Tuna sandwich at Little Pecks

little pecks tuna sandwich overhead

By Deanna Fox

To relegate tuna to the lower levels of the sandwich totem is an easy thing to do: Tuna sandwiches are stinky, leaving your breath, your fingers, and the room they are made and consumed in reeking of tinned fish. More involved but less portable than the PBJ, tuna fish is a fussy sandwich that is open to endless interpretation but always requires the same level of attention. Where a PBJ can be slapped together, thrown haphazardly into a zip-top bag and shoved into a backpack, ski jacket, or lunchpail, the tuna sandwich demands gentle, precise insertion into a storage and transport vessel, constant refrigeration of some manner, and delicate nibbles to protect the integrity of assemblage.

Despite its particularities, tuna fish is sometimes an act of desperation. A can of tuna can be found in most home pantries for last-minute sandwich emergencies, and tuna or whitefish salad is often one of the cheaper options on deli menus.

Still, a good tuna fish sandwich is a thing to marvel at. The perfect mayo-to fish ratio, the inclusion of additives to the salad, the choice of bread... a good combination of those things makes all the downsides of a tuna sandwich completely worth it.

Little Pecks -- the offshoot of Peck's Arcade and Lucas Confectionery in the former The Grocery space in Troy -- takes the humble tuna sandwich and elevates it: Simple ingredients prepared in thoughtful, unexpected ways that make the eater reconsider the abilities of the item consumed. The menu listing does not allude to much more than some amalgam of fish, carrots, and celery, but the final product is certainly more than just the sum of parts.

little pecks tuna sandwich closeup

The sandwich ($10) comes open-faced on a thick slab of toasted white pullman loaf. The bread is airy with a soft crust but still has a tight weave to its crumb that gives the bread chewy texture. A base layer of silky aioli is nestled between the bread and a heaping mound of oil-packed tuna. That tuna comes in big chunks, akin to a tuna steak more than canned meat, and is mixed with large, thin, biased-cut rainbow carrots and celery that seemingly have been run through a mandoline. A half-sour dill pickle tops the sandwich, which comes with a side of spicy giardiniera-style pickled vegetables.

This certainly wasn't what I was expecting when I ordered the sandwich but I was happily surprised based on appearance alone.

General satisfaction would be the best description of my experience with the Little Pecks tuna sandwich, but for 10 bones I think the execution could have been a bit tighter. The aioli (mayonnaise) served separate from the tuna was a playful spin on the classic preparation of the sandwich, and it did seem to be placed directly on the bread to act as a layer of protection against oil from the tuna seeping into the bread. In theory, that fat layer would help the toast retain its toasted, pebbled exterior, but unfortunately there was just too much oil on the tuna to make the concept work.

The addition of carrots adds a subtle sweetness to the tuna "salad" but overall the sandwich is a little flat and lacking in the nuance that the Peck's brand (courtesy of parent company Clark House Hospitality) is known for. Pairing bites of the giardiniera with the sandwich helps.

Overall, though, the hiccups in execution do not detract from the intention presented by Little Pecks: Thoughtful interpretations of standard fare or home-cooked classics that prove gourmet does not have to be synonymous with expensive ingredients or elaborate presentations.

Little Pecks street 2016-October

A tuna fish sandwich can still harken to the sloppy version of our youth, except now you'll be eating it with a fork and knife instead of hunched over a cafeteria table. The Little Pecks menu demands you enjoy your food with intention. Maybe that's why you can't order a slice of pie until 11 am. Perhaps that's why a side of vibrant green Castelvetrano olives costs $3, likely a dollar more than it should. (Even for the best olives, that's quite a markup. The extra dollar might account for the separate pit bowl that is provided.)

And speaking of that pie ($4 per slice), pastry chef Greg Kern's deft hand with flour and butter results in a flakey dough that rivals the most perfect croissant. And a heavy addition of lemon and salt to blueberry filling makes for a not-too-sweet, crumble-topped pie that is worthy of its own Eat This edition.

Deanna Fox writes about many things, mostly about food. More can be found on her website, Twitter, or Instagram.

