tournament of pizza 2012 bracket start

Tournament of Pizza 2012 brackets

i heart pizza

It's that time.

If the leaves are turning, and the air is crisp, it must mean that most august of traditions has returned.

That's right -- the Tournament of Pizza, sponsored by Sunmark Federal Credit Union, is back.

Lots of plotlines for this year's field: Can 5th and 50 repeat as TOP champ? Will this finally be DeFazio's year? Who are the mystery entrants in this year's field?

Here's a breakdown of this year's brackets...

sunmark pizza banner

Scroll all the way up for the brackets in graphic form. Also, here's a printable version of the brackets (pdf), if you're so inclined.

How the brackets were assembled

+ As is TOP tradition, the winner of each bracket from last year gets an automatic bid for this year's tournament.
+ Crowd voting filled another slot in each bracket.
+ The selection committee (that is, the Editors) picked a group of "tough luck" losers from previous years for inclusion in this year's field. These are shops that posted solid, even very good, scores in previous tournaments, but for whatever reason didn't win their brackets.
+ Each bracket also includes a mystery entrant, known only to the selection committee. These entrants will be revealed when/if they lose in each bracket.

Format and scoring

This year's TOP again includes pool play in the first round, not head-to-head matchups. The four pizzas in each bracket compete in the first round for two slots in the second round -- highest scoring shops advance.

About scoring this year: Pizzas will again be tasted blind (that is, the judge don't know where the pizza's from) and scored on the 100 point scale -- 100 being a pizza that achieves the highest possible score in each category: crust, sauce, toppings, overall taste. Previously this has meant that each judge was responsible for 25 of the possible 100 points for each pizza. But this year's TOP includes a panel of five judges (listed below). So each pizza's score will be its total points as a percentage of 125.


TOP2011 final judges overhead

This year's panel is an all-star lineup of previous TOP judges:

Albany Jane
The mysterious lady behind Albany Eats. She's the only judge to have participated in every TOP.

Daniel B.
You know him from the FUSSYlittleBLOG and Eat This! on AOA.

Jerry Papandrea
The one and only derryX.

Joe Esposito
Troy resident, geek, connoisseur of the slice, one of the original TOP judges. We're very happy to have him back on the panel.

Renée McAllister
Almost foodie with a remarkable memory for pizza, and one of the original TOP judges. It's great to have her back.

On with the brackets...


Returning champ: Mama Mia's
This Saratoga Springs shop posted a series of fantastic scores last year... until the semi-final, when a dud pizza at the wrong time allowed DeFazio's to coast in the final.

Crowd pick: Pope's
A longtime Saratoga favorite returns to the TOP. It lost to Nunzio's in the first round in 2010.

Tough luck: Amore
Amore occupies the location once inhabited by former bracket champ Nunzio's. And it came very close to beating Mama Mia's for a spot in the semi-finals last year, losing by just 4 points. If not for some underdone crust, it probably would have been in the semis.

Mystery entry
Hint: its crust is one of its signatures.


Returning champ: 5th and 50
This Scotia shop made a huge splash in its first TOP, winning the whole thing last year. Can it repeat?

Crowd pick: Nico's
Nico's was the runner-up in this year's Schenectady crowd voting. But the shop in first place -- Pizza King -- was not open at the time the field was set, due to the recent death of its owner, and it wasn't clear if it would be re-opening. It's almost not the TOP without the King.

Tough luck: Mario's
This Niskayuna pizza place was thisclose to advancing to the second round last year. It tied eventual tournament champ 5th and 50 in Round 1 pool play, but lost on the tie breaker.

Mystery entry
Hint: it's well known.


Returning champ: DeFazio's
You could make the case that DeFazio's has been the best performing shop in the history of the TOP. Yet it's never won the title, losing in the final the last two years. Maybe this is the year.

Crowd pick: Bacchus
This pizza place, located below Daisy Baker's in Troy, has never been in the TOP. Overwhelming crowd voting earned it a spot this year -- it got 29 percent of the vote in Troy, and more than twice the number of total votes as any other shop in all the crowd voting.

Tough luck: I Love
This shop on 4th Street in Troy has passionate fans. And it has managed to post a string of solid scores. Maybe this is the year I Love can put it all together.

Mystery entry
Hint: not your father's pizza.


