Pizza dinner at Mia Lucci's

Mia Lucci's pizza

By Deanna Fox

As a lifelong pizza eater, I've come to learn there really isn't such a thing as "bad" pizza. Sure, there's pizza that doesn't quite hit the mark of great -- or even good -- pizza, but even subpar pizza is better than no pizza.

That fact became abundantly clear during the last few rounds of the Tournament of Pizza that I helped to judge. (RIP, TOP **kisses hand, points to God**.) A few slices were questionable, in the kindest terms, but I didn't flat-out refuse to scoff down any of them.

Those slices are few and far between, however: As a whole, I'd put Capital Region pizza up against pizzas from any corner of the world. We've got an amazing array of styles and varieties here. The doughy Sovrana's slices. The interesting crusts and no-Parm rule at DeFazio's. The pan-baked pub-style pizza at Kay's. The giant foldable slices from I Love NY and Paesan's. Farm-fresh sourdough pizza from 9 Miles East. (Tell me when to stop...)

If you're going to break into the pizza game 'round here, you better be darn confident in what you are offering. Sometimes that comes via the actual pizza. Other times, it's an experiential thing. Mia Lucci's in Colonie gives us a little of both.

Mia Lucci's Woodfired Pizza, on Central Avenue, takes the incorporation of "wood" to a whole new level.

If you've ever wondered what a pizzeria in the northern latitudes of Scandinavia might look like, you found it. Mia Lucci's used to be Truman's restaurant, a brick-clad building with classic striped awnings and a neon sign. Now, the building resembles a log cabin replete with a wood-carved bear next to a gas fireplace and timber decor and beams.

Huge televisions line the walls and play cable news shows, but considering the pizzeria has become a family-friendly quick-dinner option, there is little doubt that one of those TVs could switch to Nickelodeon with a gentle request.

Mia Lucci's exterior Colonie

But about the pizza...

It's good! I don't think it will win any best-of pizza lists (even though the sign says otherwise), but it's hard to beat drinks, salad, wings, and pizza (with a generous tip) for a family of four under $40.

Mia Lucci's has woodfired in the name, but it appears the oven is a hybrid that use both wood and gas, as most "woodfired" ovens in the area are. (Exceptions include Anna's or Restaurant Navona.) The crust is blistered where it ought to be, and doughy in the other places. Big bubbles of hot air and delicious, unctuous grease lay just below the surface and make for fun arguments between anxious children waiting to pop them.

Chicken spiedie pizza -- our chosen pie ($12.99 for 10") -- gives a vinegary kick that cuts through copious layers of molten cheese and classic white sauce. Buffalo wings (10 for $8.99) are standard fare, but a great example of what sticking to the basics can lead to. Roasted until tender and fried until crisp, these wings will satisfy even the most discerning Buffalo aficionado. A green salad ($6.99) is served with creamy balsamic dressing, long tendrils of shaved carrot, and extra-crunchy pre-made croutons is enough to balance out the rich meal.

Mia Lucci's Buffalo wings

The open kitchen and large take-out counter gives the dining-in customer a bit of confusion. Do we seat ourselves, pour our own drinks (a soda fountain stands on the cusp of kitchen and dining room), order at the register? Seat yourselves and a boisterous greeter will come to take your order, but don't expect him to come back too often to check in on you. Once you're there and have your food, you're on your own. Pay at the register.

Impeccable, accommodating service is not really what you are here for anyway. You are here for quick "it does the job" pizza that satisfies hectic family schedules, picky eaters, and the post-holiday calorie blow-out that you are sacrificing your diet for. Mia Lucci's likely won't become your favorite pizza joint, but I have no doubt it will be a reliable stand-by in your dinnertime rolodex.

Deanna Fox writes about many things, mostly about food. More can be found on her website, Twitter, or Instagram.

