes about many things, mostly about food. More can be found on her website, Twitter, or Instagram.

More Eat This:
+ Knish at Nibble Inc
+ Éclairs at Sovrana's
+ Tortas at El Mariachi


So where did you buy yours? I've never seen these around these parts, but now I want one!

Similar to, but not nearly as good as Biggy Iggy's or Chewie Louies!

Nice option. Sounds close to natural ingredients. Hannaford used to have a good ice cream sandwich with real ice cream and no corn syrup cake cover, but it went bye bye. Now there is only the wretched flavored milk ice product with the King Corn coat. Amazing how such a wonderfully simple item can be manipulated more than the genetics of crops.

The Rite Aid in East Greenbush doesn't have them. Anyone know where they can be found?

I guess I've never seen these because I avoid Rite Aid like the plague, but I can get over my aversion of the chain for a good ice cream sandwich.

Thanks for the heads up.

Unsurprisingly, they don't have them at the Rite Aid on N. Pearl in Albany either.

I also checked Rite Aid on N. Pearl - perhaps they are just seasonal items?

I checked the 2 rite aids in Clifton park as well as the one in Lansingburg. None have them. I am highly doubtful any Rite Aids in the area carry them currently.

Hi everyone,

I'm sorry for the difficulties you've experienced in finding them. I got mine at the Kwik-Mart in Cobleskill. The PR representative from Byrne Dairy said that products were available at Rite Aids in our area. I will follow-up again with the company and see what I can do about this. Very sorry for all of this.

Thank you - I'm glad to hear you are looking forward to trying the sandwiches!

I checked for them at the Rite Aid on Central Ave near Manning Blvd in Albany. No luck.

Any word on this? I just stopped in at a big RiteAid on the north side of Schenectady and am leaving sad and ice cream sandwich-less. Fortunately I can console myself at Memphis King.

I'm originally from the Syracuse area but didn't have a Byrne Dairy in my hometown until this past year. My sister-in-law got me addicted to these ice cream sandwiches over Christmas! I recently found some at Shoprite in Slingerlands. They were in a box of 4 original cookiewiches near Byrne Dairy ice cream. So good!

Costco sells the original in a box of 12 :)

These are now being carried at the Price Chopper/Market 32 in Brunswick!

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

Old-school cooking and ice cream at Crailo

The Crailo State Historic Site in Rensselaer is hosting two food/cooking-themed events over the next two months: July 21: Summer Seasonals: Dutch hearth cooking and... (more)

What's up in the Neighborhood

Among the topics in this most recent spin around the Capital Region's online neighborhood: tipping, brunch on the farm, DMB weekend, local ice cream history,... (more)

Future fashion

Check out Albany High School grad Taofeek Abijako getting a shoutout from Teen Vogue for being the youngest designer to present a collection at the... (more)

Unicorn bikes for the bike share, a few ridership numbers for this season so far

Updated CDTA announced Wednesday that it will start rolling out "unicorn" bikes as part of the CDPHP Cycle bike share. The bikes have color schemes... (more)

Schenectady shooter arraigned, Skelos & Son convicted in retrial, Guardian Angels plan Albany recruitment, gun show moves to Schenectady

Schenectady shooter arraigned Dushawn Howard was officially charged on Tuesday with three separate counts of second-degree attempted murder in last weeks shooting of his former... (more)

Recent Comments

Wish they open the old McCormick road between Albany and Bethlehem for walkers and bikers so more people would have access to the trail from the Westmere, Albany, and Guilderland side.

Schenectady shooter arraigned, Skelos & Son convicted in retrial, Guardian Angels plan Albany recruitment, gun show moves to Schenectady

...has 2 comments, most recently from EMB

Gawking at the renovation of the long-vacant buildings on Broadway in Albany near the railroad overpass

...has 3 comments, most recently from EMB

Unicorn bikes for the bike share, a few ridership numbers for this season so far

...has 3 comments, most recently from Cait

What's up in the Neighborhood

...has 1 comment, most recently from Chuck Miller

Ghosts on a street that no longer exists

...has 6 comments, most recently from Paula