How did Ric Orlando do on Chopped champions?

ric orlando chopped

Could he avoid the "Chopped Shakespearean tragedy"?

Update: Here's the recap of the finals.
______

Local chef Ric Orlando (New World Home Cooking in Saugerties, New World Bistro Bar in Albany) was back on the Food Network show Chopped Tuesday night.

He won during his first appearance on the show -- but this time around he was up against three other champs from other episodes. The final spot in the champions' tournament -- and a shot at $50k -- was on the line.

Let's go to the play-by-play!

The basic format of this show: four chefs get a basket of mystery ingredients they must make into an appetizer in 20 minutes. At the end of the round, one of them gets chopped and the remaining chefs move on to the next round.

Contestants

Rebecca Newell: exec chef at The Beehive in Boston - "I was awesome, but I already knew that"
Mario Tolentino: chef at Juliet Supperclub in NYC
Christian Petroni: from the Bronx, it's tatooed on his lip -- chef at a restaurant group in Connecticut
Ric Orlando: "I'm old school and I rock"

Judges

Marc Murphy
Alex Guarnaschelli
Chris Santos

Appetizer basket

Basket ingredients: smoked kippers (cold smoked, need to be cooked), water chestnuts (unpeeled), leeks, lemon-lime soda

+ Ric's making fish cakes with lemon-lime soda
+ Ric says he'd like to win it for the old-school
+ Oh, no! Ric's fish cakes don't sizzle in the oil -- not hot enough, waited too long to get the pan hot -- "I'm not going to make it" -- "Come on, pan!"
+ Judges don't think he's going to make it. They're cringing.
+ Ric yells, "Come on!" Judges can't watch.
+ He waits until the last few seconds to plate the fish cakes. The last cake hits the plate at the last moment.
+ Ric voiceover: "I hope one of the other chefs made a bigger blunder."

Judging
Mario: tempura kippers with leak puree and water chestnut puree. Judges like soda tempura idea, if not execution (the batter kind of disappeared)
Rebecca: leek chestnut potato pancake with kipper sour cream. Judges say they like the idea, but execution falls short (oily pancakes).
Christian: kipper tartare. The judges are skeptical about whether it's safe to eat, because Ted mentioned the kippers had to be cooked. They say it's overwhelming as a tartare. Guarnaschelli says he closed his eyes and pretended it was something it wasn't (fresh fish).
Ric: crunchy smoked kipper cake with Vietnamese herb, apple and leek salad, with hot sweet and sour vinaigrette. -- judges note haphazard plating, note that cakes are raw in the middle, but salad and spicy dressing are delicious. Judges like the idea, just not the raw cakes (no comment from Guarnaschelli -- she was edited to look like a Ric skeptic in his first appearance).

Judges' conference
Judges talk about strength of concepts, but lack of execution. Guarnaschelli calls Ric's dish "the Chopped Shakespearean tragedy, act 1" -- weaved together ingredients seamlessly, but it simply wasn't cooked. Despite that, Murphy notes Ric's sauce is amazing.

In voice over, Ric says he hopes flavor profiles will save him.

Result: Chris and his tartare chopped. Judges say it wasn't for using the raw kippers, but the dressing, which was too salty.

Entree basket

Basket ingredients: caperberries, parsley root, chocolate hazelnut spread (it looks like Nutella), elk tenderloin

+ Ric decides to make the elk with a red wine chocolate sauce, based on dish he makes at his restaurants with venison -- goes for a bunch of spices on the tenderloin -- "Spices, baby!"
+ Ric "I want to win. Take my wife to Italy."
+ Ric voiceover: says ingredients are all there, just has to execute
+ Santos notes that Ric has waited a long time to put his grill pan on the stovetop
+ Chaos in the kitchen, chefs are dashing everywhere
+ Ric has bad flashbacks about his undercooked fishcakes
+ His potatoes aren't cooking -- so he puts them in in his "old friend, Mike" -- that would be the microwave
+ Ric says he's worried about getting the right temperature on the elk for the judges -- he likes it very rare, but he's not sure if they'll be into it
+ Mario overcooks his elk
+ Rebecca confident
+ Ric uses mashed potatoes as dam between his sauce and greens
+ Race to the finish -- Ric jokes after the deadline "Why are we doing this? Oh, right, the money."

Judging
Rebecca: hazelnut-rubbed tenderloin, caperberry pan jus, parsley root risotto. Guarnaschelli says she admires attempt at risotto. Santos says he doesn't understand why she used water for the risotto (under seasoned)
Ric: spice-rubbed elk filet mignon, with parsley root mashed potatoes, fried caper parsley salad. Guarnaschelli loves execution of elk -- "cocoa-y." Murphy loves parsley root puree. Guarnaschelli does not like caperberries. Santos says every thing else on the plate is "fantastic" -- "once again you're showing us you are a very talented cook."
Mario: pan roasted elk loin, three preparations of parsley root, hazelnut bordelaise. Judges rave about presentation and puree -- but elk is overcooked. Santos says it's "dry as a brick."

Judges' conference
Guarnaschelli: felt like championship round
Murphy says he likes the way Ric gets the flavors and goes for it.
Murphy and Santos both thought Ric had the best elk -- Guarnaschelli liked Rebecca's. Mario bricked his elk, but judges loved his parsley root.

Result: Rebecca chopped. Murphy says the risotto "backfired" -- overcooked and under seasoned.

