One critique of the proposed 1 Monument Square design, raised up one level

The conversation over the design of the proposed movie theater at 1 Monument Square is ramping up again, and will continue to do so as the project goes before the Troy Planning Commission July 26. [TU]

One of the criticism of the design is, essentially, a big, windowless box that blocks the river from the street (a wide outdoor stair would connect to the street level and riverfront).

So we thought the video clip embedded above was interesting -- it's by an architectural designer from Niskayuna named Tai Xi posted the design and video earlier this year as a way offering feedback. (It was highlighted by the We Care About the Square Twitter account this week.) In the design, the movie theater space would be raised up one level to create a covered plaza that extends from the the street out toward the river.

Here's a bit more about Xi's design, and a quick thought on how we all discuss these sorts of things...

The Xi design

We got in touch with Xi this week to ask, essentially, how the design in the video came about. Xi's response via email (we've broken it into paragraphs):

Among the tri-city, Troy is the most beautiful one, thanks to the better preserved urban layout, authentic architecture and interesting topography. She deserves better buildings of both quality design and construction.
So far, to fill the void at 1 Monument Square, several winning proposals seem fall short on grasping the essence of the site. When there is no vision with clarity based on the consensus of various stake holders, all becomes a guesswork in the dark. No wonder it's so hard to pin down a good scheme. As a trained architectural designer (also a licensed Architect in Ontario, Canada), I can't help to do some critiques in my counter proposals.
In the latest Bowtie cinemas episode, I can see the most damning mistake is putting a blank big box right on the ground level of River St creates a long and tall wall facing the square. How to salvage the proposal as it is? Quite simple, elevating the cinema box to the second floor so that the street level can be freed up for more animated uses. This is a proven solution; one can find many real life examples in big cities.
This setup does cost a bit more, however, to build a landmark in a historical city has never meant to be cheap. The prestige shall worth some extra investment even in the all-for-profit business world.

Tai Xi said he reached out to the city about the design idea, but never heard back.

How we discuss this stuff

One Monument Square Conceptual Renderings 2017-April 1 cropped
One of the renderings of the project proposed by Bonacio Construction and Bow Tie Cinemas.

In our email exchange, Xi added this point at the end: "To generate more meaningful dialogue, we need a more effective platform driven by Google Earth 3D model and graphic comments. Casual writeup without concrete graphic reference can hardly move things forward to reach a satisfactory conclusion."

We thought that was interesting because it gets at one of the frequent frictions when these sorts of projects get introduced to, and discussed by, the public: It's a lot to easier to say "I don't like this" than it is to show what people would like instead.

And that's totally understandable. There aren't a lot of people who have the skill and time to crank out their rendering of a building. And, frankly, trying to crowdsource the design of a building -- no matter how big or small -- sounds like a recipe for a bad outcome.

But there's also gotta be a better way for municipalities to gather feedback. Sure, people can go to the planning board/commission meetings and say something during the public comment periods. That's admirable and useful. Again, though, that format probably leans more toward "no, not that" and away from "more like this." People -- even critics! -- often want to offer constructive feedback. They just don't have good tools to do so.

We don't know if there's an answer for resolving this friction. It just seems like we all should be able to do better given the proliferation of digital media.

How to offer feedback

We got in touch with John Salka, the spokesman for the city of Troy, about Xi's design and offering feedback. Salka pointed to people participating in the planning commission process, and he said the commission is accepting written comments via email -- they should be sent to Chris Brown in the planning department at

Feedback can also be submitted via mail:

City of Troy
c/o Planning Department
433 River Street
Troy, NY 12180


Site of the extant cast iron facade Warren Building, this cinema will be a generator for activity downtown. Nineteenth century Troy like many industrial cities, turned its back to the waterfront and its potential now gets a second chance. Site lines of the water feature are important as are the functional aspects of a design but how apparent was that criteria at the programming phases to have avoided these often late in the day critiques? This design relies on the architectural technique of circuitous seduction through level changes to reach the Hudson ... Lighting will be important and I'm certain its been factored in.

Is it really that difficult???? Seriously! This cluster---k makes me yearn for the old brutalist city hall to be rebuilt!

Ok phase one of the design is great having that open cause way or I would plaza is great idea. Plus here are the pluses to that raised level. Lets say the river floods over it banks. It won't destroy the bulk of the equipment that is used to operate the movies. Being raise allows the river to come threw the first floor. I would make that first level has concert so it will be easier to clean. I mean look at this way would you rather pressure wash concert and glass walls railing. Opposed to replacing multiple movie screens and projectors that could cost way more than a pressure washer. Granted the main entrance might get hit but some principal make sure you clean it with a pressure and soap then replacing expensive equipment. It still give troy a river front view of the Hudson. And the design in my eyes from what I say is a great render. Having a plaza near the river will add to modern movie theater and have benches for people to enjoy that river front. Look at this way in the end it will be better way to give the best of both worlds. But I noticed you can not please every one anymore. The city need little more modern stuff to bring it in to the new century and beyond. Still keep the structure of the classic troy buildings. Add more of the rustic looking front to blend in to rest of the area. Give the troy feeling like it belonged there and it was meant to be. Blending it to other buildings. and still stand out with diversity of the design will give it the look. So maybe adding the building with fake windows and floors and blended it in like it was it built years ago. I mean there are many options. People need to speak up and say what instead of no to this no to that. that are a few of my input

Here's an idea for One Monument Square to be a new home for The Children's Museum of Science and Technology + City Hall, along with a redeveloped Riverfront Park. There are a few photos.

