Jump to the main section.

All of New York State's cities, lined up by size

mechanicville waterfront bridge sign

Did you know you can fit all of Mechanicville in a shoe box? (OK, that might not be technically true.)

From the Annals of Facts of Limited Utility: While editing last week's in-between places feature about Mechanicville and Stillwater, we did some research on the claim that Mechanicville in the smallest city in the state. And based on Census data about geographic size, it's true -- M'ville's land area is just .84 square miles, more than half a square mile smaller than the next city on the list.

Anyway, that got us curious about the size of cities around the state -- which are the biggest, the smallest, how big or small they are relative to each other.

So we pulled the numbers and sorted them for easy scanning. And is there a map? Oh, you know there's a map...

What is this?

It's a ranking of the geographic size of cities in New York State. The numbers are from the US Census Bureau (which lists the areas in square meters).

The rankings do not include the state's towns and villages. What's the difference between a city, town, and village? Good question. Here's a quick explanation.

Did you know: There is no minimum size -- geographic or demographic -- for a city in New York State.

New York State cities ranked by geographic size

In addition to size in square miles, we've also included size in "Albanys," "NYCs," and "Mechanicvilles" to provide some perspective. For example: about 14 cities of Albany could fit inside the area of New York City. (Or, to put it more simply: NYC is 14 times the size of Albany.)

We picked Albany because it's a place with which most people around here are familiar, and NYC and Mechanicville because they're the biggest and smallest.

Cities in the Capital Region's four core counties are marked in blue.

Map

There's a clickable map of all these cities at the top of the page -- scroll all the way up.

A few things

+ That NYC is the largest isn't a surprise. But nowhere else in the state is even close.

+ Look at Rome representing in the #2 spot. Wouldn't have expected that out of the CNY city. We would have guessed Syracuse and Utica were both bigger CNY cities than Rome. Bonus bits about Rome: It's said to be the site of the nation's first cheese factory.

+ Another surprise (for us): Saratoga Springs in the top 5, bigger than Syracuse and Albany.

+ As it turns out, the Capital District has the two smallest cities in the state -- Mechanicville and Watervliet, which is just 1.35 square miles. And Cohoes (#51) and Rensselaer (#53) are toward that end of the scale, too.

Comments

Overheard at the Census Bureau, one day last week:

Hey, all you New York State cities, listen up. I want you to line up in size order, ya' hear? Right now. Move it.

Hey you, over there in the corner. Yeah, you. What's your name? Mechanic-what? Mechanicville? OK, Mechanicville, stop goofing off and get in line. And I don't care if you're the smallest city. In line now. Hey, Mechanicville. THIS end of the line!

And you over there, big guy. What's your name? New York City? Listen here, New York: I don't want none of your lip, see? You talk back to me once, an' I'll send ya' over to New Jersey for the day. Front of the line, New York.

And what's going on over here, Saratoga Springs? Put down that racing form and get in line now. Yeah, I'm talking to you, fancy pants.

And, Oh, Albany! Stop schmoozing with New York and straighten up, now.

Albany should have annexed Renrensselaer. Troy should have annexed West Troy, Watervliet. Consolidated Services for the win.

Love the idea of Mechanicville as a unit of measure. Brilliant. Perhaps we can use it to replace hectares or something else we really don't use any more. Also love that you went to four significant digits -- I respect serious mathematical dedication to a pointless exercise!

Rome is a bit of a cheat -- it's because it includes the enormous Griffiss Air Force Base, with a runway that is more than two miles long.

How many cities did Rome have to snuggle up to to get that high up on the list?

Now I'm feeling prouder of my five mile runs around Troy. I'm seeing more of the city than I thought I was!

The reason Rome is so big in area is because of government consolidation. It has an inner city and an out city boundary, much like Saratoga Springs.
The inner city is the main part of the city where most of the residents and businesses are. The outer city is what actually was the former Town of Rome. The outer city is actually pretty much like any town in Upstate NY, farmland.

As a native "Mechanicivlllian" and "map nerd" that now resides in the NYC metro area, I can really appreciate this.

I'm sending this to all of my downstate co-workers/friends, thanks!

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Fast break

Because time lapse: Here's a video of the Times Union center changing over from hockey rink to basketball court between the Albany Devils game Saturday... (more)

The legend continues

Jimmer Fredette -- the "Loneliness Master" -- scored 73 points for the Shanghai Sharks in a double overtime loss this past weekend to the Zhejiang... (more)

518 Songfest 2017

The 518 Songfest returns to The Egg April 1. The headliner is Sawyer Fredericks, of American Idol The Voice fame. Also on the card: Girl... (more)

A front page flight

Maybe you've seen that video that's been bouncing around online today of every New York Times front page since 1852 -- in 55 seconds. There's... (more)

"The drive for citizenship and the drive for a permanent home is a pretty powerful drive"

The New York Times has a look at how refugee populations have bolstered cities along the old Erie Canal corridor in recent years, re-occupying vacant... (more)

Recent Comments

Much of Albany is still unofficially redlined. Arbor Hill, West Hill, parts of the South End in particular are. While official redlining is now illegal, prospective property buyers in, for example, Arbor Hill must deal with a lot more impediments when they seek to purchase property. Banks and insurance companies may force them to pay extra fees with extra paperwork. They may require a bigger downpayment, a higher interest rate, a higher credit score, and even additional cosigners even if the buyer has significant income. It's depressing the market in those areas significantly.

"You're saving a piece of history that cannot be remade."

...has 1 comment, most recently from jsc

The untaxed city within the city

...has 24 comments, most recently from JayK

A progressive, friendly, diverse church?

...has 3 comments, most recently from T

518 Songfest 2017

...has 1 comment, most recently from John

Examining the forces and maps that redlined the city of Albany

...has 14 comments, most recently from Justin