The city of Troy wants to plan for the future of 1 Monument Square. Again.

1 Monument Square site 2016-08-25

The site back in 2016.

This all sounds familiar.

The city of Troy says it's aiming hold a three-day public design event -- a charrette -- about the future of the 1 Monument Square site. Press release blurbage:

Mayor Patrick Madden said, "The design charrette process offers a fresh start for the redevelopment of Monument Square. With assistance and input from our community, we can create a collective vision for the site that respects Troy's unique and historic character while enhancing our city's valuable assets and expanding access to our unique waterfront location."
A charrette is an intensive planning and design session where residents, business owners, designers and other stakeholders collaborate on a vision for development. A design charrette provides a forum for ideas which offers a unique opportunity to give designers immediate feedback while creating mutual authorship among participants in the plan. The City is not advancing any predetermined concepts with the exception of a 50-foot deep esplanade along the Hudson River and connection from the esplanade to River Street.

The city has issued an RFP for a consultancy to hold the event, which does not have a date:

The selected team will lead a three-day charrette open to all members of the community to create a public consensus for the site's use and anticipated redevelopment - including construction details for the southward expansion of Riverfront Park and its connection to the business district on River Street. Developers interested in the redevelopment of the site are encouraged to attend.

There have been four major attempts to redevelop the site in downtown Troy -- one of the most high-profile pieces of real estate in the entire Capital Region -- since the demolition of the old city hall in 2011. Two of those attempts have ended in situations involving the threat of legal action. That includes the proposal to build a Bow Tie movie theater there, which stalled out last October.

It's worth noting that the city already held an event similar to this design charrette back in 2016 under the current administration.

So there are some important questions here that are one step removed from the actual use and design of the site. Among them:

+ Is it possible right now to pull together some sort of bulletproof public consensus early on that's not vulnerable to a prominent stakeholder becoming irked and essentially vetoing the project?

+ Because of the history, what sorts of developers are willing to take on the project?

+ And are there maybe completely different ways of going about developing this site that haven't been tried already?


We all know this will inevitably end up as a parking garage.

This will likely be the centerpiece of Troy's effort to win the Downtown Revitalization Initiative. A developer led plan may not be needed at all and the project can be spearheaded by the public, satisfying many in the community. The site and the City certainly meet the criteria. As mentioned above, this statement is also included: "The City is not advancing any predetermined concepts with the exception of a 50-foot deep esplanade along the Hudson River and connection from the esplanade to River Street." The lack of this assurance is what's caused much of the disdain for plans in the past.

Plus ca change, plus c'est la meme chose.

What about a movie theater? Seems like it would be a good fit with all of the restaurants, bars, and nearby colleges.

RS: Bullseye! It's a no brainer. Give the bars and restaurants downtown an economic boost by bringing in an entertainment element that has been nonexistent in the city of Troy for decades. Parking is ample with the Uncle Sam garage and State Street garage close by. Fill in that concrete void with something nice architecturally, and have people understand that it does not have to match the surrounds exactly (and that movie theaters tend not to have a multitude of windows). You are a genius! RS in 2020!!

Faneuil Hall is Boston"s permanent Farmer's Market. Why not use that model here inTroy, it is a walking city.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

A few of the 700some stories about the street names of Albany

There are 785 streets in the city of Albany. And Erik Schlimmer has figured out the backstory for the name of almost every one of... (more)

Trey Anastasio's new band Ghosts of the Forest is playing The Palace

A new band headed up by Trey Anastasio -- Ghosts of the Forest -- is set to play The Palace April 9. Tickets go on... (more)

Where to buy firewood?

Wade asks: I'm looking for a reliable source of high quality seasoned firewood. Does anybody have a firewood guy they would recommend? Delivery preferred but... (more)

Walk/don't walk

In an opinion piece over at the Times Union, Walkable Albany's Andrew Neidhardt urges the city of Albany to change its use of pedestrian signal... (more)

Chad Orzel: Breakfast With Einstein

Check it out: Union College physics professor/science writer Chad Orzel has a new book out today called Breakfast with Einstein: The Exotic Physics of Everyday... (more)

Recent Comments

I've seen a steady increase in cycling trips along Madison Ave. after the road diet. I've been one of those riders, too. It's made summertime trips from my house to the Point on Madison that much faster than walking, and there's really no need to drive that short distance - thereby saving a spot for another patron. I've not only enjoyed the F out of the trip, but burned a few calories, too, which considering my diet, is much needed. I'm very very pleased with this effort and thank CDTA, CDPHP and CDTC for their efforts in making this happen. I'm resolving to make MORE trips in 2019!

A miniature Albany

...has 8 comments, most recently from Beverly Huba McCasland

A few of the 700some stories about the street names of Albany

...has 1 comment, most recently from chrisck

Walk/don't walk

...has 3 comments, most recently from K

A large, interesting party space in Albany?

...has 4 comments, most recently from Jamie

Bike share grew in both use and reach this year -- here's what CDTA's thinking about for next year

...has 8 comments, most recently from Bobby bikes a lot, IN TROY!!!