I agree with everything Xi and AOA state in the article. Lifting Bow Tie wouldn't gain my support for the project, but it's an improvement.

Does Troy City Hall and City Council understand the substantial value of Troy's aforementioned beauty and burgeoning culture?

For decades, outsiders had plenty of valid reasons to avoid Troy, yet negatives often ended with - but we love the architecture and wish we had more reasons to visit downtown.

Now, Troy's government is willing to blemish the only redeeming factor Troy had for a generation, and in the location where Troy's resurgence birthed from that quality?

Downtown has areas where a large, windowless box for movie theaters could be located so that Troy still gains from Bow Tie's business without devaluing a historic area and underutilizing prime riverfront property.

Would Bow Tie's business be more successful if located at One Monument Square than elsewhere downtown? Maybe. Is that gain to Bow Tie / Troy more important than preserving the successful value that Monument Square currently possesses? I don't think so.

Is there value to a city, its residents, collectively owning a prime piece of property in their city? And more value if what's built there is a genuine point of pride for the city's residents?

"Lighting will be important and I'm certain its been factored in."

Exactly my thought; who enjoys walking through a parking garage at night? Seems that's what this would feel like. It's certainly a creative solution, though I'm not familiar with the examples in other cities that Xi mentions, any pointers in that direction would be welcomed.

I still don't know why it has to look like a spaceship. There are countless downtown theaters that fit in aesthetically with their surroundings. I was just in Arlington, Massachusetts and they have a six screen theater in a building fronted with a bakery, a toy store, a salon... Thinking that theaters can only look like suburban malls shows either a lack of imagination or a lack of awareness.

Maybe Chris Brown could arrange to have an interactive video set up at the Planning Commission meeting. This would enable people to make suggestions and see how they would look in real time. Use the technology that is available and stop the bickering for the love of Troy!

American movie ticket sales in terms of tickets sold have been flat or declining over the last couple of decades. Revenues are up slightly, but only because they keep raising ticket prices. The location does not have good parking options and the design does not fit with the rest of the area.
Some investors may make some money in the short run, but in the long run it will end up being a white elephant just like the city hall building was. Haste makes waste! Waite for a better solution. Please!

Movie theaters have experiences a sharp decline in attendance over the last few years, a trend that is gaining momentum as more and more online streaming services are developing and producing top notch entertainment.

Building a megaplex cinema in downtown Troy is not only a bad idea, it’s extremely shortsighted and a terrible business decision.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

Private dorm opposition, a big downtown residential conversion, and other exciting tales of the Albany Planning Board

Exciting Tales of the Albany Planning Board is a program recorded before a live studio audience in Albany City Hall once a month in which... (more)

Stuff to do this weekend

Welcome to that transitional weekend when we go from falling leaves to holiday lights. This is also the last weekend before the holiday craziness sets... (more)

Morning Blend

Trial in the death of Noel Alkaramla The jury in now deliberating in the the trial of Johnny Oquendo -- accused of killing Noel Alkaramla... (more)

Today's moment of architecture

Architecture moods around West Capitol Park Thursday night: The Capitol: LOOK AT ME! The Smith Building: I just want to efficiently finish this file and... (more)

The Regrettes at The Low Beat

Garage rock band The Regrettes are set to play a show at The Low Beat December 6. Tickets are $10 and available online. The band's... (more)

Recent Comments

My grandmother has Alzheimers and sometimes comes to stay with us in Troy. Last week the absolutely highlight of her day was seeing the hundreds of crows that came streaming by the window at our apartment. I watched her go from completely unresponsive to engaged... stringing questions together and returning to her old joyful self for the half hour she watched those birds was enough to endear crows to me forever.

If you see someone running around throwing bird seed in Riverfront Park yelling "COME ON DOWN, BIRD FRIENDS!", it's me.

A few more details about the proposed mixed-use development near St. Peter's hospital

...has 19 comments, most recently from BS

Morning Blend for Nov 17

...has 1 comment, most recently from Summer

Today's moment of architecture

...has 3 comments, most recently from -B

The ethics of dropping your dog's poop in a neighbor's garbage can

...has 38 comments, most recently from Howz

The Regrettes at The Low Beat

...has 1 comment, most recently from Brian