Dessert basket

Basket ingredients: taco shells, bosc pears, crema, red curry paste

+ Ric says he's recognizes Mario's talent, but says he's "force to be reckoned with."
+ Ric says he loves red curry paste and says it's a natural with pears
+ Mario goes for the ice cream machine, even though "I've never made ice cream."
+ Ric also thinks about ice cream with crema, but sees Mario's gone for the machine
+ Ric decides on a whimsical dessert taco -- a sort of Choco Taco.
+ Ric adds crema to carmelizing pears. Says he's very confident about the way they'll taste.
+ Calling them "Ziggy Tacos and the Pear filling from Mars" -- in honor of David Bowie.
+ Ric makes chocolate sauce with red curry pears
+ Santos says Mario is like a mad scientist -- Mario uses crema to make caramel.
+ Ric gets almonds going in a pan to coat the taco shells -- but they burn while he's in the pantry. Says the end is again becoming a "fire drill"
+ Ric says he's not excited about presentation, but "knows it will be an explosion of flavor."

Judging
Ric: "Ziggy Taco and the pear filling from Mars" -- taco with bitter chocolate, pears with red curry and maple syrup. Murphy looks perplexed about how to eat it -- Ric encourages him to pick up the taco and go for it -- "there are some real bangin' flavors on there for you." Guarnaschelli says she doesn't know how he does it -- "it's really imaginitive" -- loves chocolate with cardamon. Santos says it's "strangely good" and "much better than I expected." Guarnaschelli says the cream is a little grainy.
Mario: tortilla-crusted pear with sherbet and spicy red curry caramel. Santos praises Mario for taking ice cream risk. Guarnaschelli says she doesn't like it at all -- grainy and doesn't have enough flavor. Santos doesn't like crusted pear.

Judges' conference
Judges say Mario tried to wow them with sophistication, but should simplify. Guarnaschelli says she never thought she'd like Ric's dessert, but it was great -- pears were "meaty." Guarnaschelli says she admires Ric's "insanely bold use of the spices in the chocolate"

Mario in voiceover: "I'm not going to lose to a Choco Taco. That's ridiculous."

Result: Mario chopped! Ric wins and advances to finale !

Guarnaschelli: Mario brought a lot of energy, but it didn't always translate on the plate.

Ric: "I feel like The Who at the Super Bowl -- and then they come out and it's like, wow, these guys rock."

He now advances to the finals of champions tournament, with $50k on the line.

New World Bistro Bar has advertised on AOA in the past

screengrab: Food Network

Comments

I like this write up much more than the show itself. I find the host to be tedious.

Dammit, now I want a Choco Taco.

Ric Orlando was aweful - he licked his fingers while seasoning the meat and smeared the chocolate on the taco with his fingers!!!! Besides one of the rules is to alter the ingredients - he did NOT change the taco shell at all. Chef Mario was the clear winner!!! what were the judges thinking????

Ric was very clumsy in the kitchen. He knocked over bottle of wine, constantly licked his fingers, each dish looked like a hit mess. Plus he is a chef of how many years again?!? Like a lot...so why did he forget that u must heat a pan before you can use to fry?? And why did the chocolate in his dessert seize up?? Also judging criteria is taste, presentation and creativity. Well all his presentations were ugly!! He used made a dish in entree round that he makes at his restaurant. Which is not really being creative.
Chef Mario had good taste presentation and creativity throughout. The judges told him he was too creative. What the F!?!? he was robbed! No one on the show has made ice cream!

This write up was amazing, i felt like i was watching the show, but saved almost half an hour of my life!!!!
Thanks, AOA!!!!

Way to go, Ric!! Much love aimed at you from the TV-less Rock Hill crew! Keep rocking, man! Best of luck in the final!

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

A quick recap of the week

Here are a few highlights from the past week on AOA: + We gave away tickets to Historic Albany's BUILT event by asking: If you... (more)

Coxsackie. Skaneateles. Canajoharie.

This is total linkbait, but it's funny linkbait: The real estate website Movoto asked Californians how to pronounces the names of places in upstate... (more)

Cider donut bread pudding

We saw that Deanna had made this for a party and it looked like an idea that needed to be shared. So, we asked her... (more)

Capital Region neighborhoods with the most trick-or-treaters

After a recent conversation about popular trick-or-treat neighborhoods, we were curious about which Capital Region neighborhoods have the most trick-or-treaters. And while we can't really... (more)

Stuff to do this weekend

It's Halloween. And it's the weekend, so there's plenty of stuff to do. After the jump we've assembled a bag of fun-sized treats for your... (more)

Recent Comments

... as somebody who is interested in developing downtown and possibly starting a business there, but isn't Columbia development, what message do those tax breaks send to me? The smaller players who will do the type of infill, mixed use development that we really need get discouraged when they see that only the big guys get any support from the city and that the playing field is tilted against them ...

Coxsackie. Skaneateles. Canajoharie.

...has 1 comment, most recently from KB @ Home-Baked Happiness

Cider donut bread pudding

...has 1 comment, most recently from Jeff

Capital Region neighborhoods with the most trick-or-treaters

...has 3 comments, most recently from J

Campaign Yard Sign Design Election 2014, Part I

...has 7 comments, most recently from -S

Impact Downtown Albany's vision of what the city's downtown could be

...has 12 comments, most recently from Joe A