More Eat This:
+ Duck drumettes at Rascals
+ Breakfast sandwich at Gibby's Diner
+ French toast at Baking You Crazy

Find It

Mia Lucci's
1647 Central Avenue
Colonie, NY 12205


Bellini's also has a true wood oven for pizza, no gas, or anything else. Why did you guys stop doing pizza wars?

I’m surprised to see this place make the pages of AOA.
Even by your own admission, it’s simply a “does the job” pizza joint.
I’d considered writing about Mia Lucci’s after the first visit, but after a few more visits I came to agree with your assessment.
I don’t consider it worth the ink. Maybe someday.
Although the owner is passionate about pizza, they’re still a bit inexperienced.
Inexperienced in their approach to pizza, AND the service industry.
There’s plenty of great pizza in our area (and slightly beyond).
As well as, PLENTY of “Friday-night-joints”, places good enough for that quick, almost mandatory, Friday night pie.
Let’s focus on the great stuff, the mediocre will take care of itself.
- OCtG

@Nick -- thanks for that update! I didn't realize, my mistake :( Which Bellini's in particular, the one in Clifton Park? I'd love to check it out! I'm on a stupid diet (food writing, man) but should probably make it a goal for 2017 to check out other pizza joints who claim to be "wood fired," just to be sure.

@Nick: We ended the Tournament of Pizza because it felt like it had become repetitive and we figured it was better to bid if farewell before it burned out.

@OCtG -- Thanks for that note. I actually really liked the chicken spiedi pizza. We took leftovers home and I had a cold piece the next day and I think I like it even better when cold. (And in my opinion, if you are going to call a pizza good, it's gotta hold up when chilly, too.)

Out of curiosity, what are your go-to "Friday-night-joints?"

Thanks for reading!

The first time I went there, I thought a great crust was let down by a blend sauce. I've tried it again twice, and they have improved quite a bit. Maybe not yet worthy of regional renown, but certainly one of the better pizzerias between Wolf and Balltown. Hopefully, they'll keep at it and meet OCtG's standards.

Have you checked out Pizza Mare on Central Ave? It's right down the street and has been there for almost 30 years. Best quality pizza in the area IMO

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

Hello, 838

Starting today -- September 19 -- if you get a new phone number/line, it's possible it could be a number with the 838 area code.... (more)

If you want to provide direct feedback on that Capital District Gondola idea, here's your chance

The backers of the proposed aerial gondola between the Albany-Rensselaer train station and downtown Albany are surveying people this week about the idea. If you'd... (more)

Morning Blend

Rensselaer County exec election Christopher Meyer has formally conceded the Republican and Conservative primaries to Steve McLaughlin in the race for Rensselaer County exec. (Meyer... (more)

Checking in on the Tivoli Preserve Community Farm sheep

Among the newest residents of Albany's Tivoli Lake Preserve: sheep. The small flock is there now as part of the Tivoli Preserve Community Farm project.... (more)

TEDxAlbany is back in December, and the call for speakers is out

TEDxAlbany -- the local, independently-organized version of the TED talks series -- will return to Overit in Albany December 7. And the call for speakers... (more)

Recent Comments

Seems like they've put together realistic plans, though I wonder whether the proximity to the ESP ramps would be a deterrent to finding a residential developer. I'd really like to see that Trailways Building kept. We have so few century buildings in Albany that I'd really we rather keep them when we can. And this building is not at all shy about advertising its era. E-Comm 6, however...well, I won't cry if it comes down.

If you want to provide direct feedback on that Capital District Gondola idea, here's your chance

...has 1 comment, most recently from Jeff D

Quick-scan primary election results 2017: Sheehan wins Albany Democratic mayoral primary

...has 6 comments, most recently from Pine Hills

Good lawn mowing service in Albany?

...has 1 comment, most recently from Albany Landlord

The week ahead

...has 1 comment, most recently from Dan Roesser

Albany's mayor gets selected by just a small slice of the city's population

...has 1 comment, most recently from leslie