Jump to the intro.

Maps

Please see the note below about the creation of these maps.

Census tract-to-tract commutes of less than 100 miles

PLOS_megaregion_paper_tract-to-tract.jpg

Regions based on an analysis of commuter flows

PLOS_megaregion_paper_commuting_regions.jpg

The researchers generated this map by running the data through algorithm to help determine areas that are clustered together into regions by connections forms by commuting flows. (Again, as mentioned below, the researchers note these sorts of analyses are based on choices and assumptions baked into the algorithm, so this is one interpretation of the data.)

Commutes between communities

PLOS_megaregion_paper_intercommunity_commutes.jpg

This map shows every commute where the assigned destination and the assigned origin are in different communities. As the researchers write: "This gives a sense of just how incorrect it is to call these partitioned communities truly ‘independent’ or autarchic in terms of their economic geography. For instance, the northeastern seaboard, the Great Lakes, and California are heavily interlinked by commutes which stretch across regions."

Regional map

PLOS_megaregion_paper_regions_national_map.png

PLOS_megaregion_paper_regions.png

The researchers created this map of regional designations by combining many of the techniques they used while sorting through the commuting data, using both algorithms and human interpretation. We also included the full national map because we thought you might find that interesting and it'd provide some context for the map clip of this part of the country.

What if Albany is upstate, but not "Upstate"?

commuting regions map New York State

What are we really talking about when we use the term "Capital Region"? Is it a geographic place? A population of people? A set of economic connections? A culture?

That's one of the questions we were thinking about while looking over a recent attempt by researchers to define megaregions and lay out a "functional economic geography of the United States." The work -- by Garrett Dash Nelson of Dartmouth and Alasdair Rae of the University of Sheffield (UK) -- takes a ton of Census data about commuting patterns and processes it into a series of maps. It's published in PLOS One.

So, let's have a look at those maps for this area, along with a few thoughts about the results.

Look up

Map clips are above in large format -- click or scroll all the way up.

About the maps

As mentioned, the researchers used Census data from 2006-2010 for commuting trips between census tracts. And they processed and analyzed this data using a variety of mapping techniques and algorithms. In fact, a large part of the paper is about the various strengths and weaknesses of these approaches. Boiled down a lot, the researchers basically conclude there's no single best way to do this, but they've tried to use a set of techniques to create maps that are helpful.

The full (open) version of the paper walks through these details and also includes full national maps.

And for a quick, not very technical overview of the paper, Wired has a write-up.

A few things

The structure of the Capital Region
One of the defining geographic characteristics of the Albany metro area is that it doesn't really have a clear, single center. So the "shape" of this region is a streak stretching from Glens Falls to south of Albany, with Schenectady and Amsterdam pulling to the west.

That's in contrast to many other metros around the country that are more or less central hubs with radiating spikes. (The PLOS One paper focuses on Minneapolis as a prominent example of this starburst metro shape.)

Of course, this isn't a new observation -- this area has been like that for a long time. But it highlights how this place isn't necessarily like other places. And it adds some different development challenges. (If you could combine many of the aspects of Albany, Schenectady, and Troy into one place, you'd have a pretty great urban area. But... you can't.)

The Capital Region's relationship to the rest of Upstate
Another thing that sticks out in the various maps is how the Albany metro sort of stands apart from the rest of Upstate. And in some interpretations, it's more closely linked with Western Massachusetts and Vermont than, say, Syracuse.

We've always thought that Albany was somehow different from Syracuse, Rochester, and Buffalo -- that Albany leaned more toward New York City and the East Coast, while those other cities seemed more like they belonged to the Great Lakes. Maybe there really is something to that.

If anything, it's a reminder that "Upstate" is a big place and it's probably wise to not make generalizations about what sort of place Upstate is or is not.

Vermont
You know, Vermont was once part of (colonial) New York. Maybe it sort of still kind of is. (Don't tell Vermont that.) Or maybe Albany and eastern New York are still sort of part of Vermont. (Don't tell Albany that.) Maybe the Capital Region and Burlington need to talk more.

Also: This apparent connection between this part of New York and Vermont reminded us of the data from a recent NYS Attorney General's report indicating Vermont was one of the hot spots from which "likely trafficked" guns came to the Capital Region.

High-speed rail
One other quick thought: There's long been talk of maybe, potentially, someday running high-speed rail along a path that more or less follows I-90, so that it would connect NYC, Albany, Syracuse, Rochester, and Buffalo.