More Eat This:
+ Bullet latte at Kru Coffee
+ Cider donuts at Indian Ladder Farms
+ Toast menu at Superior Merchandise Co.
+ Tacos at Oaxaquena Triqui

Find It

Little Pecks
217 Broadway
Troy, NY 12180

Comments

What a review! I never feel hip enough to go in there though.

The huge chunks of carrot and celery in the photo are a total turn off for me. And it really wants some minced onion in there.

Always drain the oil in a strainer.
Mash tuna with shaved onion, add HELLMAN'S, dill weed, celery seed, parsley flakes.
Serve on toasted ,seeded rye with a Kosher, garlic , dill pickle.
A glass of chilled milk & rice pudding for desert is REL COMFORT FOOD FOR ME!

While I acknowledge that that single slice of bread probably is the equivalent of two slices of sandwich bread, it's kind of putting me off visually. It looks like too much bread, not enough tuna salad. Betcha it tastes fab though. (Love the pickled veg, one of my favorite things at the Confectionery.)

Since we're sharing tuna sandwich receipts, I'm going to invalidate any chance I ever had of being a taste maker and throw up my favorite, which was my grandmother's: tuna salad made with chopped celery and onion (optional,) lemon juice, and Miracle Whip (YEP). Serve with bread and butter chips on toasted bread. (If possible include a mug of cup o' soup, a selection of your finest supermarket tabloids, and an ice skating competition OR The Price is Right on the TV.)

Will the shark be jumped? I believe it will be, via PB&J
https://youtu.be/uqPaxsJnkT0

Let me get this straight: overcharging (for the Castelvetrano olives) is conducive to "eating with intention?" This makes me laugh. They put olives -- admittedly great olives -- in a bowl. Period. You eat them. It may be olive nirvana, but it's thanks to the buttery Castelvetrano, not the upcharge.

I am loving all the personal memories and recipes for tuna sandwiches. Keep posting them, please!

@Z -- Daniel of FUSSYlittleBLOG and Yelp fame reminds me that "open faced sandwiches" are really called tartines, so maybe it helps to think about it that way? Other term might be a "trencher."

You people are weird, obviously you need some elbow macaroni and sweet relish in your tuna salad.

But, it looks like they are trying to let the tuna "express itself" here. Like Z, I bet it's delicious, but yeah that bread looks thick. I'm not in the habit of calling anything I can't eat with my hands a sandwich.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

The Playdium redevelopment! Downtown residential! Neighborhood critics! And more exciting tales of the Albany planning board

The proposed redevelopment of the Playdium was among the projects up for review. Despite the fact that they often focus on multi-million-dollar projects that... (more)

An award-winning tale of Victorian robot sex

Check it out: Local artist/author Jess Fink won the 2017 Ignatz Award for outstanding series for her comic Chester 5000 XYV. The annual Ignatz Awards... (more)

Adult swim at Via Aquarium

This looks like it'd be a different sort of night out: Via Aquarium in Rotterdam is hosting a "Mer-Mixer" evening September 29 that "allows adults... (more)

What's up in the Neighborhood

Among the topics in this most recent spin around the Capital Region's online neighborhood: rude people, restaurants, the Pony Barn, a basket of ingredients, babysitters,... (more)

Autumn Evening in the Garden 2017

The annual Autumn Evening in the Garden event to benefit Capital Roots is September 28 from 6-9 pm at the Hilton Garden Inn in Troy.... (more)

Recent Comments

Imagine if a mixed use development - apartments, townhouses, restaurants, offices, a park - were built on the Rensselaer riverfront, and people on both sides could go to work and go out in either Albany or Renss, just by walking to a gondola station? If people had reason to traverse the Hudson - in both directions - for a reason other than commuting or getting to/from the train station, a gondola could be an awesome (and financially self-sustaining) idea, that also cuts down on the need for parking. ...

If you want to provide direct feedback on that Capital District Gondola idea, here's your chance

...has 14 comments, most recently from Al Quaglieri

Quick-scan primary election results 2017: Sheehan wins Albany Democratic mayoral primary

...has 8 comments, most recently from Pine Hills

Good open mic nights?

...has 19 comments, most recently from NEIL

Albany's mayor gets selected by just a small slice of the city's population

...has 3 comments, most recently from stan

Cereal sundae from Bumpy's Polar Freeze

...has 5 comments, most recently from ACW