Albany bashing has a long history

North Pearl Street 1800s

Was Pearl Street dead back in the day?

By Carl Johnson

The recent item proclaiming Albany to be one of America's 10 dead cities was just the latest in a long tradition of bashing our capital city.

Who knows when Albany-bashing began, but I found evidence of it that dates back to 1789, and is a kind of reminder that in all criticism, you have to consider the source.

When our new nation was finally ratifying the Constitution (which perhaps took its earliest form in the Albany Plan of the Union,), Dr. Jedidiah Morse published his "American Geography," one of the first comprehensive textbooks on the subject. In it, Morse, one of the earliest recognized names in American education, expressed an unreserved dislike for the people of the oldest city in the colonies:

"Albany is said to be an unsociable place. This is naturally to be expected. A heterogeneous collection of people, invested with all their national prejudices, eager in the pursuit of gain, and jealous of a rivalship, can not expect to enjoy the pleasures of social intercourse or the sweets of an intimate and refined friendship."

Okay, so Morse wasn't big on diversity. He also wasn't big on the Dutch:

"To form a just idea of the manners and customs of the inhabitants, we must confine ourselves to the Dutch, who being much the most numerous, give the tone to the manners of the place. Two things unite more particularly to render these disagreeable to foreigners; first, a natural prejudice which we all possess in favor of our own, and against the manners of another place or nation; secondly, their close union, like the Jews of old, to prevent the innovation of foreigners, and to keep the balance of interest always in their own hands."

In fairness to Morse, he did admit that those observations were not his own, but from a "gentleman of observation and discernment, who resided some time in Albany." Still, to go on with this diatribe, he must have agreed with them:

"Their diversions are walking and sitting in mead-houses, and in mixed companies they dance. They know nothing of the little plays and amusements common to small social circles. The gentlemen who are lively and gay, play at cards, billiards, chess, &c., others go to the tavern, mechanically, at 11 o'clock - stay until dinner, and return in the evening."

So, Morse's problem with Albany? An unsociable place, but also a diverse party town. With mixed dancing.

I'm so ashamed.

(Jedidiah, by the way, had a son named Samuel -- the noted painter and inventor of Morse code.)

The first version of this post included a typo for the publication date for "American Geography." It's 1789, not 1879

image: James Eights via Wikipedia


I'd say we still pretty much have some of the same diversions (although I'd love a mead-house), except we've got Cap Rep Theater to class us up a little bit.

Do our lively and gay men still play cards and billiards?

The first thing that crossed my mind when I saw this piece was a letter that Colonel Kosciuszko wrote to General Gates' wife shortly after the Battles of Saratoga. In it, he mentioned how glad she must be to leave Albany and that she was "no longer among Dutch Society so gloomy and serious."

Glad to know I'm not a trend setter, but following a rich legacy.

Looks like Daniel B. has been reincarnated.
I kid, I kid.

We have lots of local brewers (Browns comes to mind)- do those count as mead-houses?

Alternatively, perhaps we can start our own mead houses- does anyone know the recipe for mead? I've wanted to try home-brewing for awhile.

Yes- technically mead is not a beer. According to wikipedia, it's a mixture of honey, water, and yeast. mmm, sounds delicious.

You can get mead in some wine stores. I really wanted to like it for it's historic value, but the stuff it just too sweet. Ack.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

Gawking at the new Schenectady train station

In a bit of a surprise the new Schenectady train station opened this past Wednesday, a few weeks ahead of the announced schedule. The $23... (more)

A little push up the hill

Wrapped into my update this past week about what it's been like to use a bike as one of my primary ways of getting around... (more)

A collection of castle day trips

This part of the country is dotted with castle-like structures, full of history, mystery, romance, and fairytale. Here's a handful of castles that are within... (more)

Classics of Science Fiction at The Linda

A multi-day get-together called Classics of Science Fiction will be at The Linda in Albany November 1-4. Blurbage: Guests include authors, artists, podcasters, cosplayers, business... (more)

Cuomo leads in Q-poll, NTSB still hasn't examined limo from deadly Schoharie crash, Schenectady and GE

Q-poll shows Cuomo with strong lead The latest Quinnipiac University poll shows Andrew Cuomo with a 23-percentage point lead over Republican challenger Marc Molinaro. [Spectrum]... (more)

Recent Comments

I ride every day to work, and also after work for exercise. I love the concept of being a person who happens to ride a bike. There's a level of bike riding, with the high performance gear and sleek clothing, that makes riding seem like its not for everyone. I try to avoid markers like that, and always wear regular clothing/shoes/backpack with dumpy-looking bike. One concession is bike gloves.

Gawking at the new Schenectady train station

...has 4 comments, most recently from Walter Clark

A collection of castle day trips

...has 1 comment, most recently from Jsc

A little push up the hill

...has 2 comments, most recently from Ryan H

Today's moment of mural

...has 3 comments, most recently from Rich

A year later I'm still using a bike to get around town -- here are a few thoughts about how that's worked out

...has 13 comments, most recently from Randal Putnam