Returning champ: Marisa's Place
This Guilderland shop had a good run last year -- but it just couldn't overcome 5th and 50 in the semi-final (the judges thought its topping held it back). Could be a savvy pick for this year's title.

Crowd pick: The Fountain
An old-school tavern favorite from Albany's New Scotland neighborhood. Its last appearance in the TOP -- in 2010 -- ended with a hard-fought loss to Paesan's in the first round. Maybe this is the year a tavern pizza breaks through.

Tough luck: Pizzeria Sapienza
This downtown Albany shop came up just short to Marisa's in Round 2 last year, 75-66. The match was a lot closer than it looked, though -- a point or two different in each category and Sapienza would scored a win. Let's see if it can get tasty payback.

Mystery entry
Hint: good for big appetites.


(deep breath)

Results start Tuesday. Get ready.

Many thanks to Sunmark Federal Credit Union for again sponsoring the Tournament of Pizza. Sunmark's continued support helps make the TOP possible.

Previous Tournaments of Pizza:
+ Results from Tournament of Pizza 2011
+ Results from Tournament of Pizza 2010
+ Results from Tournament of Pizza 2009
+ Results from Tournament of Pizza 2008


I'm guessing that the mystery pizza from Saratoga is from Capriccio. It's phenomenal.

The real ALbany mystery: Where is Victoria?!

I'm feeling like a loser! A hungry loser. I can't believe how many of these places I don't know. I love pizza. I guess I need to get out from under my rock and try some new pizza restaurants.

Solid field in the Troy bracket. Can't wait to find out who the mystery pizza but I can't think of a place that can hold a candle to DeFazios or Bacchus... The COB from Red Front?

Bummer, I was hoping to see how Ottimo's pizza (new) fared in the competition!!! We have used a couple Groupons there and LOVE the pizza. Wings not so much.

Where will this tournament be taking place?

HUGH fan of Bacchus (for about the last 4+ years), but i am afraid for its delicious, delicate crust being transported in cardboard and not being eaten right out of the "god's mouth" as nature intended.

the red front would be a delicious choice to add to the Troy bracket (as would Dante's or Notty Pine)

oh pizza, i love you. can't wait to see how this turns out.

I'm surprised that SoHo Pizza on Lark Street has never gotten a chance (nor has any other pizza shop around Lark). Still, good to see Sapienza carry the Downtown banner. I wonder who Albany's mystery entrant is. So is Sciortino's too new to get a look? :)

What about

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

The Scoop

Ever wish you had a smart, savvy friend with the inside line on what's happening around the Capital Region? You know, the kind of stuff that makes your life just a little bit better? Yeah, we do, too. That's why we created All Over Albany. Find out more.

Recently on All Over Albany

Thinking about affordable housing in Albany

What can the city of Albany do to encourage more affordable housing? That's the question at the center of a debate that continues to simmer... (more)

Tulip Queen finalists 2017

The list of finalists to be this year's Tulip Queen -- and to reign over this city with an iron tulip-shaped scepter -- is out.... (more)

Old trees out, new trees soon

James tagged us on Twitter today after noticing that a crew had taken down the trees in the southeast corner of the Empire State Plaza.... (more)

Talking about the fears of "bicycle face" and other preoccupations during the early history of women and bicycling

This could be interesting: The Schenectady County Historical Society is hosting a talk May 13 -- "Women on Wheels" -- by author/historian Ellen Gruber Garvey... (more)

History days at Cherry Hill and the Ten Broeck Mansion 2017

Two Albany historic mansions have annual history-themed events coming up... Albany History Fair Historic Cherry Hill in the South End is again hosting the annual... (more)

Recent Comments

I feel that when people don't confront inappropriate behavior it sends a signal that it is tolerated. I often speak up in situations like these, depending on my reading of the situation. If we consider ourselves part of a community we all have a role to play in signaling what is and isn't appropriate behavior.

Talking about the fears of "bicycle face" and other preoccupations during the early history of women and bicycling

...has 3 comments, most recently from j9

Garnet Douglass Baltimore, who was "as much of Troy as the monument"

...has 6 comments, most recently from Paula

The quintessential Capital Region food?

...has 42 comments, most recently from Lily

Morning Blend for Apr 27

...has 1 comment, most recently from Amy

The Fort Orange General Store is re-opening

...has 2 comments, most recently from Peter