Complications and cost -- of which there are many -- aside, the Albany-New York City link seems obvious. That route is already highly traveled on the existing rail line. And this analysis of connections does't seem to provide any argument against it.

But... What about Albany to Buffalo? It makes sense when you look at a traditional map, but maybe it makes less sense when considering connections among those major cities. That said, if you could hop a train in Syracuse and be in Albany in less than an hour, maybe more connections start to form.

Comments

You ask about - what is the "Capital Region"? In 1982, I created and published a magazine named "Capital Region Life" . This was before anyone was even talking about a "Capital Region" and in it I defined what the "Capital Region" consisted of and devoted my stories to all of it. If you would like a copy, send me an e.mail I will mail you one (I published 6 editions - then got married to a man who was not interested in it - so, I put it on hold and so far, have never returned to it)
I believe it has on the introductory page the best definition of the Capital Region that exists - and does the most to tie it all together and promote the "region" as a whole. I hope you are interested. Let me know. DLH

Confirms the theory that all of New Jersey is either a NYC or Philadelphia suburb.

For a lack of better terms (but slightly better than the broad brush of 'Upstate'), I have always called the Albany region the 'Middle East' of NY

I grew up in the Utica area and moved out here in 1998. It really is funny how different the cultures are less than 100 miles away.

It's more laid back in the Utica/Syracuse area, and the culture is much more "country" whereas Albany and a lot of the are around it is much more fast paced and has more of a NYC influence. Both are nice places to live, but definitely different vibes.

At SUNY Albany I used to have countless arguments with one of my Long Island roommates about "Upstate" ... he would say "I'm not from Upstate like Paul" (who was from Suffern) and I would scream back "That's not upstate, Paul lives 5 minutes north of Jersey!!!". All about your perspective I guess.

The regional designation map includes Sullivan, Ulster, Dutchess, Orange, Putnam, Rockland, and Westchester counties (as well as Nassau and Suffolk counties, of course) as part of the NYC metro-area.

Does this add any clarity to what constitutes "Upstate" verses "Downstate" geographically?

>>Or maybe Albany and eastern New York are still sort of part of Vermont. (Don't tell Albany that.) >>

I dunno ... there are a lot of us that wouldn't mind being lumped in with VT! :) (If only it was as quirky and the beer was as good ... but, at least on the latter point, we are getting there pretty quickly!)

>>>Or maybe Albany and eastern New York are still sort of part of Vermont. (Don't tell Albany that.)

At this moment I don't even mind being lumped in with Canada. At least for the next 4 years

"I dunno ... there are a lot of us that wouldn't mind being lumped in with VT!"

I escaped Vermont. Please don't make me part of it again.


Upstate is anything north of I90 and/or west of I88. :)

Interesting map. I don't know anyone who would agree with the label of 'Hudson Valley'.

How about we start with a normal train line connecting Albany and Boston...

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Nutella bacon bagel at Wired Coffee

There are certain foodstuffs that really only exist for those moments when you just don't care about life anymore. Those items that make it hard... (more)

That's a 5-point shot, right?

Ahmad doing Ahmad things. pic.twitter.com/p7FJ22NsbS— UAlbany Basketball (@UAlbanyMBB) December 12, 2017 UAlbany's Ahmad Clark was working on extending his range ahead of Tuesday night's... (more)

Scanning the 2018 Tanglewood season lineup

It's cold and snowy, but summer will return. Eventually. With that in mind, we were looking over the schedule for the next season at Tanglewood.... (more)

Holiday gifts: Alexandra Stafford

Gifts and giving are on most everyone's mind this month. So we're again asking people to share some thoughts on presents, past and present, charities... (more)

What's up with the Albany Skyway, and a few bits about plans to makeover a key piece of downtown

The Albany Skyway project -- which aims to turn a lightly-used off-ramp into a linear park connecting downtown Albany with the riverfront -- is set... (more)

Recent Comments

My husband and I took a couples massage class a few years ago around Valentines Day at Om Shanti Healing Arts. Not sure if it's offered year round but worth an ask.

What's up with the Albany Skyway, and a few bits about plans to makeover a key piece of downtown

...has 4 comments, most recently from Ian Benjamin

Where to take a couples massage class?

...has 3 comments, most recently from Heather

Holiday gifts: Jammella Anderson

...has 1 comment, most recently from BS

Where to cut your own Christmas tree 2012

...has 9 comments, most recently from MB

Icy, Snowy Apocalypse Watch

...has 2 comments, most recently from Daleyplanit