TOP2011: The Semi-finals

TOP2011 semi-finals

Here we are with just four pizzerias remaining in the the 2011 Tournament of Pizza, sponsored by Sunmark Federal Credit Union. The semi-finals line up as such (bracket):

5th & 50 (Schenectady) vs. Marisa's Place (Albany)

DeFazio's (Troy) vs. Mama Mia's (Saratoga)

The pizzas for this round: sausage, peppers, and onions. We were inspired by Marino's winning pizza last year.

Let's head to the Hilton Garden Inn Albany Airport to taste some pizza!

sunmark pizza banner

A quick note about how all this works: The four judges -- Albany Jane, Daniel B, Jerry, and our guest judge -- taste the pizza blind. That is, they don't know which pizza they're tasting during judging. They taste the competitors side by side. The scoring is on a 100 point scale -- each judge represents a quarter of those possible points.

TOP2011 Semi judging

Guest judge

Our guest judge for the semi-finals is Celina Ottaway. You know her from CelinaBean, where she writes about food and people, as well as her time as a restaurant reviewer for the Times Union. Celina is a thoughtful person -- about food, about everything -- and we're delighted to have her as a judge.

5th & 50 vs. Marisa's Place

TOP2011 Semi 5th and 50 Marisas Place closeup

5th & 50 Marisa's
Crust 16 13
Sauce 13 11
Toppings 14 10
Overall taste 30 23
Totals 73 57

Post game

A convincing victory for the Scotia shop! 5th and 50 scored a win in each category, but really separated itself in the crust and toppings categories.

One judge called 5th's end crust "wonderful" and another said the crust had a "nice yeasty chew." Another noted crispness on the outside, with chewiness on the inside -- sort of like a pretzel. Marisa's crust also won praise -- the judges liked its bottom, which one described as "beautiful" and another called "charred" (charred is good -- burned is not). But its thinness couldn't stand up to the toppings -- one judge said it became "soggy" under the weight.

Speaking of the toppings... 5th's sausage was described as "crumbly and fennel-y, with a good grind." Another called it "tender and juicy," while noting "well cooked" strings of onions -- red onions, that were sliced "thin and long" and were "awesome." One judge noted that the peppers didn't have much flavor. As for Marisa's -- the judges noted its sausage was lacking fennel flavor, and "was more like breakfast sausage" (though one judge enjoyed it and praised its natural casing). The judges split on Marisa's peppers -- two called them "really good," while another found them "mushy."

It's not that Marisa's turned out a bad pie by any measure -- one judge even scored it ahead of 5th. But noted a different judge of Marisa's pizza, "a well made pie that suffers from underwhelming toppings." The judges preferred 5th, calling its pizza "delicious" and on which the "flavors came together beautifully."

So, a round of applause for Marisa's. The Guilderland spot competed well this year.

And congratulations to 5th and 50 -- they're on to the final!

DeFazio's vs. Mama Mia's

TOP2011 Semi DeFazios Mama Mias closeup

DeFazio's Mama Mia's
Crust 13 8
Sauce 15 9
Toppings 15 7
Overall taste 27 13
Totals 70 37

Post game

Here's the thing: Mama Mia's makes good pizza. We've seen it in this tournament. It averaged a 72.5 in its first two matches -- a 72.5! That's fantastic.

Mama Mia's pizza in the semi-final, however, was not fantastic. Everyone has bad days -- and unfortunately for the Saratoga shop, its bad day came at the wrong time. The judges described its crust as "uneven" and "burned in places." Its sauce tasted "like it came out of a can." And while the judges liked that Mama's used red peppers as a change-up -- its sausage flopped. Let's just say the judges weren't fans, calling it "bland."

DeFazio's posted a solid score. Of its crust, the judges said: "beautiful" (if a bit "bready"), "well seasoned," and "nom." Its sauce had a "a good concentration of tomato flavor." Its sausage had a "good course grind" with "great crust." The judges weren't big fans of the peppers, which one remarked as being "a surprising weak point." But they loved DeFazio's cheese mix, which one judge said had "a little funk in there" (funk in the good sense).

