Historic Albany endangered building list 2015

St Josephs Albany steeple angle 2016-January

St. Joe's is on there.

The latest edition of the Historic Albany Foundation's endangered building list is out. It includes more than 20 historic properties and places the org says "suffer from vacancy and disinvestment or inappropriate development pressure, and are often potential targets for emergency demolition."

HAF releases this list every five years. It says the list is an effort to raise awareness and help find solutions for reuse and preservation.

This time around it's grouped the properties into categories. You'll definitely recognize some of the buildings -- and there might be a few others you didn't even know were there.

Here's a quick overview, along with the list.


+ Vacant religious properties: Most of these are vacant churches that have struggled to find new uses. Example: St. Joseph's in Arbor Hill.

+ Zombie buildings: These are properties that are vacant or unmaintained and seemed to be stuck, in either foreclosure or some state of neglect. Example: 558 Madison Ave (on the corner at New Scotland Ave) -- the building that was once an ice cream parlor.

+ Underutilized municipal buildings: "This theme represents municipal buildings that once served the community and represented public investment and civic pride, but have since fallen into disservice and are unoccupied." Example: Public Bath No. 2 in the South End.

+ Historic commercial districts: HAF identifies both the Warehouse District and Central Ave as historic commercial districts "threatened by inappropriate development which would destroy much of their character" -- advocates for them to be listed as historic districts on the National Register of Historic Places, which could bring rehabilitation tax credits.

+ Rapp Road Historic District: "The Rapp Road settlement is an excellent example of a priceless cultural and architectural resource in the Capital Region, representing a once thriving African American farming community of the mid-20th Century adjacent to the Pine Bush Preserve. Today the site is faced with the threat of outside development, and while already listed on the National Register of Historic Places, a local nomination would protect this precious resources and its unique ecosystem." (Here's more about the history of the neighborhood.)

+ James Hall House: "The Italianate Villa style building, a National Historic Landmark, hidden along the western edge of Lincoln Park was designed for geologist James Hall in 1852 by prominent American architects Andrew Jackson Downing and his student Calvert Vaux. ... Each year the building remains vacant, it will continue to fall deeper into disrepair and is an example of an underutilized resource that is significant at both the local and national level for its architectural and cultural significance."

List and map

These places are mapped above in large format -- click or scroll all the way up.

Vacant religious properties
St. Joseph's Roman Catholic Church - 38 Ten Broeck Street
Herkimer Street Synagogue - 94 Herkimer Street
German Evangelical Church - 82 Clinton Street
St. John's Roman Catholic Church - 142 Green Street
Mount Olive Baptist Church - 226 Northe Pearl Street
Church of the Holy Innocents - 275 North Pearl Street
Krumkill Road Cemetery - Krumkill Road and Bender Ave

Zombie properties
161 Eagle Street
558 Madison Avenue
62 Spring Street
274 New Scotland Avenue
49 Park Avenue
114 Fourth Avenue

Underutilized municipal buildings
Public School 22 - 292 Second Street
Third Police Precinct - 222 North Pearl Street
Bath House No. 2 - 90 Fourth Avenue
Public School 17 - 43 Second Avenue
Central Fire Alarm Station - 25 Delaware Avenue

Historic commercial districts
Warehouse District
Central Avenue business corridor

Rapp Road Historic District
Rapp Road Historic District
31 Rapp Road
54 Rapp Road
59 Rapp Road
Rapp Road Smoke House
Rapp Road community
Rapp Road ecosystem

James Hall House
James Hall House - Lincoln Park

List PDF

HAF 2015 Endangered List


How does one consider a cemetery "vacant"? (Krumkill Rd. and Bender Ave. cemetery.) No longer maintained, perhaps, but not exactly vacant. I tried to drill down to get more specific info on that cemetery on the HAF 2015 Endangered List, but it kind of lumps all the vacant religious properties together.

The Friends of the Evangelical Protestant Cemetery gives more specific information on the history and religious affiliation of this abandoned cemetery and their hope to restore it. The (German) Evangelical Protestant Church was founded in the south end of Albany in 1850 by German immigrants and the cemetery was established in 1854. The church closed in 2010.

The records of the Evangelical Protestant Church, including a register of the plots in the cemetery, are in the New York State Library manuscript collection.

Supposedly this cemetery property is for sale, and given its location of Rt. 85, it's prime real estate (valued at over $1 million). I have no idea what the restrictions are on developing cemeteries. It would be a shame if condos or a shopping center were built there.

I've walked around that cemetery a number of times, but now feel motivated to go back and look more carefully at the gravestones.

Can someone explain the rationale behind 274 New Scotland being on list?

Make St. Joseph's into condominiums.

@Jo - It's listed as a zombie property, meaning it's unoccupied and trapped in probate or foreclosure proceedings.

The church building in the South End and its accompanying cemetery are for sale. I hear that the cemetery goes with the sale of the church building. Yes, it appears to be prime real estate. However I believe that it would be cost prohibitive to remove all of the interments aside from just being plain WRONG to disrupt these souls. As I have read elsewhere, sonar units would have to be brought in to locate unmarked grave sites and an archaeologist would need to be secured and direct the removal of each person.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

Must-do Albany/Troy activities for new arrivals to the Capital Region?

Lindsay emails: Some long-time friends of mine will be moving to the Capital Region in June, and I was looking for some expert/crowd-sourced advice on... (more)

Morning Blend

Marchione to retire State Senator Kathy Marchione announced on Wednesday that she will not run for re-election. Marchione cited family reasons for stepping away from... (more)

Forever wild: The advocacy of Verplanck Colvin

A few dozen miles south of Tupper Lake is some of the most rugged and remote wilderness in New York State. This is where Seward... (more)

The Postal Bank

Kirsten Gillibrand is proposing legislation to spur the creation of a Postal Bank, which would offer banking services in all of the US Postal Service's... (more)

Katherine Applegate at Skidmore

Newbery Medal-winning author Katherine Applegate will be at Skidmore May 8 for an event organized by Northshire Bookstore. She'll be talking about her new book,... (more)

Recent Comments

I have really enjoyed working with SEFCU Insurance Agency and have saved a great deal of money with them. If you are a SEFCU member, you will likely get an additional discount on top of bundling (auto+property, etc.) and other discounts most insurers offer. ...

The plan to fix a problem in Albany that's been a century in the making -- and the concerns about that fix

...has 10 comments, most recently from BethAM

Forever wild: The advocacy of Verplanck Colvin

...has 2 comments, most recently from Lisa D.

An end for plastic shopping bags in New York?

...has 4 comments, most recently from chrisck

The Postal Bank

...has 1 comment, most recently from Herbert

Approval for another big apartment project, Warehouse District reuse, Pine Hills demos, and more exciting tales of the Albany planning board

...has 9 comments, most recently from Corky