So, let's have a hand for Mama Mia's -- it burned fast and bright, and then it didn't. It's better than not showing up at all.

And congratulations to DeFazio's for advancing to the final for the second straight year. That's an impressive achievement -- whether they win it all or not.

Up next

The final: 5th & 50 vs. DeFazio's. Can the the Scotia shop win it all in its first tournament? Can DeFazio's seal the deal this year?

Results later this week.

Thank you, thank you

TOP2011 Semi judging celina

Many thanks to the Hilton Garden Inn Albany Airport for hosting us -- its location right next to ALB made it an easy spot to bring the four pizzas together. And thanks also to Celina Ottaway for guesting at the judges' table for this round.

+ Crunching the numbers on 2.5 tournaments of scores
+ Results from Round 2 in Albany
+ Results from Round 2 in Troy
+ Results from Round 2 in Schenectady
+ Results from Round 2 in Saratoga.
+ Results from Round 1 in Saratoga.
+ Results from Round 1 in Schenectady.
+ Results from Round 1 in Troy.
+ Results from Round 1 in Albany.

The 2011 Tournament of Pizza is sponsored by Sunmark Federal Credit Union, which is collecting donations for the Regional Food Bank of Northeastern New York to help Irene recovery efforts.


For the second year in a row, it's a battle between Troy and Schenectady! I'm really interested in see what pizza DeFazios puts into the final this year! To Whole Wheat crust, or to not Whole Wheat crust? Oh, the tension!

Many thanks for the close-up pictures. By sight alone, I fully concur with your findings! 5th and 50 looks to turn out a mean pie; DeFazio's is going to have their hands full this year. BTW, I'd recommend no whole-wheat this year for DeFazio's - it's what got them last year.

Say Something!

We'd really like you to take part in the conversation here at All Over Albany. But we do have a few rules here. Don't worry, they're easy. The first: be kind. The second: treat everyone else with the same respect you'd like to see in return. Cool? Great, post away. Comments are moderated so it might take a little while for your comment to show up. Thanks for being patient.

What's All Over Albany?

All Over Albany is for interested and interesting people in New York's Capital Region. In other words, it's for you. It's kind of like having a smart, savvy friend who can help you find out what's up. Oh, and our friends call us AOA.


Recently on All Over Albany

The lady in the window

We were walking by the Church of the Holy Innocents on Friday when this figure in the boarded-up window of one of the buildings behind... (more)

Gawking at the renovation of the long-vacant buildings on Broadway in Albany near the railroad overpass

The renovation of the buildings at 800-806 Broadway in Albany -- a strip of four buildings just south of the railroad overpass between downtown and... (more)

Interactive toiletry

Danny Hakim reviews the recently renovated Adelphi Hotel in downtown Saratoga Springs (starting at $384 per night) and finds a surprise in the bathroom: "There... (more)

Scanning that New York State Department of Health report that argues the case for legalizing recreational marijuana

The New York State Department of Health released its report on regulated marijuana Friday -- and it argues for legalizing recreational marijuana. Here's a chunk... (more)

Unsealed after a century

Divorce records are sealed in New York State for 100 years. And then they're open to the public. So Ken Crowe and Tim Blydenburgh of... (more)

Recent Comments

Wish they open the old McCormick road between Albany and Bethlehem for walkers and bikers so more people would have access to the trail from the Westmere, Albany, and Guilderland side.

A few more bits about the present and future of the Helderberg-Hudson Rail Trail

...has 8 comments, most recently from CB

Scanning that New York State Department of Health report that argues the case for legalizing recreational marijuana

...has 2 comments, most recently from CB

Local places to buy head scarves?

...has 1 comment, most recently from J

Checking out the new Rensselaer esplanade

...has 2 comments, most recently from Daleyplanit

There will be a film shoot in Albany next week -- and a bunch of road closures and detours

...has 5 comments, most recently from Joseph